Winning start for City in New Under 21 League.

The Professional Development League – League 2 (South) is a bit of a mouthful, but one of the consequences of the reorganisation of the Academy system which saw City categorised as a grade 2 club is that their young professionals who are too old to feature for the under 18 team will be playing regular, competitive matches against similar sides from teams in the Premiership and all three Football League divisions over the course of this season. Last night saw the opening fixture for City’s development team and they picked up three good points with a 2-1 win over Brighton in front of a decent sized crowd, which looked to number 500 plus to me, at Cardiff City Stadium.

Actually, the venue for the match might have been significant, because it was interesting to read in a reaction piece to the game on Brighton’s official site that their coach felt that there was a bit of a reaction from some of his players to being asked to perform in surroundings that were far more plush than the ones they were used to playing in. Whilst that may sound like a bit of a lame excuse from a side that were beaten a lot more convincingly than the scoreline suggests, it has to be admitted that the record of City’s youngsters previously on the rare chances they have had to play at the new ground has been pretty awful, but, possibly because of the first team experience many of them have had recently (especially last week at Northampton), they responded well this time with most of them suggesting that they were not daunted by their surroundings at all – in fact they seemed to relish them.

It was obvious watching Brighton play that the intention was to get them to perform in a similar manner to the way their first team does (i.e patient, passing football with many short clearances by their keeper to their back four who would then try and connect with their midfield), but, newly appointed head coach Kevin Cooper, sent the City team out to play in a way which was, in terms of formation and tactical emphasis at least, a lot different from the way our first team plays. For example, although Nat Jarvis sometimes looked to be playing  a little deeper than his striking partner Jesse Darko, a 4-4-2 formation was definitely being used with both wide players in the midfield four being encouraged to hug the touchline as opposed to cut inside and make the pitch narrower.

For the first half in particular, this made for an entertaining spectacle with City, apart from a ten minute spell when they got pretty sloppy, in control against an opposing team which included Dennis Bergkamp’s nephew Roland in a lone striking role and Brendan Rodgers’ son Anton in midfield where he was accompanied, for the first half at least, by thirty eight year old Charlie Oatway (you are allowed to field three players over the age of 21 in these games) who is now a first team coach at Brighton.

Gethyn Hill is congratulated by Dekal Keinan (whose attitude to playing with a “bunch of kids” was exemplary) and Adedeji Oshilaja after his excellent late goal put us 2-0 up.*

In the early stages it was right winger Kevin Sainte-Luce who impressed most, especially when he got to the bye line after beating a couple of defenders and knocked over a glorious cross just waiting to be headed in by one of his colleagues. No doubt it would have been if Darko and Jarvis had been on the end of it, but the smaller Kadeem Harris had to stretch that bit to reach the ball and this resulted in him not having the control in his header to direct it in – instead it flew agonisingly wide for the player making a return after missing most of the pre season with an injury picked up at Forest Green. However, that was to be the low point of what was an encouraging hour’s work out for the winger who has played so little football since being signed from Wycombe in January.

From then on, most of City’s more dangerous moves came down their left where Harris combined very effectively with left back Declan John who got plenty of opportunities to display the dribbling and crossing skills which, before this year, had marked him out as a very promising winger himself. It was from the left that the low cross which was just missed by an onrushing Tommy O’Sullivan and then turned goalwards by Jarvis only for the effort to be blocked on the line came and a few minutes later another cross from that side was met by Jarvis at the near post as keeper East was forced into a smart save. Finally, when, with about thirty five minutes played, Harris went down under a challenge in the penalty area after another fine run, the referee pointed to the spot – a decision which looked quite a harsh one from my position about seventy or eight yards away, but the lack of Brighton protests suggested the official had got it right.

Darko, who had also fired not far wide during City’s dominant spell, confidently despatched the penalty to give City’s youngsters a half time lead they definitely deserved – if there was a criticism of them at this stage it was that they should really have been further in front. For much of a more even second half though, it looked as if that penalty would be the match winner. Apart from a fleeting chance presented to them by a poor pass by keeper Parrish and a header not too far over the bar from a corner, Brighton had not threatened at all in the first half, but, the only real concern for them after the break (until the closing stages anyway) came from from an amazing escape when they carelessly gave the ball away to Sainte-Luce whose pace took him clear of the last defender and around the keeper only for centreback Akubuine to get back and clear off the line what had appeared to be a simple tap in for the Frenchman.

