If we stay up this season I have a request regarding season tickets for 2019/20 Cardiff City home games. It’s a totally selfish request, I realise that, but after sitting through today’s 3-0 defeat at the hands of a dominant Tottenham Hotspur side, it’s one I feel I have to make.
Could a new season ticket category be introduced whereby you are buy a ticket for the thirteen games against the “rest” only, thereby ensuring that the fan buying the ticket does not have to watch the matches against the big six clubs.
I’m being facetious there, but as is quite often the case when someone uses that type of humour, there is a serious point behind it. After giving a typically flakey Arsenal side a good run for their money in a match where we competed throughout and could easily have got a draw, the subsequent home games against Manchester City, Manchester United and Tottenham have been pitiful – there is no pleasure whatsoever to be taken from seeing your side being taken apart so effortlessly and the worst thing about these thrashings is that there are no signs of any evidence to suggest that we are learning any lessons from them.
As well as our home trouncings, we have lost 4-1 at both Chelsea and Liverpool, while Spurs were pretty comfortable in beating us 1-0 at Wembley with a team missing quite a few of their first choice players.
Last time we were in this division, much was made of our win against a Manchester City side that would go on to win the title and, in many ways, it has meant that our subsequent awful record against the big six has been ignored. The truth is though that, apart from a home draw with Manchester United courtesy of a very late header by Kimbo, we were beaten in all of our other games against the big six in 13/14
Nevertheless, the signs are that the four points we gained that season are going to be a few more than we’ll manage this time around. I make it that it’s now fifteen straight defeats to the big six, with a total of forty nine goals conceded in that time.
This time around, it’s seven defeats from seven with twenty five conceded and, when you consider all of the evidence set out in those last few paragraphs, I don’t believe there can be too much argument with my contention that we are the worst team in the Premier League when it comes to matches against the top six – after all, it’s impossible for any team to have a worse record than ours!
I started by concentrating on the three most recent home matches we’ve played against the top six and I had hoped we’d seen the last of the humiliating home defeats after Manchester City’s cruise of a 5-0 win which denied us even a slight degree of hope that we could score at some time during the ninety minutes. I still believe that the defending Champions could have scored ten against us if they had needed to, but at least we kept them out for the first quarter of the game before our defensive dam burst.
For me, the most disappointing aspects of the two most recent games have been how the hopes of a sell out crowd have been deflated so early on in the game. Against Manchester United, a defensive wall which was not set up very well failed to do its job properly and our keeper could therefore only watch helplessly as Rashford’s free kick whistled in, but tonight was so much worse.
With the scoreboard clock showing something like one minute fifty seconds played, I jokingly remarked that we were going to hold out for longer than we did against Manchester United. By saying this, I accept my share of the blame for what followed in the next thirty seconds or so, but I refuse to be held solely responsible – I would say I should have three or four co defendants at least!
City were the holders of a proud record going into the game – that is that they were the only current Premier League team that Harry Kane had not scored against. Well, he has done now, but having only watched what happened just the once, I’m still not sure quite how this came about – one second Sean Morrison seemed to be on his way to clearing a cross from our left hand side and the next the ball was hitting Kane and rolling into the net.
The sense of deflation as the ball trundled gently into our net was palpable, but City responded in a fairly positive manner which helped to get the crowd going a bit. However, it didn’t take long for for Spurs, who it must be admitted played some lovely stuff in the first half an hour or so, to cut through us again before Christian Eriksen appeared to wrong foot Etheridge by giving him the ”eyes” and then rolling the ball beyond him.
Therefore, City found themselves 2-0 down with barely ten minutes played. This time though there seemed to be an appreciation from the City faithful that there was little they could do to try and transform the situation. The die had been cast and there was no way of influencing things on the pitch – the home crowd found their voices somewhat as the final whistle approached, but were generally a lot quieter than has been the norm this season.
Spurs, now doing much as they wanted, added another from Son Heung-Min before half an hour had been played and that was the end of the scoring, even though I had the feeling that, like Man City, they could have doubled their lead if there had been a reason for them to do so.
