Kadeem Harris stakes his claim.

CoymayIt’s strange how footballers can end one season playing in a certain way, come back six weeks later after their summer break, do a bit of pre-season work and then proceed to look a far better performer when the new campaign gets under way than they did three months earlier. The transformation can be explained to some degree I suppose if the player involved is a youngster who is still growing and if they are benefiting from being a full time footballer for the first time in his life, but not all of that applies to City winger Kadeem Harris who has started this new season so well.

Last season Harris was a regular starter for the successful City Under 21 Development team and, on his day, he could be a very effective member of it as well. However, he tended to blow a bit hot and cold, his finishing was similarly erratic and he had a tendency to fade out of games if things weren’t going his way. Now, last night’s 1-0 win over Swansea City’s Under 21’s at Cardiff City Stadium was the first time I’ve seen him play this season, so I suppose it’s best not to make too many sweeping claims on the basis of one game, but he looked a completely different player from the one I’d seen in the previous eighteen months – he was probably the most effective player on the pitch.

I say that I shouldn’t make snap judgments on the basis of one match, but it does have to be said that all of the reports I’ve read him so far this season say Harris has been playing very well and what cannot be denied that he is in great goalscoring form – last night’s matchwinner was his ninth goal of the season. I’d also say that he looks stronger in the upper body this season – he’s better equipped to hold off opponents than he used to be. Maybe the growing process I referred to earlier might have something to do with this change, but I suspect it might have more to do with sessions on the weights – if he has been “bulking up”, then it’s good to see that this doesn’t appear to have had a detrimental effect on his pace.

Kadeem Harris in action in the pres season match at Barry - he scored that night as well.

Kadeem Harris in action in the pres season match at Barry – he scored that night as well.*

However, I suspect the thing which is making as big a contribution  to the difference between the 2012/13 Kadeem Harris and the 2013/14 one is that oh so vital thing for any professional sportsperson – belief. Harris looked like a confident footballer with faith in his ability to get the better of his opponent(s) – Swansea tried to double up on him at times in the second half last night.

There are still wrong decisions taken occasionally and I’d like to see more awareness of what is going on around him in terms of team mates movement off the ball, but I’d say that Harris looked like a player ready for a first team call up in next week’s League Cup tie at West Ham last night. Certainly, if you were just going by the ninety minutes against Swansea, he would be the one I would pick if the last place in the side came down to a choice between him and Craig Noone – Nooney had his moments, but it was one of those frustrating “typical winger’s” games from him where as much, if not more, didn’t work for him as did.

Based on last night, Harris’ improvement from last season has been a dramatic one, perhaps the same cannot be said of striker Rhys Healey, but I liked what I saw of him against the jacks. Going back to the youngsters growing theme, I saw little tangible evidence of that, but Healey has definitely got stronger physically. Last season he looked promising, but his slight frame meant that he was often brushed off the ball quite easily by defenders and the idea of him playing in a lone striker’s role would have been ludicrous. However, that’s what he did last night and, although, just like the rest of the team, he faded somewhat after we took the lead, he made a decent job of leading the line.

The bigger Swansea centrebacks weren’t able to dominate Healey physically and, when he got the chance, he showed a sharpness in thought and deed which went some way towards showing why his goalscoring record at this level is so good. He didn’t add to his goal tally, but it needed a desperate block by a defender to foil one surging run into the penalty area, impressive visiting goalkeeper Zabaret made a couple of good saves to deny him and there was also an overhead kick which the keeper couldn’t reach, but flew inches wide.

I’ve already mentioned Craig Noone’s contribution and of the other senior players on show I thought Jordon Mutch looked too good for this level for about an hour, but then lost a little focus for the remainder of the match. As for Simon Lappin, who filled in at centreback (I’m not aware of him ever playing in that position before in his career), he and captain Deji Oshilja did go missing on one occasion in the first half where a simple looking through ball left Rory Donnelly through on goal, but, apart from that he did well and his ability to pass the ball accurately from the back certainly helped the team. Donnelly was foiled by Simon Moore from that chance I mentioned just now and, overall, our new keeper looked clam and composed – his kicking was particularly impressive and he also made a good block in the closing seconds as the jacks strove for an equaliser. Of the other players, there wasn’t any one who had a poor match and I enjoyed the contributions of Tommy O’Sullivan with his clever passing and Theo Wharton with his good all round game.

