Weekly review 24/7/11.

Not as much to report this week because much of the stuff that would have appeared has already been covered in my reaction piece to the Celtic game. What has happened though is that Filip Kiss’ season long loan move from Slovan Bratislava has been confirmed with Malky Mackay stating that the club would look to make it a permanent deal if things went well here for the Slovakian Under 21 player who has been described as a box to box player who tends to be more defensive than attacking in his outlook. Despite my earlier misgivings about personal terms being agreed, the Kenny Miller transfer has been all but completed. Miller has passed a medical, taken part in some training sessions with us and agreement has been reached on the aforementioned terms, but we have been waiting for international clearance to come through from the Turkish end since Friday – this seems odd, given that Bursaspor were talking about needing the money from selling Miller sooner rather later about ten days ago as it was required to help them pay for the replacement striker they had lined up.

It has been reported that Miller will be presented to the press tomorrow when the signing has been completed and he may well have Rudi Gestede there with him. The former Metz striker who impressed while scoring the only goal of the match with Charlton in Seville last week flew into Cardiff on Friday to complete his move following his earlier trial period  and has already had a medical – Malky Mackay was talking yesterday as if it was already a done deal. The arrival of three more players would take the number of new signings this summer up to nine, but Malky is still talking about the need for more new players and, on that score, some usually reliable “in the know” messageboard posters are saying that, contrary to what I had speculated in the post Celtic piece, the club are still pursuing Craig Bellamy as well as David Goodwillie. Our manager has spoken about us needing to stay patient about some of our targets and it may take until the end of August or even the opening of the loan transfer window in September before anything is confirmed, and, with Goodwillie’s assault case being continued into “next month” following the court hearing on Thursday, it certainly looks like it will be a while yet before his future is sorted out.

Before leaving the transfer speculation, it was reported a few days ago that City had made a bid for Nottingham Forest’s Player of the Year Luke Chambers. The centreback, who can also play at right back, has a year left on his Forest deal and had, apparently, recently been critical of the lack of new signings at the club. Certainly, Chambers would give us more pace in central defence, but he would not come cheap and so you get the impression that there may still be a fair bit left in Malky’ s transfer kitty yet even when the deal for Miller (which has been reported as costing us anything between £650,000 and £1 million) has been completed. It needs to be said though that when questioned about Chambers yesterday, our manager was keen to emphasise that the club had only made an initial enquiry about the player – if there was any more to the matter than that, then our manager wasn’t willing to talk about it. What it does tend to confirm though is that when Malky Mackay talks about us still needing defenders as well as midfield players and strikers, he means it – although some would argue we don’t need any more defenders, it looks like our manager thinks differently.

New loan signing Filip Kiss in action for Slovan Bratislava against VfB Stuttgart in a Europa League match last season.

Filip Kiss was able to get some game time in when he appeared as a second half sub in yesterday lunchtime’s 2-1 friendly defeat at AFC Bournemouth. City used the same starting line up as they had done against Celtic, but, within a minute had lost Anthony Gerrard to a head injury which saw him being replaced by Dekel Keinan. Whether this disruption was responsible for the team’s slow start I don’t know, but they were already grateful to David Marshall for not being behind when a terrific left footed strike by Scott Malone from twenty five yards put the home side ahead after just eight minutes. City created little of note for the next fifty minutes or so, but, strangely, going 2-0 down after Stuart Lovell took advantage of some hesitant defending seemed to galvanise the team and they soon reduced the arrears when Martin Taylor finished off a fluent right to left move with a low shot from fifteen yards. Peter Whittingham also hit the post with a long range effort shortly after that and there were one or two other close shaves for the home defence, but the disruption caused by the stream of substitutions made in the last half an hour meant that City’s momentum was soon lost.

While no one wants to lose matches, doing so in pre season games is hardly the end of the world. However, it was disappointing to hear how often we gave the ball away in the first half in particular and, as this happened more and more as the Celtic match went on, I think it’s fair to say that our new look midfield, which looks an improvement on last season on paper to me,  have yet to start proving that this is the case out on the pitch. With players still getting to know each other and the hope that the availability of more mobile strikers (Miller and Earnie may play some part at Yeovil on Tuesday, while Gestede is likely to feature prominently) will give them better options, there are genuine grounds to believe that things will start to improve soon – Craig Conway may be ready to have a bit of a run out at Yeovil as well.

Finally, just a quick mention about the EGM to be held on Thursday which should ratify the conversion of some of our debt into shares and give us more of an idea as to how healthy, or otherwise, the club’s finances are looking – more on that next week (I’ll not be able to make much sense of what’s going on, but, hopefully, I’ll be able to find a link to someone who can!).

Posted in Out on the pitch, Up in the Boardroom | Comments Off on Weekly review 24/7/11.

City lack Malky’s “X Factor”.