City restored a little pride by, largely through Etheridge, keeping Spurs goalless in the second half while also forcing Lloris into a save or two, but there is a reason why the details of the game are a bit vague to me – after the second goal went in, the amount of attention I gave the match declined quite markedly, I was watching it, but my mind often seemed to be elsewhere.
I wrote all of the above straight after getting home from the game before the need for sleep took over and I nodded off. Looking at it now, there are clues that I was getting very tired because it does get a bit rambling, but I’m going to keep it as it is because, having now slept on it, I still think it accurately represents my feelings when it comes to our hopeless performances against the so called top six clubs.
The way we have been opened up so easily in our last two fixtures against the league’s recognised stronger sides is an indication that our problem with them is getting worse rather than better.
We had one hundred and fourteen points to play for at the start of the season, but, based on the evidence so far, the reality may well be that the figure is actually seventy eight because there is very little to suggest that we are going to get anything from our twelve matches against the teams currently occupying the top six places in the league.
Trying to be optimistic, although they were beaten 4-1 at the Emirates yesterday, Fulham, just like Burnley at the same ground over the Christmas period, were well in the game for long periods – Arsenal are not playing well and haven’t done so for weeks, so we might possibly get a point if we go up there and play with the sort of spirit and skill we showed at Leicester especially. Manchester United on the final day of the season may offer some hope as well I suppse if we go there needing something from the match and they have nothing to play for.
Apart from those two slight possibilites, it’s hard to see where we can get anything from our five remaining matches against the top clubs, but, on the available information, I suppose we should be grateful that only two of the five games are at Cardiff City Stadium, because, contrary to the overall theme of the season so far, we seem to be better off playing the leading sides away.
Maybe, there is a bit of a feeling that we have to at least look to attack when we play at home, but only one of our four home matches with the top six so far has been remotely competitve and, with the way we went about things against the two Manchester clubs and Spurs, there has to be a chance that even Arsenal would find a visit here much easier to cope with now than they did back in September.
When you look at the sides around us, only Fulham look possible contenders for our title of worst team in the Premier League when it comes to playing the top six – Burnley gave Liverpool a very tough time of it at Turf Moor a month ago before losing narrowly, Huddersfield took Arsenal all the way at the Emirates before losing by a late goal to nil, Southampton beat Arsenal, it needed a wonder goal for Man City to beat Newcastle at the Etihad and Palace won at that ground, as well as drew at Old Trafford, recently.
Although we’re almost certainly not talking about many points, it seems to me that most of our relegation rivals can be more hopeful of getting the occasional good result against the big boys than we can. However, thankfully, there are only six of them and the signal sent out so far in our encounters with the rest of the division is that we may be able to amass enough points for survival even if we don’t get any of those thirty six points on offer againsr Liverpool, Man City and the rest.
We’ve taken eighteen out of forty two points on offer so far in our fixtures with our other thirteen opponents in the division and our largest margin of defeat in these matches has been the two goals losses at Bournemouth and West Ham. There are another thirty six points on offer against the rest before the end of the season and, if we can maintain our current results against them, then I’d say we should get another fifteen, possibly sixteen, points.
Thirty three or thirty four points might well be enough to ensure survival based on the way the season has gone so far, but it would be cutting things fine. However, I would say that there are two things which offer hope for City that our final total may be more than that.
First, contrary to what is happening when we come up against the top teams, we appear to be getting better at competing alongside the rest and so it’s a possibility that those reamining fixtures may bring more points than I have anticipated.
Second, after looking incapable of gaining points on our travels for much of the time, our last two games, especially the win against the side currently standing seventh in the table, offer the hope that we can go into the away matches we have left against sides in the relegation dogfight more confident of getting something out of them than we would have been before Christmas – again recent events and performances offer the hope that we can get to more than thirty three or thirty four points, even if we don’t get a single point against the top six.
One thing I should mention before I finish, last night was the third occasion this season that Kevin Friend has taken charge of one of our games and I sincerely hope it was the last. Although we managed to beat Fulham with him in charge (he also officiated in our first game at Bournemouth), it was despite him rather than because of him – he has given us virtually nothing in those three matches. That said, I’m sure the linseman on the Ninian Stand side of the pitch did break the monotomy of him awarding everything to our opponents by giving us the very occasional throw in decision somewhere along the way last night, but I can honestly say that this morning I cannot recall it having happened!
