Weekly review 14/7/14.

CoymayCardiff City played their first pre season matches this week. Firstly, they beat Carmarthen Town 3-0 in a game that was switched to Haverfordwest at fairly late notice and then they drew 1-1 on Saturday at Bath City. Both matches were played to a similar format with City almost completely changing their team at half time. Given the very large squad we currently have, this would appear to be a sensible policy as it gives Ole the chance to see most of the players available to him in action before we are halfway through July, but, while the theory was sound, the practice proved to be more problematic.

For example, an early injury to Craig Noone (who may require an operation which will cause him to miss the start of the season) in the Carmarthen match saw him replaced by new signing Guido Bergstaller. With Ole reluctant to give any of his outfield players more than sixty minutes playing time, the Austrian then had to be replaced for the last twenty minutes or so, but, with all of the other substitutes used, it was back up keeper Ben Wilson who had to come on and play in our midfield! On Saturday, it was Kevin Theophile-Catharine who picked up a second half knock and there was only Joe Lewis left on the bench to replace him, but, this time, Ole decided to play on with just the ten men – I suppose it gave the team some practice for a situation they are likely to encounter during the upcoming season  as the odds have to be against us having eleven players on the pitch at the end of every match we play.

City’s goals at Carmarthen were scored by Nicky Maynard and Joe Mason for the first half team, while it was Frederico Macheda who found the net after the break. At Bath, Jan Inge Berget put us ahead in the second half, but former City Academy scholar Zac Evans leveled for the home side. A draw against a team four levels below us in the English football pyramid and a so, so win over a Welsh Premier League outfit are hardly going to get the other twenty three Championship teams quaking in fear, but that’s not the point of these games – I daresay a couple of 8-0 wins would have got people sitting up and taking notice, but it’s much too early yet to start drawing any conclusions about how we are going to do based on what we see in warm up games.

Apart from a story claiming a proposed season long loan deal for Manchester United centreback Michael Keane only needs to be rubber stamped by new manager Louis Van Gaal for it to go ahead, there has been no talk of new players in the past week, but there have been a couple of departures and there’s a growing feeling that there will be a few more shortly.

It was revealed last week that Don Cowie had turned down the offer of a contract extension at Cardiff and on Thursday Wigan Athletic announced that the underrated midfield man had become the second Cardiff player to sign for Uwe Rosler’s side this summer – I wish all the best at his new club to a player who always gave his all in a City shirt. Young centre back Ben Nugent’s departure is a temporary one with his loan to Yeovil due to end on 4 January, while Ole confirmed yesterday that Kevin McNaughton will be joining Bolton on a season long loan deal shortly (this is an odd one to me, why give a new one year contract to someone who you are prepared to loan out until May?).

Apart from savings to the wage bill and possible loan fees, none of these moves will make the club much money, but it looks like some of the predicted departures of established first team players are going to be happening sooner rather than later and, it may be that these will net the club not far short of £20 million in transfer fees alone. Inter Milan have been in discussions with City regarding Gary Medel – if the reports coming out of Italy are to be believed, the two clubs are some way apart with Inter favouring a season long loan to be followed by a permanent deal if things go well, while City look for an immediate sale for a fee of around £10 million (which would be not far short of double what Inter are prepared to pay if the rumours are to be believed).

With Olympique Marseille also joining in the chase for the Chilean international apparently, City’s chance of getting the sort of fee they are holding out for appear to be better than they looked a few days ago – certainly, if we could get an eight figure sum for Medel, then the new Committee structure which oversees transfer in and out of the club could legitimately claim kudos for delivering such  a deal.

In the case of Steven Caulker, the fee has been set at more or less what we paid for him and it looks as if a few clubs have been prepared to match the release clause figure in his contract. So, it’s widely reported that we should be getting £8 million for the centreback, but the question is who from? For a fortnight or so, it looked pretty certain that QPR would be securing Caulker’s services, but, after stories that the player was holding out for a move to Liverpool (negotiations with the Anfield club were reported to have stalled originally over the player’s wage demands), it’s now claimed that he is signing for Crystal Palace.

Excessive wage demands are almost certainly the reason why Leicester City pulled out of their move for Fraizer Campbell and, for a short while, the possibility of the striker starting the season at Cardiff was being entertained, but Palace are, seemingly, also in for Campbell and so it looks like Tony Pulis will be looking to extend his record of never being relegated as a manager with two members of the team that finished bottom of last season’s Premier League in his squad.

The moment that won the World Cup. Mario Goetze's fine finish puts Germany into the lead - perhaps their win over Argentina was a little lucky, but, overall, the first European side to win a World Cup held in South America were worthy winners of a fine competition.

