Great entertainment at Cardiff City Stadium, but it really should have been a win.

New signing Krystian Bielik should know that we’re not always this good! I’d voiced concerns after the Norwich game in midweek that we hadn’t had many on target goal attempts in our first two home games against Championship opposition and, of course, against a team that had drawn their first two games 0-0, it was 2-1 to Sheffield United after seven minutes today at Cardiff City Stadium!

The following 86 minutes produced just the one goal and at least some sense of justice was ensured when it went to City as one point was the very, very least they deserved after their second successive 2-2 draw to follow on from the 1-1 opening draw with Wrexham.

After looking somewhat soft and naive as an early 1-0 lead was turned into a 2-1 deficit within five minutes,, City had to endure an uneasy few minutes as the Blades looked to take the game out of our reach almost before it had started. However, after that,Cardiff really warmed to their task as a total of twenty eight goal attempts rained in on the visitor’s goal compared to the six we had to defend.

Once again, you can’t help thinking we’re going to be great fun to watch this season, but, to go with that, we seem to have a habit of starting games sloppily – we’ve conceded in three minutes in both of our home games and could have done so at least twice in that time at Derby.

The shame is that once we’d got past that first ten minutes or so we defended well with Bielik, after a hardly surprising rusty start, impressing with a showing full of poise which showed any one unfamiliar with his career history that he is, if anything, more of a natural midfield player than a defender.

Indeed, Bielik had three of those twenty eight goal attempts with two of them being among our ten on target efforts.

For me, City are going to win more than they lose this season if they keep on playing like that. That’s not to say we don’t still need a few more in before Tuesday night because I don’t think we have the squad depth to maintain the standard we saw today and in the first half at Derby,

City moved Joel Bagan to left back in place of Ronan Kpakio to accommodate Bielik in the only change from Derby as they took on a Sheffield United side that possess a strong looking squad,. However, after losing their parachute payments, the Blades are reduced to signing loans and free transfers in the face of a possible points deduction as a result of litigation between the previous owners and the current ones.

In light of this, three points out of a possible nine is a bit concerning with the possibility of them being lost along with a few more on top. The thing for Sheffield United, and City for that matter, is that, as I know I’ve mentioned a few times on here down the years, if you’re in a run of draws, it all depends how you end that run – a defeat means you’re a lot of games without a win, yet a three pointer means you’re on a very promising unbeaten run to start your campaign.

I could understand why the home fans were upset with inconsistent referee John Busby at the final whistle (blown before the stipulated three minutes added time I thought), but, with barely a minute on the clock, it was the visitors who were annoyed with him as he ignored claims for a foul in the middle of the pitch by Rubin Colwill as Cian Ashford freed Jack Moylan who cut in from the left and got away a shot from the edge of the penalty area that beat Martin Cooper on his near post.

The keeper may not have covered himself in glory there but he made up for that with some good saves as he kept his side ahead and then on level terms as the pressure came on them. – notably, a deflected effort by Moylan and a right footed shot from Bagan from around twenty yards out

Attention turned to the other end of the pitch almost straight after our goal though as Perry Ng gave the ball away cheaply, United broke quickly and Alex Robertson earned a booking with a pull on Tom Cannon inside the penalty area.

The lack of protests looked to confirm my impression that Mr Busby had got the decision right , albeit, it was pretty tame stuff compared to the grappling at corners and free kicks that so often goes unpunished even though there was, supposed to be a crackdown against the practice this season). Cannon went virtually down the middle with his penalty as Trott dived to his left to ensure that City’s lead had lasted barely two minutes.

A second goal for the visitors soon followed as two or three individual duels were lost by City players and Patrick Bamford fed Callum O’Hare who calmly steered his shot beyond Trott.

City’s keeper saved smartly from Cannon to prevent it being three conceded within ten or twelve minutes, but the home team took a grip on midfield from then on with the ball being moved at a pace and urgency their opponents often found hard to counter.

Moylan was particularly dangerous in the first half as he looked like a player who is settling down in new surroundings, while Robertson recovered from his shaky start to again suggest he can make a success of the number six job. Oddly, Ashford looks to have gained pace from somewhere over the summer and the move infield has added dynamism to his game. Rubin Colwill is playing with a maturity and team discipline which makes him a natural captain for this young team – I honestly can’t see how Craig Bellamy can leave him out of the Welsh squad now and he, increasingly, looks capable of playing in a deeper role which I’d say offers an easier route into the team.

