A “re-branding” ten miles down the road from us.

May 17th, 2012

Tuesday’s Board meeting came and went with no announcement as to whether last week’s furore about the “re-branding” proposals had led to a watering down in terms of a new training centre, increased capacity for the stadium and the size of the budget available to Malky Mackay for team building. It seems we’ll have to wait a few days more until Datuk Chan Tien Ghee (TG) has reported back to Vincent Tan and the other Malaysian investors before there’ll be further developments in the saga that has rocked the club to it’s foundations.

Maybe that’s a bit of an over exaggeration, but there are many who will be re-assessing their relationship with the club, There’ll also be some who will be regretting things things they said and did in the past week and, in those sort of terms, I’ve not known a period like this since “Black Friday” back in 2005

As the arguments have raged on the messageboards, in the pubs and in media outlets, there have been occasions when those on both sides have used the examples of clubs who have “re-branded” in the past to support their viewpoint, but, as far as I’m aware, no one has mentioned what happened ten miles down the road from us in Newport back in the days when words like “re-branding” didn’t seem to exist.

When former City manager Jimmy Scoular took over at Newport County in that long, hot summer of 1976, he did a couple of things. Firstly, he completely revamped the County squad by bringing in a host of players who had worked under him at Cardiff. The County squad which started the 1976/77 season featured Gary Bell, Steve Derrett, Tony Villars, Brian Clark, John Parsons, Peter Morgan and had Ronnie Bird as it’s kit man – they would also be joined by Don Murray a couple of months into the campaign.

The other thing Mr Scoular did was change the team’s kit – I don’t mean a slight alteration to the sleeves, collars or cuffs here, it was just about as drastic a change as could be imagined. As far as I was aware at the time, Newport County had always played in amber (or orange) and black – the town’s rugby side were known as the “Black and Ambers” as well. However, Mr Scoular decided what was needed was a change to sky blue and white striped shirts and sky blue shorts! This link shows that I was mistaken to believe that County had always played in amber or orange, but it had been nearly forty years since neither colour featured in their kit.

I’m sure that the new kit was not welcomed by the club’s fanbase, but, I don’t seem to recall angry supporters demanding that Scottish Saltires be burnt or there being panic on the streets of Rogerstone, Spytty, Maindee, Usk side. As to the reasons for the switch to sky blue and white, well it seems there were no multinatonal conglomerates who wanted their company colours to be worn by a Fourth Division club, it was that, just like the only reason we’ve been given so far for our planned change to red shirts and the change the deeply superstitious Don Revie made at Leeds in the early sixties from blue and yellow to all white, Jimmy Scoular wanted a change of luck at Newport.

I'm sure there are other pictures of Newport County's 1976/77 kit about on the Internet somewhere, but I couldn't find them, so here's one of a County fan wearing the Argentina style shirt with a couple of dogs who will be celebrating their 40th birthdays soon.

There’s been talk of red being a “lucky” colour in the Far East to justify our proposed change of shirt colour and Leeds’ switch to white was inspired by the fantastic Real Madrid side of that time, but it seems that Mr Scoular’s attitude was more along the lines of anything but the colours Newport had worn throughout most of a history that has seen them established as one of the Football League’s perennial strugglers – given County’s permanently parlous finances, it might be that the kit, which I suppose most resembled Argentina’s, was part of a job lot going cheap!

Whatever the reason, the change of kit didn’t do Jimmy Scoular’s team any good – a woeful goals for record (they only scored thirteen times in their first twenty six league matches) soon had them clunking along in the lower levels of the league’s bottom division. Jimmy Scoular didn’t last too long – he had resigned after a defeat at Darlington in mid January which had left the side one place off the bottom. With his successor, Colin Addison, making a poor start, County were at the foot of the table five weeks later following a 4-0 thrashing at Aldershot and looking certainties to finish as one of the bottom four teams who would have to apply for re-election to the Football League in the summer.

From this point though, County’s fortunes began to slowly improve simply because they had finally began to start scoring on a consistent basis. More matches were won than lost, but they still looked to have only a very slight chance of avoiding re-election as they went into their last five matches, The fact that four of them were at home offered some hope though, and three wins on the trot saw County go into two matches against re-election certainties Workington to finish their campaign with their fate in their own hands. A 1-0 win at Workington’s Borough Park meant that, for the first time, County found themselves as favourites to escape re-election ahead of the return fixture at Somerton Park and the nerves showed in a game of a very poor quality. However, a solitary goal by striker Eddie Woods in the first half ensured that the side who had played all season in that bizarre kit had avoided having to go cap in hand to the other league clubs hoping to get enough votes to survive another season – Workington weren’t so lucky, the Cumbrian club, which was regarded as something of a footballing outpost, had played their last match in the Football League as they were voted out and replaced by Wigan Athletic.

So was Newport’s “re-branding” a success? Well, despite their great finish to the season, I’d say Newport’s change of kit could hardly be deemed a success and they were back in orange and black for the following season, but the 8,313 that crammed into Somerton Park to watch Workington’s final Football League game thirty five years ago today was their biggest for a league match in the 70′s up to that point. So, maybe, if anything can be learned from Newport’s experience in a season which ended with the Queen’s Silver Jubilee being celebrated and the Sex Pistols singing (I use that word loosely!) about her “fascist regime”, it’s that, even when a club ignores it’s heritage, people still turn up to watch them if they are winning matches.