Mr Friend and that linesman weren’t the reason why we lost last night, but, as City are proving so well, it’s hard enough trying to get anything from games against the top sides anyway, without having officials who seem to have a default setting which always favours the Spurs’ of this world taking charge of these games.
Once again, I’ll finish with a request for support from readers by becoming my Patrons through Patreon. Full details of this scheme and the reasons why I decided to introduce it can be found here, but I should say that the feedback I have got so far has indicated a reluctance from some to use Patreon as they prefer to opt for a direct payment to me. If you are interested in becoming a patron and would prefer to make a direct contribution, please contact me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com or in the Feedback section of the blog and I will send you my bank/PayPal details.
Cheers, Paul.
I watched the full game on Sky, should have pushed the mute button, what a mess that first goal was! When the second went in I had the feeling every time that Tottingham attacked they were going to score. When Son then, luckily, managed to thread one through for the third that feeling got stronger. Luckily for us Spurs seemed happy with three.
Looking for an excuse for our lacklustre performance I could only come up with the demanding schedule. Agreed the other sides have had the same problem but with our style of play and weakness of squad perhaps we cope less well than most.
I don’t know if that early goal did the damage but we didn’t really look up for it, we just allowed them to do what they wanted with the ball. Very frustrating and if I had paid to watch the game I would be looking for at least a part-refund.
Paul, is there nobody in the younger levels of the team that could force their way into the match-day squad?
With Camarasa going off and a couple of others appearing to be having problems late on it is just as well it is FA Cup weekend.
Presumably it will be a much different side starting at Gillingham and hopefully any niggles that players have will have a chance to clear up before the Huddersfield game.
Good morning Paul – A most thoughtful summary of our current situation and analysis of our performances against the top six in this division. I listened to NW’s comments on Radio 5 live on the way home and he again complained that his defenders did not do as they were told, but would not name them. I understand that. Public criticism does nothing for morale. But for the second home game in succession, very, very poor defending has seen us behind within three minutes to wretched decision making and I just wonder where the mind set was for those responsible so early in both games. Our concessions made it somewhat easier for our opponents to control the games. NW and others have to make all concerned both more mentally and physically alert than they are currently when performing against the better teams.
There is another issue that really bothers me is that for the second game at home over the holiday period, with a full house and on TV streamed to the world, we have looked a poor side. And for all of those spectators who are not regulars, performances such as these will not encourage them to return as many were heading for the exits long before the final whistle, and that does nothing for the players, nor the image that we wish to show TV viewers. A further ‘and’ – what does it convey to potential new recruits?
These past twelve days have seen my cup emptied, filled and emptied again! Thank goodness for the FA Cup before I dress myself in various shades of blue as we confront the Terriers. Will we have additions before then, I suspect unlikely but, sadly, some are desperately needed. I think we all know where.
I’m reluctant to criticise Neil because of what he has done, and is still doing, for the Club but I have to take him to task on a few of his personnel decisions.
Firstly, we have struggled up front all season and have a full back playing there after he was jettisoned from the defensive role he had always occupied because he was allegedly suspect in that position – I doubt very much if he is as suspect defensively as Sean Morrison has been nearly all season. I’m afraid a lot of goals we concede hit the back of the net with Sean on his backside or lunging in too late. He doesn’t even seem to have the saving grace of nicking the occasional goal for us any more. Bruno is our best centre back and should play there, even if this means Lee Peltier playing right back (I remember thinking what a good signing Jazz Richards was but he simply can’t seem to stay fit).
Returning to our attacking problems, Anthony Pilkington may not be the player he was but is still probably more technically proficient than any of our other front men yet isn’t even in our 25. Similarly, Rhys Healey was prolific pre season and is still scoring regularly, albeit for MK Dons. I find it hard to believe that neither of those two wouldn’t have been a better option on times this season.
Despite my moaning, four points is still a better return than I expected over Christmas and there is definitely still a decent chance of staying up with the help of a few decent signings and selection decisions.