As for the match itself, it offered good entertainment throughout. City started well and there were times in the first twenty minutes when a goal looked inevitable for them – Mutch, Healey (twice), Noone and Harris were all close to putting us ahead, but Swansea rode out the storm and had a five minute spell where they caused City all sorts of problems as Moore foiled Donnelly, winger Gorre had a goal disallowed and then nutmegged Luke Coulson before hitting the underside of the crossbar with an angled shot and, finally, it took an outstanding challenge by Oshilaja to deny Lee Lucas as he bared down on goal.

No goals for Rhys Healey last night, but an impressive all round display.

No goals for Rhys Healey last night, but an impressive all round display.

Given their strong finish to the first period, the jacks being level at the break was probably just about right, but City began the second half very strongly and, once again you had the feeling that a goal was definitely coming as Harris and Healey were denied by Zabaret, the latter went close with his overhead kick and Mutch headed on to the roof of the net and then saw his deflected effort headed off the line by Donnelly. All Swansea could offer in reply was another effort from Gorre which hit the woodwork, but, when they forced a corner after sixty three minutes they were probably thinking that, just as in the first half, they had got through a Cardiff onslaught and could now put something together themselves. Instead though, the corner was cleared to enable Coulson to go on a fifty yard run down the right as City counter attacked and his fine cross was volleyed in from about eight yards by the unmarked Harris.

As mentioned earlier, City lost their way a little after that and only looked like adding to their lead when Zabaret came a long way off his line to deny Healey, but was then helpless as Coulson floated  a forty yard lob over his head only for a defender to get back and head off the line. City’s fade out ensured that they had to endure a more nerve wracking finale than their overall performance merited, but they held on to record a victory which means that their 100% winning record at this level is still intact for the season while also maintaining the jacks 100% losing record in the league!

Finally, there’s always something you can find to moan at the club about if you want to, but they deserve credit for their decision to offer free entry to last night’s match (this resulted in what looked like a more than half full Grandstand from where I was sat) and for the way they had people coming around handing out team sheets to anyone who wanted them while the game was going on – well done to all concerned.

* picture courtesy of http://www.walesonline.co.uk/

Posted in The stiffs | Tagged , , | 4 Comments

City squad shows surprising depth as they make it three games without defeat.

CoymayTo hear Steve Bruce talking after yesterday’s 1-1 draw at the KC Stadium you’d be forgiven for thinking that it was only Hull City who had players away on international duty over the past fortnight. The Hull manager used the international break as an excuse for his side not being able to win what he had described as a “season defining” match beforehand, so you would guess from what he said that his team’s opponents had not been inconvenienced by it as much as his had.

Not a bit of it actually. This Daily Mail article isn’t wholly reliable  because it makes makes no mention of the fact that Hull’s Robbie Brady was an unused sub for the Republic of Ireland in a couple of matches during the International break, but it’s clear to see that it’s Cardiff, not Hull, who had more right to use the demands of all of that travelling and additional football as an excuse for not winning the match – in fact, even if you add on Brady’s air miles in the past fortnight, the whole Hull squad traveled less distance and only played five minutes more football than City’s Gary Medel did while representing Chile since he last played for us!

It goes further than that though, Hull had their three internationals available to start yesterday’s match – Brady came off halfway through the second half, but Figueroa and Elmohamady played the full ninety minutes, so it seems to me that any disruption caused to Hull was minimal. Compare that to Cardiff, Kimbo only lasted forty five minutes, Bellamy was absent and, while lasting the whole game, Medel probably had his least effective Cardiff match so far and that’s before we even get on to the tale of two keepers!

Peter  Whittingham and Fraizer Campbell head towards the City fans after our goal.

Peter Whittingham and Fraizer Campbell head towards the City fans after our goal.

Hull’s Alan McGregor didn’t join up with the Scotland squad because of an injury which had cleared up sufficiently for him to play yesterday and, despite what City fans sing, he really is Scotland’s number one at the moment. However, in McGregor’s absence, David Marshall had the opportunity to add another couple of international caps to his collection last week, only for a hip injury sustained in the second of them, against Macedonia, to force him off at half time and then keep him out of the match at Hull.

Marshall’s misfortune gave Joe Lewis a chance to make his Premier League debut. Now, before yesterday, I’d only seen Lewis play for us in a couple of pre-season friendlies, the FA Cup match at Macclesfield and three or four Development team games last season – not much to form an opinion on then, but more than the large majority of City fans I’d say. Based on what I’d seen, I’d rate Lewis as good as Marshall in terms of shot stopping and reflexes, but less convincing when dealing with crosses and not as good in the concentration stakes – I would have not been too surprised to have seen Simon Moore being used as Marshall’s deputy this season.