17 May 1977

Newport County 1 Workington 0

County Macey; Derrett, Walker, Murray, Bell; Preece, Emanuel,Relish, Byrne; Woods, Clark

Workington Laisby; Leng, Johnston, Scholes, Wallace; Harris, Honour, Kisby, Wiiliamson; Ashworth, McDonald

HT 1-0

Att. 8,313

 

Share

Back to blue.

May 10th, 2012

Earlier this afternoon club Chairman Datuk Chan Tien Ghee (TG) issued this statement on the club’s official site. So, there you have it, we won’t be playing in red as our first choice kit next season. Time to start popping the Champagne corks then – not for me though thanks, because I’ve got this strong churning feeling in my stomach. I’m not certain what’s causing it, but it did come on just as I was hearing Alan Whiteley read out the fifth paragraph of TG’s statement at the meeting I attended at Cardiff City Stadium a few hours ago – anyone who feels that today’s news is a cause for celebration should have another read of that paragraph and think about it for a while.

Perhaps after they have done that they could tell me where the good news is in learning that the man who has been writing the cheques every month for the last couple of years to keep the club solvent has his spokesman saying “but the club inevitably now faces bold and real world decisions should we want to see the club survive. As romantic and simplistic a notion as it may seem, maintaining our current course without growth or change, is not, and cannot be, an option.”? Before anyone says we can go into administration if Vincent Tan is no longer prepared to bankroll us or that he won’t walk away after he has put millions of pounds into the club, let’s not forget that this is not a Langston situation where the debt is unsecured, at the moment this is a secured loan which he is entitled to in full if the club goes to the wall.

As for us popping into administration for a couple of months and then coming back after as good as new again with some other billionaire owner, well I draw your attention to this story in the local press today which talks of our £70 million debt – strikes me that any administrator might have a bit of a problem finding a buyer for a Championship (emphasis on the word “Championship”) club with debt levels like that. This is far from a day for celebrating, this is not a day for messageboard banter (I hate that word!) or triumphalism, this is a day when we should all hope that there is a way out of this mess because if there isn’t, I think the future is too awful to contemplate.

For those who are looking for some feedback from today’s meeting, it got very heated at times as the twelve people present proved that, whatever else they are, they are passionate supporters of the club. Once again, I’d like to thank the four club employees who hosted the meeting, but the lasting memory I’ll take from it was what one of them said regarding Vincent Tan’s commitment to the club. The person I’m talking about decided to stay at a less well paid job at Cardiff City after he had been accepted for a position at a Saracens RFC. I think that says all you need to know about Julian Jenkins’ commitment to the club and so, while I cannot speak for the others present, when he says that Vincent Tan has already put tens of millions into the club without getting a penny back, that he has connections with 350 shops in the Far East which could be ready to stock Cardiff City merchandise and that plans have already been drawn up for the stadium expansion and new training facilities, that an agreement with Sam Hammam was imminent regarding the Langston loan note debt and that Malky Mackay and Alan Whiteley have already been in negotiations with transfer targets, I believe him.

Kuala Lumpur - could it ever be a hot bed of Cardiff City support? After today's events we may never know the answer.

If there was any good news to come out of the meeting, then it was that the Malaysian investors had agreed to a change to incorporate a Bluebird into the badge we had been shown on Tuesday (it’s below the Dragon and motto). As I said when asked about it, for some mysterious reason, club colours, badges and Bluebirds mean little to me, so I was hardly the person they should be seeking an opinion from, but, what I could recognise is that there had been a spirit of compromise shown by the Malaysian investors.

Unfortunately though, I came out of the meeting believing that something I had been suspecting for a couple of days might well be true – there are cultural and behavioural differences between Cardiff and Kuala Lumpur that are hard to breach. On the one hand, we find it very difficult to understand something that Vincent Tan seems to believe in implicitly – that is that changing our colours to red could have transformed the club’s fortunes, but, without knowing all of his thinking on the matter, it’s impossible to be persuaded. That shouldn’t mean that his ideas should be dismissed out of hand though – speaking as someone who has spent the best part of half a century watching us cock things up and snatch defeat from the jaws of victory so often while wearing blue. maybe he has a point!

On the other hand, it would appear that the Malaysians have been genuinely upset by behaviour that we probably dismiss as ill judged, but passionate. Speaking for myself, I was surprised that they would abandon their plans as quickly as they did, but then again, I don’t understand the Malaysian psyche (very few of us do) – confrontation (which is what messageboards and social networking sites sometimes seem to thrive on most) does not sit well with them.

I’ll finish by saying something about a message I read when I got in that had been posted on one of the boards after the statement by TG which, once again, set me thinking that Malaysian values may be the right ones to follow. Now, although I probably don’t show it often enough on here, I have a stoical outlook when it comes to my team – there’s not too much that upsets me about them and I can usually find something to laugh at when it comes to all things Cardiff City. However, it was a good job that my cat was out when I saw a thread titled “The Malaysian Ownners can stick their money up their arse if money is the only motivation.” because she would have been kicked from here to kingdom come! Thankfully, I’m pretty sure that the message has now been deleted and, on the off chance that TG, Vincent Tan or any other of the Malaysian investors get to read this and saw that abomination, I can only apologise for what that moron posted. We aren’t all like that you know – perhaps a few of us should have done more to make that clear over the past few days, because I’ve a nasty feeling that the damage might already have been done.

Share