Paul, thanks for your summary of the game. It was a game to forget which i did. I had left the house at about 2.30pm back home 9.30pm. i am 75 years old and was knackered when i got home. A nice cup of hot chocolate and mince pie before bed was the best part of the day.
I do sit in the corporate stand and the linesman could not wait to put his flag up against us for very close offside decisions in the first half on our side .Reid was through twice, but no the flag was pointing. i thought that Mr Friend and his linesman should have wore white tops as they seemed quite intimate with the Spurs players.
Cardiff line up a bit odd paterson wing back and reid centre forward. i thought he may have tried mandine in the second half nothing to lose. never mind roll on next game
I must agree with most comments on here but to think of Healey against prem centre backs is not one. I am sure he has yet to hit double figure in league one. Also, is it Morrison at fault. I recall Hudson was disliked in his first season and I kept saying he was covering for 3 players. Left back and left side CB. Look how good he was as soon as he could rely on those around him.
Bamba was made to look a fool by Kane who dragged him out of position time after time allowing others to run into the space left by him.
Gunnerson is out of his depth, he was at fault for first goal as Kane got goal side of him creating an extra man. We needed a solid back four but we were all over the place. I sit around the 25 to 30 yard mark and I was amazed at how the back line was often mis shaped.
Just read MW comments about ref and linesmen. He was spot on, i do not recall the sissoko foul but these officials certainly favour anyone over us. I will not say big sides as Fulham are not one and Mr Friend did not send off chambers or give us a penalty. As he did not yesterday.
Rhys Healey has 9 goals and 3 assists in 20 appearances.
Thanks, Paul…it must have been so hard for you to get yourself sufficiently ‘up’ to make that report; as ever, indebted to you for the platform.
Down to earth…bump!!!
So disappointing, especially this habit of giving away dozy goals so early on.
One begins to wonder what NW puts into his pep talks.
And, I totally agree with BJA about our appearing second-rate to a world-wide audience.
Oh well, here we go again – full of hope and dreams.
Thanks Paul for such a detailed and speedy report. Not sure how you manage it straight after your drive home on a midweek night – especially when we have been well and truly spanked!
Have to agree with all comments above, but especially concerned with how we seem over-awed when playing the Big 6. NW sounded as angry as he was frustrated with the errors made and individuals not doing what they were set up to do.
In the end it felt like a nice training ground run out for Spurs as we never looked capable of mustering any kind of meaningful response.
For the first time this season the home support was muted with Spurs supporters making all the noise. And agree not a good look when so many left way before the end.
Let’s hope we get back on track against Huddersfield and other results go our way tonight!
I was supposed to be in Spain last week but a hospital diktat put a stop to that plan a day before our flight and the money paid out was non- returnable. Bad luck number one.
So we had a pleasant few days in the Seabank Hotel in Porthcawl’. Bad luck countered by good luck number one. I was considering going to the game as usual but ended up watching it on my daughter’s mobile phone. Bad luck again, or rather, a game where the Cardiff defenders were embarrassingly nervous and mistake-prone. I look forward for some good luck for the fans . Good Luck, it is said, has to be earned — and that’s the big stumbling block.
Paterson as a desperation right wing back might have worked, but as he’s in the team as the only one to attack a high ball up front, why the hell wasn’t Madine brought on to have a go at filling the void? I think there must be some kind of dispute taking place either with him and the team or with the management I hope I’m wrong but I can’t see any other reason for sticking him on the bench like a coat of paint waiting to dry.
And as for our ridiculous policy of long throw after unsuccessful long throw, I’ve come to the conclusion that the Cardiff players lack the basic skill of quick movement and ball control needed for a short and accurate throw-in to succeed. I see no other logical reason for the whole predictable rigmarole.
So, what player of manifest quality is going to come to Cardiff at the moment? Word gets around in the game and we’ll be lucky to get any new faces in, and if they do come, can we trust the judgement of the powers-that-be to lure anyone better than we already have at our disposal? Good judgement is not just for players on the pitch!
As always a big thank you to all who have replied – I have to apologise as well though I’m afraid because pressure of time means I’m unable to give your comments the replies you deserve.