Ashford’s performance, which you’d like to think also set the Wales manager thinking, got the reward it deserved as the pressure on the Sheffield defence increased after Tanner weaved past two or three opponents to get away a shot which Cooper blocked with his foot into the path of Cian who swept the rebound home from ten yards.

Tanner tested Cooper again early in the second half with the keeper grabbing hold of the ball at the second attempt as Salech waited to pounce. The striker should have won the game late on though after Ng’s twenty yarder rebounded off the crossbar. Salech took a good first touch, but, having looked to control the rebound, but instead, the ball rolled wide as the striker’s second touch proved to be much heavier than his first.

Other than that, it was hard to tell why Robertson’s offence was deemed to be worth a penalty, while United sub Rhys Norrington-Davies’ grabbing at Tanner well inside the area was not. There was also a big shout for a handball against another sub Kalvin Phillips as he blocked Robertson’s shot – it was impossible for me to tell about this one at the time, but having watched ir back once or twice now, I’d say that the ball did hit Phillips’ arm, but he had his hand tucked into his side at the time and so I’d say no penalty.

Away from the first team, there was another disappointing loss, this time by 3–1, for the under 18s in their home EPL Cup clash with Swindon Town despite scoring first through Logan Cartwright inside the first ten minutes. In mitigation, a second yellow card for Dayton Jeremy early in the second half with the score 1-1 hardly helped the cause – home defeats on successive Saturday’s to Fleetwood and now Swindon is not a good look.

In the Highadmit South Wales Alliance, Treherbert Boys and Girls club were well beaten, by 3-0, at home to Amman United in the Premier League. Ton Pentre have made a good start in the Championship with two wins – the second of which came yesterday by 2-1 at Penycraig United, but it’s three losses in three matches for Treorchy Boys and Girls Club now in Division One (East) following a 1-0 loss at home to Tongwynlais AFC.

Posted in Football in the Rhondda valleys., Out on the pitch, The kids. | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Seven decades of Cardiff City v Sheffield United matches.

Cardiff City may have killed two birds with one stone yesterday with the signing from West Brom of Polish international Krystian Bielik. Our new signing first made his reputation in this country by starring as a defensive midfielder for the likes of Derby and Birmingham, but has dropped back to play in central defence in recent years and, apparently, the plan is for him to be used as a central defender until our injury crisis in that area eases and then he will switch to playing as a number six.

So, it’s a clever signing in some ways for us and, with my memory of the early Bielik being considered one of the best midfielders in the Championship around five or six years ago, I’d definitely be claiming we’d got ourselves a tremendous signing if this was, say, the start of the 2019/20 season when he’d just signed for Derby.

Unfortunately, seven years on this is a signing which is a much more riskier one than it would have been back then and this is reflected in the price we are paying for him (something that I will come to again later). Some four months after signing for Derby, Bielik sustained an ACL injury in January 2020 which kept him out of acton until the following November, but, having regained his place in the first team, he picked up an identical injury early in 2021. Bielik returned a year to the day after this latest setback in January 2022 and scored for Derby who were now facing an inevitable relegation to the third tier following their massive points deduction.

Bielick moved to Birmingham on loan for the following season and then made the deal permanent. In three seasons at St. Andrews, Bielik was largely injury free as he clocked up around 120 first team appearances before moving to West Brom around this time last year.

Bielik’s time in a struggling Baggies team cannot be deemed a success. Having had shoulder surgery while on loan to Walsall from Arsenal early in his career, Bielik was absent for a long stretch of last season with a shoulder problem – although I must emphasise that I could not confirm whether these injuries were to the same shoulder.

Essentially, the messages I’ve seen from supporters of the clubs he played for early in his career (i.e. Derby and Birmingham) are of the good player if you can keep him fit variety, while West Brom fans seem more surprised, and delighted, by the size of the fee of £2.5 million we paid for him. They are very complimentary to their club for managing to get so much for someone who was just one year into a three year contract after they’d paid a reported £900,000 for him. However, I must admit to being baffled by what I saw in one Baggies podcast which talked about Bielik in terms of him being some washed up veteran in his mid 30s when, at 28, he is at an age where, traditionally, players are considered to be at their peak!

I should say here that there is no confirmation from City that £2.5 million is the correct fee we paid. Selling clubs have a tendency to release the maximum potential value of a deal, thereby including extra payments for all sorts of unlikely events that never end up happening and the one figure I’ve heard from the Cardiff end (albeit from a pretty unreliable podcast) is £1.5 million – it’s worth saying there that the Chat GPT report I asked for on Bielik’s signing concluded he was a good buy, but not on a three year deal (as we have done) for a fee over £2 million.

