Cardiff, unconvincing at either end of the pitch, face a long winter.

It’s getting beyond a joke now, For what was definitely the third game out of seven, Cardiff City were clearly the better team (we were slightly the better side against Derby and also probably worth a draw in the end against Wrexham as well) and it’s only against QPR and Portsmouth that we’ve been second best.

If football was decided by boxing style judge’s marking, I reckon we’d have eleven points now and I daresay some would say I’m being harsh there and it should be thirteen.

Yet, here we are with no wins and just four points out of a possible twenty one and I’m thinking that if we can’t beat a side as limited as the Bolton Wanderers that we’ve just lost 1-0 to, who can we beat?

Once again, I’m finding myself thinking that a neutral watching a City game for the first time.would be thinking “how on earth did they not win that?”, but, with each passing match, those who watch every game their team plays feel like answering “quite easily actually ”.

It is true that City are not getting any luck at all – little things like double connections as winger and full back challenge for a ball and whether a ball hitting a corner flag goes for a City corner or a throw in invariably go against us this season.

Another example of this is, just like with Bailey Peacock-Farrell at Blackpool on two occasions last season, a goalkeeper with a fairly dodgy reputation decides to have a blinder against us!

Gavin Bazunu was regarded as a very promising keeper three or four years ago and i’m pretty sure BBM had him on loan at Rochdale when he was their manager, but the intervening years have not been kind to him and there was plenty of criticism of him following his part in West Ham’s winning goal in midweek on his Bolton debut.

However, Bazunu was a clear winner of the Bolton man of the match today with one save to foil a close range Yousef Salech header falling into the superb category. 

It was really telling though that, when Bazunu did mess up, it only served to show one of the main reasons why City are where they are for all of the slick passing and attacking intent which makes them such an attractive watch.

Bazunu’s error came when, in attempting to play out from the back, he presented Alex Robertson with the ball about thirty yards out with no covering defender close by and a pretty simple to execute overload with City players in attacking areas if he wanted to use them. However, Robertson, who I thought was our best player on the day, took a terrible first touch which saw the ball end up some five yards or more in front of him and what should have, at the very least, been a shot on goal was snuffed out at source.

If I had to describe our attacking play in terms of finishing and the final ball this season in one word, I would say “unconvincing”. I’m labouring the point again, but the match stats 

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/live/c6y4znek19y4t#MatchStats

tell a story which is not backed up by the play of our attackers in front of goal. The stats tell the story of a team in control. A team that should be confident and assured in its attacking, but, instead, as the wait for a win goes on and on and our scorelines don’t reflect the flow of our games, the limitations of a set of players who, despite their ninety goals last season, have very few natural finishers among them become all too apparent.

When the word unconvincing can equally be applied to a defence which just cannot keep a clean sheet, then the things that we are good at become not as influential as they should be. 

Equally, a bench which includes two keepers, a sixteen year old plus a seventeen year old, correctly hints at a lack of squad depth. Of course, five established first team squad members out injured doesn’t help but, to cover old ground, it needn’t have been like that if we’d had a decent transfer window.

City went with an unchanged line up and for twenty minutes were far better than a home side that had given West Ham such a tough time of it on Tuesday. Chris Willock, Salech and Joel Colwill all had efforts kept out by Bazunu with the last save being the best of them, but in each case, that word unconvincing came to mind again in terms of our finishing.

A couple of positional switches by home manager Steve Schumacher helped nullify City’s control and Bolton had their best spell of the game for the rest of the first half as Nathan Trott made something of a meal of Ruben Rodrigues’ swerving shot. 

The biggest talking point of the half occurred when Bolton broke at speed and Kylian Dong was suddenly through on goal. Dong went down as he tried to go around Trott and I assumed the referee had blown for a penalty. Instead though, Thomas Parsons showed a yellow card to the Bolton player for simulation and, to his credit, replays proved the ref to be right.

Bolton made a couple of half time substitutions to illustrate how City were causing them problems, but after a fairly even quarter of an hour where neither side threatened much, the home team became distinctly second best again. By this time though, I had little faith in City coming up with the one goal that would surely win the game. Yet, when Willock put over his one good cross of the afternoon to find Salech ahead of his marker just five yards out, Bazunu reacted to the diving downward header with a blocking, sprawling save which stifled Cardiff celebrations everywhere.

I’ve still got mixed feelings about this miss because I didn’t think Salech did much wrong with his header, but then the logical part of me is saying a header from inside the six yard box that he could see all the way as the ball was coming to himshould have been buried.

Ng went down in the Bolton area and became the second player booked for simulation – again, replays proved the ref right. Jack Moylan had been one of our better players, but when the ball rolled Invitingly into his path about sixteen yards out, I won’t use that word again, I’ll say instead that his finish lacked authority as Bazunu made one of his easier saves.

Sub Cian Ashford (why has he been dropped from the starting eleven in our last three games during which we’ve scored once?) brought another diving save from Bazunu as that neutral watcher would have been thinking there was only one team that could win this. However, with left back Max Conway driving the home side on as he was exploiting a wilting and disappointing Ollie Tanner, Bolton roused themselves for one last effort and, just like last year, they won it with a single goal scored very late on.