Therefore, the news that Lewis was playing did not fill me with a great deal of confidence beforehand. Fair play to him though, he did a fine job yesterday. Perhaps he could have pushed Aluko’s early shot more to the side thereby not presenting Danny Graham with the sort of chance he would have put away without a moment’s hesitation a couple of years ago, but, that’s being hyper critical really – Lewis let no one down. He was confident and decisive in his punching of crosses and, if Hull’s goal came from one of those punches being turned back into the penalty area, no blame whatsoever could be attached to the keeper who, indeed, had grounds to question the defence as to why Huddlestone’s cross was allowed to bounce in a central area not too far from goal before it was nodded in by Curtis Davies.

Marshall missed most of the 2010/11 campaign with a hip injury, so it’s a bit concerning to learn of another one he’s suffered to that part of his body. Hopefully, it won’t turn out to be as serious as the earlier one was (there’s been nothing so far to indicate that it will be), but Lewis showed yesterday that a long term injury to our first choice keeper may not be the disaster most of us would have thought it was before yesterday – I know it’s only one match, but Lewis did not look out of place at all at this level against Hull.

So, Joe Lewis put up a pretty convincing case to suggest we may not be as weak in terms of squad depth as many in the media would have you think we are. Yesterday saw a few other examples of players some supporters seem keen to write off doing their bit for the cause. For example, I get the distinct impression that I rate Don Cowie quite a bit more highly than many of our supporters do, but, that said, I had him down as a candidate to be loaned out this season – instead of that, I’d say that Malky is almost showing more faith in him at the higher level than he did in the Championship last season.

Perhaps this is because in a team environment where containment, rather than trying to force the issue, has become more important, Cowie’s more disciplined game and ability to follow the orders he is given has made him a more reliable option for our manager than, say, Craig Noone or Jordon Mutch who were both ahead of him in the midfield pecking order by the end of last season.  That’s not to say that Cowie is just a grafter who stops the opposition playing – I know it’s not going to last, but, currently Don Cowie is providing the assists for 50% of our Premier League goals! There is a serious point behind that, admittedly, none too convincing stat mind. That is that Cowie can deliver a quality cross from dead ball or open play situations. There are not many members of our squad I would have preferred to be given the chance to put in the cross which led to our goal over Cowie (wasn’t it great to see Peter Whittingham in such an advanced position to put away the chance so confidently as well)  – he’s a player who is easy to under estimate.

For a side that is regarded as set piece orientated when it comes to attacking play, we’ve scored two cracking goals so far this season – Gunnarsson’s against Man City was an example of a team patiently probing for an opening and then striking, but yesterday’s was, if anything, more impressive in my book because of how incisive it was. From captain for the day Steven Caulker bringing the ball out from the back in a manner which will make us far more of a handful for opponents if he can keep on doing it, right through to Whittingham’s volleyed finish it was a goal of Premier League class – Caulker’s pass was accurate and hit with the right pace and from there, it was just three touches and McGregor was picking the ball out of the net.

Guess which one of these two players has just scored in his first Premier League goal in nine years!*

Guess which one of these two players has just scored in his first Premier League goal in nine years!*

Cowie and Whittingham got two of those touches and it’s worth noting that Nicky Maynard, a player who might be thought of as someone whose chances of first team game time were not looking too good with the arrival of Andreas Cornelius and Peter Odemwingie, who got the third. With Rudy Gestede also seeing twenty odd minutes of action after replacing Fraizer Campbell, it was a good opportunity for what I suppose could be called unglamorous members of our squad to prove they have a part to play over the next eight months.

Kevin Theophile-Catharine was pushed straight into the starting line up in the first game we’ve played since he signed, so he doesn’t really fall into the same category, but with nobody really knowing what to expect from him, he added to the impression that we were relying a lot less on the “big name” players yesterday than usual. Based on first impressions, he looks like he will be a very good addition to the squad. Strong and quick defensively, he also showed good ability going forward and laid on a great chance for Gunnarsson just after our goal.

That scoring opportunity was one of only a few we had. Campbell and Medel both could have been in on goal with a better first touch, but it was a generally a case of the home side having the chances while we had more of the ball. Hull’s manager had more of a case when he said that his team had more openings, but this was still another impressive performance in many ways by City because of the way seeming “bit part” players rose to the occasion – it was easy to see why Malky Mackay was pleased with his side last night.

* picture courtesy of http://www.walesonline.co.uk/

Posted in Out on the pitch | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on City squad shows surprising depth as they make it three games without defeat.