The final ten minutes saw City rediscovering their attacking edge though – captain Ben Nugent nodded narrowly wide, Jarvis wasn’t far away either with a near post header and visiting sub Rae powered another fine Sainte-Luce cross on to his own crossbar, but it was just as Brighton were begining to look dangerous for about the first time in the game (Parrish saving well from a near post shot and then holding on to a close range header from the resultant corner) that City made the points safe with a superb thirty yard shot from substitute Gethyn Hill who knew exactly what he was doing as he fired over East (who was about six yards off his line) to make it 2-0. Hill then touched in a Keinan header from a corner only to be denied by a marginal offside decision (the original effort might well have been going in anyway mind) and then was only inches away from connecting with a superb Jarvis cross from the left to complete an all action end to the game for the tall striker who had scored against Brighton’s Academy team in the 2-1 defeat for the Under 18’s on the weekend. However, it was the visitors who had the last word, when their captain Barker cut in from the left and netted with a low shot which seemed to leave Parrish flat footed as he was beaten on his near post.

There was barely time to restart the game after that and the Under 21’s could reflect on a job well done in which everyone had played a part, but there were four players who stood out for me – I’ve already mentioned Harris and John (who, as well as looking good going forward coped very well in defence), but the central midfield pair of Theo Wharton and Tommy O’Sullivan both excelled – especially when you consider that they were up against a three man visiting central midfield for much of the time. Wharton gave his usual high energy display, but it was O’Sullivan who really took the eye for me with his ability to drift away from opponents when in possession marking him down as one to watch over the next few years.

* picture courtesy of http://www.cardiffcityfc.co.uk/page/Home/0,,10335,00.html

Posted in The stiffs | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Good result and performance, but 4-5-1 questions remain.

Everything I’ve heard and read about City’s 0-0 draw in front a record crowd at Brighton’s Amex Stadium last night from people who were actually there to watch it says that the team played well (certainly better than they did in beating Huddersfield on Friday). Furthermore, there’s also been testimony to the fact that City did not go away just looking for a point, but were after the win.

It’s easy to look at a record of one goal scored and none conceded in two matches and come to certain, not very complimentary, conclusions about our style of play so far, but, based on what I saw on Friday and what I’ve gathered from last night, I don’t believe it’s fair to criticise the team’s intent, which, in my opinion, has been to try and win both matches – if I have any questions for now, they would be as to whether the 4-5-1 system we are using is the best way of utilising the talent we’ve got to get those wins.

Before I go any further, I should say that I’m a fan of the 4-5-1 formation if it is flexible enough to be transformed into, say, a 4-3-3 or a 4-2-3-1 when the opportunity presents itself, but the trouble is that there is evidence so far that the problems of last season whereby we suffered because of a lack of players in our five in the middle who, by instinct and experience, thought like forwards have not disappeared yet. Too often last year, 4-5-1 was exactly that – an isolated striker with five midfield players not doing enough between them to support him. Things improved when Joe Mason was one of the five, but all that is happening so far is that Craig Bellamy has replaced him as the one in the five who could switch to a striking role and make a decent job of it.

Don Cowie turned in another hard working and pretty effective team performance last night by all accounts, but his solid virtues have not been enough to stop him becoming a bit of a target for City fans looking for the likes of Joe Mason to be included from the start. If the choice between the two was for a right sided attacking midfield role in a 4-5-1 then I’d go for Mason, but I’m not sure I would for any other midfield position.*

After watching the likes of Mutch, Gunnarsson, Conway and Ralls doing so well in getting forward to help out Helguson in the pre season friendly with Newcastle, it was disappointing to see so little happening in terms of attacking runners from midfield against Huddersfield and you didn’t have to be there at last night’s match to know that Tony Cottee was almost certainly right when he talked on Sky Sports News of Helguson winnings plenty of headers that only handed possession  back to Brighton because there was nobody close enough to him to benefit from them.

It was interesting to see that Sky had us lining up in a 4-3-3 formation before Friday’s match – although Bellamy didn’t get forward that much, you could at least understand the thinking behind him being seen as a left sided attacking midfielder with a licence to get into striking positions at times, but look at who we were supposed to have on the other flank as one of our “attacking three”! Now, Don Cowie currently seems to be something of a target for City fans in much the same way as Kevin McNaughton has become and someone like Mark Hudson or Steve McPhail has been in the past. I happen to think that Cowie does a lot of good for the team (emphasis on the word “team”) – for example, if the opposition launch a quick counter attack from one of our attacking set plays, Cowie is invariably the midfield player busting a gut to get back to, often successfully, try and cut out the danger and our full backs will always know that they’ll have someone in front of them who’ll put in a full defensive shift if he is playing on their side.