Rather like against Stoke, City had defended well, Gabriel Osho, Krystian Bielik and Joel Bagan had been in charge in their individual battles and although I’m thinking Perry Ng is finding the return to the Championship a bit of a struggle, i didn’t think he played too badly today. 

Unfortunately, the passage of play which led to the goal began with a miscontrol by Osho and then the other three members of the back four were too far from the action to influence things as two subs combined with Theo Baur crossing to the far post where Thierry Gale was left in glorious isolation to head home from eight yards – what’s the word I’m looking for to describe the defending? I know, unconvincing!

Still there was time for one more Bazunu save from a well hit volley by another sub Callum Robinson, but City had to accept another poor result which wasn’t a fair reflection of the balance of play and, to be frank, it’s becoming harder and harder to feel much sympathy towards them as the attempts directed towards the centre of goal, as opposed to the corners, continue to pile up.

While the first team struggles in front of goal, the under 18s hit seven unanswered against Hull at Leckwith today, Keanu Conaty, then Jack Sykes and Leo Papirnyk with two each, Gruff Evans and Taono Nyakuhwa got the goals.

In Rhondda Valley football, Cambrian were 2-1 winners over Holywell Town in the Cymru Premier last night. This afternoon, Treherbert Boys and Girls Club were 2-1 winners at Aber Valley in the Highadmit South Wales Alliance Premier Division and Ton Pentre were beaten 1-0 at home by Dinas Powys in the Championship.

Posted in Football in the Rhondda valleys., Out on the pitch, The kids. | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Seven decades of Cardiff City v Bolton Wanderers matches.

I can remember that there were quite a few podcast discussions concerning Port Vale’s “false” position in League One through the first half of last season. Vale were bottom of the table, but opinion was that would soon change because their stats were so good.

Vale’s xg figures for goals for and against were saying they were far better than their position indicated, but they stubbornly remained in the bottom four and by the time they were beating clubs from higher divisions in their FA Cup run to the Quarterfinals, there was a grudging acceptance among the podcast pundits that Vale were going down despite what the stats were saying.

I couldn’t help thinking of Vale, who are currently bottom of League Two, when I looked at WhoScored.com’s stats which showed City top of the Championship shots at goal per game table, top of the possession table and fifth in the xg attacking table.

I was quite surprised to see us only fourteenth in the xg goals against table because I thought we’d definitely be in the bottom three. We’ve not even come close to keeping a clean sheet yet (in fact we’ve yet to get to half time without conceding in any of our eight competitive matches so far) and the number of really soft goals we’ve conceded already is a big concern.

Even our “good” figures can be taken another way. For example, only QPR have a higher negative xg v actual goals scored figure than us – we’ve scored 4.6 less goals than the analysts say we should have. Similarly, 17.3 shots per game looks less impressive when you’re only averaging 1.33 goals per game – for me, while I’d clearly prefer us to have what I’d still call impressive attacking stats, they do carry a hint of a lack of precision in terms of the final ball and finishing which I felt was an issue even while we were scoring ninety league goals last season.

Tomorrow, we travel to Bolton to play a side that have lost their last four league games and are below us in the table. While I can see us picking up a fifth draw, my lack of faith in our defending makes me think that’s the best we can hope for.

On to the quiz then, I’ll post the answers on Sunday.

60.s. With a surname indicative of something King Charles might wear, this Wigan born forward had a style which Wikipedia describes as “bustling”. Bolton were his first club, but he only played four league games, scoring once, for them and around halfway through the decade, he left to join a side thirty eight miles away. Promotion followed in his first season to a level the club could only dream of now as he provided the assist for the goal, scored by a former City player, which took them up. A regular and a crowd favourite for six seasons at his second club, he moved south to a market town preparing for it’s first season of league football and played his part in two promotions before he went Roman for a while and then he returned to his third club to finish his career off meaning that he had only played for one club which didn’t play in a combination of black and white. Who am I describing?

70s. This Liverpudlian full back spent all of his career in Lancashire with the large majority of his near four hundred league appearances coming for his first club, Bolton. A contractual dispute led to him moving on to a club that wore the same colour shirts and then there was a short time on the coast wearing yellow/amber. Name the player.

80s. Hearing aid for a fish perhaps!

90s. Northern fern spread in central area of the pitch. (3,8)

00s. Eastern European capital joins with Queen track to provide non scoring striker!

10s. He currently manages in the Premier League, played thirty five times for his country and had a spell at Bolton early in this decade. Who is he?

20s. Tardy with your duty by the sound of it!

Bolton answers

60s. Eric Redrobe joined Southport in 1966 after leaving Bolton. At the end of his first season he made the goal by George Andrews which took the Sandgrounders into the Third Division and he did enough during his time with them to win a supporters’ vote for their all time favourite player in 2007. Redrobe signed for Hereford in 1972, then on to Bath before a second spell at Edgar Street to end his career.

70s. John Ritson was part of a Third Division promotion side during his eleven years at Bolton, he later played for Bury and Southport.

80s. Mike Salmon.

90s. Per Frandsen.

00s. Riga Mustapha.

10s. Brentford Head Coach Keith Andrews.

20s. Eoin Toal.

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023, Out on the pitch | Tagged | Leave a comment