The moment that won the World Cup. Mario Goetze’s fine finish puts Germany into the lead – perhaps their win over Argentina was a little lucky, but, overall, the first European side to win a World Cup held in South America were worthy winners of a fine competition.

Just to finish with a few paragraphs about the World Cup. My belief that Brazil would win the tournament because their superb home record would be too much of an obstacle for anyone to overcome, was spectacularly blown  out of the water in just about the most incredible game I’ve ever seen. If ever there was a side that would not be intimidated by playing the most successful team in World Cup history in their own backyard, it would be Germany and, with Brazil’s two most influential players absent, I did concede there was a possibility that I might be proved wrong, but, if Germany were to win then I could only see it being by a single goal or on penalties. Instead, we witnessed a massacre – the writing was on the wall for Brazil in the time after they went 1-0 down as their opponents kept on opening them up so easily and once the second one went in, the game resembled a practice match with four of the goals being tap ins as a rudderless home team simply imploded.

Brazil’s feeble performance in losing 3-0 to the Netherlands in the Third Place match on Saturday night showed that the wounds from four days earlier were still open and the devastating and humiliating nature of the loss to Germany means that I wouldn’t be surprised if the Brazil team is still bleeding for decades to come. In fact, in a nation which places so much store in football, I feel that the psyche of the country as a whole could be seriously affected for years to come – in sporting terms the only thing I can think of which might influence a country’s morale as much as Brazil 1 Germany 7 is if the All Blacks had been beaten something like 70-10 by France in the 2011 World Cup Final and, even then, I’m not sure the hurt would go so deep.

So were Brazil very bad or were Germany just brilliant? Well, the evidence of last night’s Final suggests to me that it was more the first option than the second one. Although Germany finished the ninety minutes the stronger and looked the better team in extra time, I thought their 1-0 win over Argentina flattered them, because it was the South Americans who created, and wasted, the better chances. Leaving the Brazil game to one side, Germany’s 4-0 dismantling of Portugal in their opening match marked them down as potential winners and I believe that, overall, they were the strongest team in the competition, but, for me, Argentina raised their game in the Final in every department, except for finishing.

With the winning goal coming deep into extra time just as everyone was thinking that  a penalty shoot out was inevitable, I suppose it could be claimed that the Final was similar to the one four years earlier in South Africa, but that apart, there was little common ground between the two matches. In  2010, one of the sides involved seemed more interested in kicking lumps out of their opponents than trying to win the game, whereas last night you got the impression that both sides wanted to win the game by going for goals throughout. True, Argentina were content to play a counter attacking game, but the speed and purpose they showed when they did break forward offered all the proof you needed that their outlook was far from a defensive one.

By offering a much more watchable final than many in recent memory, Brazil 2014 confirmed that it was the best of the modern day World Cup tournaments. However, for me, although Germany came close at times, it didn’t have the outstanding team or classic Final to put it above 1970 and Lionel Messi’s failure to really impose himself on the competition meant that it also didn’t have the brilliant individual that lit up the 1986 tournament (the Final that year was a real thriller as well). So, 1970 and 1986 remain the two best Worlds Cups I’ve seen, but 2014 is there in third place because, by and large, it was full of positive football, had one or two truly amazing matches and had a verve and a colour that was not totally down to it’s brilliant setting.

Posted in Out on the pitch | Tagged , | 5 Comments

Weekly review 6/7/14

CoymayI’ve always thought that the new football season is not too far away once Wimbledon is over and done with. I’ve watched more of the tennis than normal this year and enjoyed the actual games, but have had more than enough of all the bollox spouted by the commentators about “body language” and the endless banal shots of each player’s “entourage” celebrating every point he or she wins. It seems almost compulsory that points won have to be followed by mad fist pumping and shouts of “come on” and I hope so much that virtually the only player who does not follow these guidelines and just gets on with playing the game ends up winning the title – I’d want Roger Federer to win anyway because he is such a great player to watch, but a victory for him would be a shot in the arm for those who just get on with playing the game.

Anyway, the last day of Wimbledon and the news that many clubs (including City) have started their pre-season training means that the big kick off is getting pretty close. The early part of the training routine varies little from club to club with an emphasis on physical work and a series of tests to monitor general levels of fitness – on that score, I hope there is no truth in the story I was told last night that three City players failed their tests because they had not met the standards set for them as far as keeping fit during their time off was concerned. If it is true, then it goes straight to the heart of why I’m not as convinced as some seem to be that we can go straight back up (stuff like this does nobody any favours in my opinion) – in a league where team spirit and discipline counts for so much, having players who return to training out of shape is a bad sign and I just hope that, if some of ours did this, they are among the ones that will be leaving the club in the coming weeks.