Whatever the fee we’re paying for Bielik, it’s some way short of the reported £10 million, including add ons, Derby were reported to have paid for him seven years ago and, in a market that I’d say has seen a slight rise in player valuations since then, that is suggestive of Bielik not being the player he once was even if you make an allowance for the fact that age plays a big part in these sort of things.

The fact that the last of Bielik’s eleven senior caps for Poland was won in 2023 at a time when that country is going through a decline in terms of qualification for major tournaments again suggests a player whose best days are behind him.

However, that need not mean that Bielik cannot be a success at City. For a start, you would expect his experience of this division and his general know how to be invaluable at. a club with such a young squad. Furthermore, when you consider how good I can remember him being, I feel that even with a decline from those levels, he could still be a valuable member of the squad. Given that the plan seems to be to have Bielik as the eventual replacement for Ryan Wintle, I can definitely imagine that he would be a step up from our Player of the year from last season.

That said, my final thought on this deal is that it’s hard to see, or believe, that Bielik is a player we’ve been chasing for the four months since promotion was confirmed. Therefore, while “panic buy” is putting things too strongly I believe, this does have the feel of a transfer we’ve been somewhat forced into given our problems at centreback – would Bielik have been on our radar a month ago?

Anyway, on to what is the main point of this message – the quiz! As always I’ll post the answers on the morning after match day.

60s. As a left sided central defender, you would suspect that this Yorkshireman would be much in demand today. Sheffield United were his first club and he spent a decade with them with the last seven years of it as a pretty regular member of the first team. When he moved on, it was to play for another team which played in black shorts (back then at least) and a distinctive shirt. Here he was in competition with a well established centre back pairing and so he was more of a squad player than a regular and when his side were promoted to the top flight, he decided to move to the Midlands and get a full time job. Still playing in black shorts, but with a plainer shirt, the irony was that, as a part time player, he was turning out for a side that probably got more national media coverage at that time than either of his first two teams would have done. He was part of what has to be the most famous game in this club’s history and helped to establish the team in their new, more illustrious, setting, before a move to a club which played in the same colours and also had an animal as its nickname. Can you name the player being described here?

70s. A few years before this player was turning out for Sheffield United during this decade, Tina Turner was singing about a place that was almost, but not quite, his surname. Name the player!

80s. Beginning at Sheffield United during the 80s, his stay at Cardiff crossed two different decades and he ended up managing south Wales scapegoats as well as Gwent Cuckoos – who is he?

90s. Rebel rat doubling up as England international. (4,7)

00s. This Sheffield United player from this decade was a full international who shared his name with two other players who, between them, played international football in the three preceding decades. Who are they?

10s. Signify our bills? Sounds like it anyway!

20s. Which former Sheffield United player from this decade was sent off twice within three weeks earlier this year while playing for his current club, scored for his country in the World Cup and was part of a devastating defeat this week?

Answers.

60s. Ken Mallender played for Sheffield United and Norwich before moving to the Bulls of Hereford United at a time where they creating headlines as FA Cup giant killers. Mallender was in the team for the famous win over Newcastle in 1972 and his final season at Edgar Street was played out in the Football league after Hereford’s election to that competition in the summer of 1972. After a short spell in America playing in Miami, Mallender ended his career at Teford United (the Bucks).

70s. John Cutbush (City Limits) played for Sheffield United between 1977 and 1981.

80s. Jeff Echardt played for City between 1997 and 2001 and went on to manage the Martyrs of Merthyr Tydfil and Risca United.

90s. Earl Barrett.

00s. Andy Gray the former Sky presenter won thirty caps for Scotland between 1975 and 1985. Former Palace and Spurs midfielder Andy Gray won a cap for England in 1991 and Andy Gray was a well travelled striker won two caps for Scotland in 2003 while at Bradford City, the team he played for before Sheffield United.

10s. Marcus Williams.

20s. Auston Trusty was red carded in Celtic games in January and February of this year, he scored for the USA against Turkey in the World Cup and was in the Celtic side which managed to turn a 4-0 aggregate lead after half an hour of the Second Leg of their Champions League qualifier with LASK of Austria this week into a 5-4 defeat after extra time!

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023, Out on the pitch | Tagged , | Leave a comment