No, Cowie is a better player than his critics think he is, but, in saying that, I’ve not seen anything to suggest he’ll ever make a success of a Bellamy type winger cum striker role on the right as he was supposed to have been playing against Huddersfield if Sky are to be believed. Now, it needs to be said that if Mason is in from the start once he gets full match fitness after his pre season injury, or we sign the latest player we have been linked with, or if Kim Bo-Kyung is as attacking a midfield player as his recent goalscoring record suggests he is, then a 4-5-1 which features any two of a quartet which includes this trio and Craig Bellamy, looks like a much more exciting prospect in terms of attacking threat than our current selection does.

As things stand, the only formation I’d say our 4-5-1 could be called as an alternative is 4-1-4-1 with Peter Whittingham as the deep lying quarterback style playmaker. Apparently, Whittingham did better in that role against Brighton than he did on Friday, but questions still have to remain as to whether we can keep someone who may not think like a forward, but has the long range shooting ability, general finishing quality and footballing technique to have once been the Championship’s highest scorer in such a withdrawn role when his midfield colleagues are struggling as much as they certainly did on Friday to offer our lone striker any support.

To be fair, as I hinted above, it’s probably too early to get too critical of how we are implementing 4-5-1 this season because, by the time we next play at Cardiff City Stadium our manager may well have the sort of options which would allow him to to play with a more attacking version of the formation. The risk behind doing so of course would be that we would lose something defensively, but, for the moment, with our goalkeeper in great form and our centrebacks looking a really strong partnership at this level, we have a solidity in that area which you would like to think could absorb a change of focus to a more flexible use of what had become Malky Mackay’s default formation.

City’s newest recruit Matt Connolly in action for QPR against Wayne Rooney last season – his arrival strengthens what was our weakest area in terms of squad depth and his versatility will help greatly when injuries and suspensions start to bite.

Talking of defensive solidity, our options in that area were increased with the signing of Matt Connolly from Queens Park Rangers. Connolly, who can play anywhere along the back four, cost a reported £500,000 and has fallen out of favour at Loftus Road in the last year or so, but he started around three quarters of Rangers’ games in 2010/11 when they won the Championship and had a six match spell at Champions Reading playing at right back last season – the first five of these matches were won, but Connolly got injured in the last of them and only returned for the Royals’ final game of the campaign (a 2-0 defeat at Birmingham).

Connolly joins Heidar Helguson as a former QPR player at Cardiff and there might be another one if this story is to be believed. Tommy Smith is the player I mentioned earlier whose signing would give us more attacking options in a 4-5-1 (or any other formation we used for that matter) and he’s someone I’ve always admired as a skilful, good quality, Championship performer whose attitude always looked to be spot on. I think he would be another good signing, but, whereas it only took a few days between Connolly’s name first being hinted at as a transfer target and his arrival at Cardiff, there has been speculation going on about Smith for weeks, if not months, and I wonder if the player’s apparent reluctance to leave the London area could end up scuppering any deal?

Finally, messageboard gossip has it that Sam Hammam/Langston have turned down the club’s latest offer to settle the long running loan note debt. I have to say that if it is true that there had been an earlier verbal agreement to settle for a payment of £7 million plus £2 million on promotion, as claimed here,  then you really do have to wonder why a deal which guarantees Langston the same sum with the potential for a further 66% on top is now unacceptable. Furthermore, if Langston/Hammam are reportedly willing to settle for £10 million plus a promotion bonus of £5 million (which wasn’t mentioned when the “close friend” set out what was acceptable to our former owner), then, surely, the difference between a possible £15 million on promotion and  a possible £15 million after three seasons in the Premiership is not worth arguing about if Sam Hammam really believed all that stuff he used to tell us about how Cardiff could be one of the top teams in the country – after all, we’ve got someone at the club now with far more of the sort of financial resources to deliver three seasons of Premiership football than he ever had.

* picture courtesy of http://www.walesonline.co.uk/

Posted in Out on the pitch, Up in the Boardroom | Tagged , | Comments Off on Good result and performance, but 4-5-1 questions remain.