Ole is following the route that Lennie Lawrence, Dave Jones and Malky Mackay went down by visiting mainland Europe as part of the build up for the new campaign, but, whereas last year Mackay preferred not to play any games on the first team squads pre-season trip, Ole is following a more conventional route in that there will be three matches for the team during the week they spend in Austria from July 17 to 24th. Indeed, it appears our manager wants as many pre season matches as possible and I must say, given a choice between last year’s approach and the one we have adopted this year, I prefer the option Ole is taking.

City’s pre-season programme reads as follows;-

July 7, Carmarthen A (confusingly, this match is being played at Haverfordwest)

July 12, Bath A (this replaces the game originally planned for Hereford)

July 19, TSV 1860 Munich and KS Teuta Durrës A- the game against the German team beaten by West Ham in the 1965 European Cup Winners Cup Final kicking off at 4pm, followed by the match with the Albanians two and a half hours later.

July 22, FK Amkar Perm A – they play in the Russian Premier League and will probably be the toughest opponents we face in Austria.

July 27, Yeovil A

July 29, Chasetown H – pretty sure this is a Development team game

August 2, VFL Wolfsburg H

USA centreback Matt Besler is, apparently, one of the players City are looking at to replace Sreven Caulker whose departure is now looking  inevitable following the acceptance of a recent bid by QPR.

USA centreback Matt Besler is, apparently, one of the players City are looking at to replace Steven Caulker, whose departure is now looking inevitable following the acceptance of a recent bid by QPR.

On the transfer front, a bid from QPR which matches the player’s relegation release clause fee has been accepted for Steven Caulker – there is also reported interest from Southampton in our captain . Gary Medel has indicated that he would be open to a move to Italy amid reports that Inter Milan are preparing a bid, while, disturbingly in my view, there has been talk of City being willing to accept a fee of £5 million for Jordon Mutch in the light of Sunderland’s renewed interest in the midfielder (it’s reported that they have had a £3.5 million bid rejected). One move that doesn’t seem to be going ahead now is Fraizer Campbell’s to Leicester – the newly promoted Foxes have a wage policy that they are determined to stick to and it seems our striker’s demands are not acceptable to them. Finally, Bolton and Reading are, apparently, interested in one of City’s forgotten men, Joe Mason, with the latter thought to be favourites to get him  if we decide to sell.

As for players coming in. Southampton have seemingly turned down a £3 million bid from us for their Portugese centreback Jose Fonte. The 30 year old was a regular starter last season for an impressive Southampton side which is in the process of being dismantled with Lallana, Shaw and Lambert all sold already and reported interest in some of their other key performers, so their reluctance to let the reliable Fonte go is understandable and I tend to believe there would be Premier League interest in the player if the Saints did decide they would sell. Another name I’ve seen linked with us is Matt Besler who did a fine job for the USA team which won a lot of friends with their showing in the World Cup, with their 2-1 last 16 defeat by Belgium being one of the matches of the tournament so far.

Sadly, but predictably, the World Cup is getting less entertaining as the tournament goes on and the stakes get higher, but it retains it’s capacity to be eminently watchable. For example, a pretty turgid set of Quarter Finals were rescued to some degree last night by the Costa Rica v Netherlands encounter in which a mediocre and goalless eighty minutes was followed by ten minutes of siege on the Costa Rican goal as the Dutch did everything but score and then an amazing extra time  period which ended with both teams going hell for leather for the goal which would end the need for a penalty shoot out. In the event, it was Newcastle’s Tim Krul, who was brought on just for the penalties, who was the hero with a couple of saves, to take his side into the last four.

The Netherlands will face Argentina on Wednesday after hosts Brazil have taken on Germany twenty four hours earlier, so earlier stories about South American dominance at the expense of Europe have proved not to be the case. That said, my prediction is for an all South American final, but I say that while believing that one of the main reasons why the 2014 World Cup has been an enjoyable one is that there is no outstanding team in it. I think this competition has been a little like the Championship in that you almost get the feeling that any one team in it is capable of beating any other. It’s the old argument as to whether having one outstanding team in it makes a competition strong and does a tournament where all the sides are pretty evenly matched make it a weak one?

I’m not sure if there is a right or wrong answer to those questions, but would always prefer to watch something where the winner is hard to predict. As for a winner this time, I’m sticking with Brazil – like every side left, they have their weaknesses and losing Neymar makes their task harder, but I still feel that none of the other three sides left are good enough to overcome the huge advantage the hosts have in terms of support and their incredible record in competitive matches played in their own country.

Posted in Out on the pitch | 5 Comments