I’ve got this season ticket holder friend who is a regular in the Wales “I told you so” team and around this time for the past few years we have been having the same conversation where he says that pre season friendlies are glorified training matches which the club charge us a small fortune to watch. He has long since stopped going to such matches and tells me each year that I’m wasting my money going to watch them. He’ll be in his “I told you so” element when I see him next on Saturday and, although I’ll answer that it’s always worth going to these games to get an early look at our new players and to see City take on big teams. four “proper” pre season matches at Cardiff City Stadium since it opened without so much as a City goal to celebrate means that my protests will be half hearted ones.

Let’s face it, the punters hardly got their money’s worth last night did they and I can’t help thinking that if a Dave Jones side had played like that then many of those emphasising the positives which came out of the match would be singing a very different tune! City started brightly and could have gone ahead early on, but from around the twenty five minute mark onwards, we struggled for controlled possession and, apart from a long range effort by Joe Mason late in the first half and a possible penalty shout for a foul on the same player after the break, we never looked like scoring. Once we started to make substitutions, it soon became clear that the players coming on were, in most cases, not as good as the ones they were replacing and a second Celtic goal was always more likely than a City equaliser.

The brutal facts are that if we went into the league season with that team and turning in performances like that, then we would spend most of the campaign being concerned with what was happening at the bottom of the table rather than the top, but it needs to be said of course that there were mitigating circumstances behind what happened last night. Firstly, Malky Mackay has stated that we need more players in defence, midfield and attack. Therefore, it’s obvious that our squad is still very much at the “work in progress” stage and when you consider that we had two players (Earnie and Craig Conway) who would be in our strongest current team missing and two more (Quinn and McPhail) who would be pretty strong contenders for a starting place missing from our too small squad as well, then last night’s performance becomes more understandable. As well as this, Celtic were four days from playing their first competitive match of the campaign, whereas it was still eighteen days until we play at West Ham – Celtic wouldn’t have been so much quicker in thought and deed than us if the match had been played in a fortnight’s time.

Joe Ledley, along with Adam Matthews and Glenn Loovens, was given a good reception by City fans on his return to Cardiff.


So, I’m sure that the outlook isn’t as bleak as I painted it earlier, but, I’d still say that last night did further reinforce one aspect of the team building process that our new manager is, surely, already aware of. Malky has said that there will come a time when relying on the Bosman free or, relatively, low cost transfer market will not be enough and we will need to start exploring different options. When he was talking about Craig Bellamy recently, our new manager used the term “X Factor” to define what he could give us at Championship level – I assume what he meant was that Bellamy can give us that something special which can make the difference between taking one point or three or no points and one. Although Earnie and Conway are two players capable of making things happen, I think last night offered proof that we are in need of quite a bit more of the match winning quality that players like Bellamy could give us. On that score. Malky Mackay has said that Peter Whittingham is a very important part of his plans for next season and that soon became clear within minutes of the game starting as everything we did seem to go through him – just as against Reading in his last match at Cardiff City Stadium, I thought Whittingham was very good in the first half, before fading somewhat after the break, but he did seem to be our only real creative outlet and the only possible provider of the aforementioned X Factor.

In saying that, I don’t want to be too critical of his team mates – especially the four new signings on view last night. I thought Gunnarsson was the pick of the new players and showed up well in that initial period when we were on top and I’d say Cowie and Taylor were competent without doing anything spectacular. None of them provided much in the way of inspiration though and, although that may follow with some of them, it could well be that their strengths will lie in other facets of the game. It was much the same up front where Mason was quiet overall while showing a few nice touches (he was fighting something of a lone battle up front at times mind, given Jon Parkin’s ineffective showing) and it was here where this lack of the X Factor showed most.

It looks as if immediate steps are being taken to address this with Scotland International striker Kenny Miller, reportedly, in Cardiff to take a medical today prior to signing a contract with us (I still believe that agreeing terms with the player could be a problem mind). It had been assumed that Miller, who has won fifty five caps for his country, would be returning to Rangers after his ill fated, but highly paid, brief spell with Bursaspor, but, with the Glasgow club’s bid being well below the fee of around £800,000 that City are, seemingly, willing to pay, it looks like they may have missed out on a player who scored twenty two goals for them last season before moving to Turkey in January. It also seems certain that we will by signing Slovakian Under 21 captain Filip Kiss on a season long loan deal from Slovan Bratislava. Twenty year old Kiss is a midfield player who scored six times in twenty nine matches last season as his club performed the domestic double – little else is known about him and the only thing you’ll find on You Tube featuring  him are pictures of the Stuttgart keeper clogging him in a Europa League match!

City’s interest in Miller is being taken to mean that we are no longer after David Goodwillie by some. While I can see the logic behind that thinking, I reckon it’s more likely that Miller’s wages at Cardiff if he signed (he is reportedly on £45k a week at Bursaspor, but realises that he will have to take a significant wage cut if he is to return to the UK) would make it more likely that it will be Craig Bellamy who we will stop chasing  because we would surely be looking at a combined wage of £50k a week or more for them. Anyway, Goodwillie is due in Court today to answer an assault charge and there are still plenty who maintain that he will be signing for Cardiff as long as there is a favourable outcome to the case for him.

Posted in Out on the pitch | Comments Off on City lack Malky’s “X Factor”.