Seven decades of Cardiff City v Huddersfield Town matches.

Luton Town (the team many, including myself, think should not have been reinstated to the competition after they had been beaten by a Swindon team fielding an ineligible player) came from behind to beat Stockport County 3-1 in the whatever its called Cup Final at Wembley yesterday.

This means that the Bedfordshire Hatters have a trophy to, perhaps, rescue what’s been a very disappointing league season for the team that was most pundits’ choice to be Champions of League One before a ball is kicked. That being said, Luton are in maybe their best form of the season currently and so there is still the possibility I suppose that the six point gap to Stockport and Stevenage in the last two of the Play Off places can be bridged in their last five matches. If that was to happen, there’d be many fancying them to become the third promotion team.

Given that the club that I reckon was picked as potential Champions most by those who didn’t fancy Luton winning the title, Huddersfield Town, have a point more than Luton with four matches left for them to play, their promotion hopes aren’t gone yet either. However, with us to be faced tomorrow, followed by a trip to Bolton on Saturday, their prospects don’t look that great – they’re in a position where even four four wins would still leave them needing a pretty big collapse by one of the four sides currently in third to sixth positions in their remaining matches.

Huddersfield have to be the League One team to have spent the most in the last two seasons (I mean sides like Birmingham, Wrexham and Luton are excluded because they’ve only had one season at this level in that time) and their latest Accounts show they lost £22.4 million last season. It seems to me that such a level of loss cannot be sustained by a League One club over a period of two seasons and more, so if it’s not to be promotion for the Terriers this season, there will surely have to be some reining in on the spending this summer.

Last season, Huddersfield finished tenth and although they look on track to better that this time around, poor results in their last four games could change that. So, why is a side that had so much faith placed in them back in August, seemingly going to come up short again this season?

Looking in from the outside, the most obvious reason for me has been apparent in two of their last three home matches. In the third of these matches on Good Friday, a goal in the 96th minute was enough to rescue Huddersfield from defeat against Play Off rivals Reading, but, in the other two, it was Lincoln and Wycombe who pinched a point with late goals. The Champions elect had trailed 2-0,. but got back to 2-2 in the 93rd minute, while there was a crazy finish on Saturday against Wycombe as Huddersfield led 2-1 going into added time, conceded almost straight away, then went ahead in the 96th minute only to lose the three points as the visitors scored after 101 minutes!

Promotion sides don’t tend to be in the habit of drawing home games they’ve been leading in 2-2 and 3-3 through conceding very late equalisers and, although they’ve tightened up defensively in the second half of the season, their total of fifty six conceded is more than you’d expect from a top six side already.

If City play as well as they did on Saturday, it’s hard to see Huddersfield getting the win they need, but, even if they do, a top six finish still looks beyond them to me.

On to the quiz, seven Huddersfield related questions covering a period of sixty six years with the answers to be posted on here on Wednesday.

60s. Born in a place called Swallownest, this forward never matched the scoring rate he maintained at Huddersfield at the start of his career. I think I’m right in saying that all seven of the Football League clubs he played for either wore stripes, halved shirts or shirts with white sleeves at some time or another over the period since he began his time in the game sixty four years ago. Despite his good strike rate, the fact he didn’t get to fifty league appearances in his four years as a first team squad member at Leeds Road rather shows where he stood in the pecking order at the club.

His first transfer saw him crossing the county border to play for a team which, like Huddersfield, was a real power in the game a very long time ago. Once again though, he rather struggled for game time, before he moved to a club where Tommy Docherty would have been his manager (he may even have signed him). Two goals in twenty seven starts meant he was moving on again without establishing himself, but he did better on the south coast as he managed to maintain a one in three strike rate over more than fifty appearances.

Next there was a spell at a club that is already promoted this season before returning to Yorkshire to play for a side that are still hoping to go up. Thirty goals in seventy appearances persuaded another 25/26 promotion hopeful to take him on, but that move didn’t work out, so he briefly upped sticks to America to play for some Comets and when he returned to England, it was to play in non league football for a place with a historic connection to that country. It wasn’t the end of his time in the Football League though, as he played a couple of games to finish at one of his earlier clubs (the one that has a striped shirt which is unique in the current EFL) and he was to be given a testimonial game by them well after his playing days had ended for his service to them in a range of jobs including groundsman and commercial manager. He died last year at the age of eighty one as another victim of dementia thought to be caused by his heading of the ball over a long period in his football career, but can you name him?

70s. Nicknamed “Bamber” at his first club because he was studying for an economics degree at the time, this forward also played for the British Olympic side in qualification matches for the 1968 games. This ended in a failure which was something he didn’t really experience much in a career that was spent mostly in the old First Division and featured a goal scored in a Cup Final at Wembley. His time at Huddersfield was the exception to the rule though as they were in a decline that would eventually see them go from First to Fourth Division football during the seventies – who am I describing?

80s. Yes, he loved ET – it was released while he was a Huddersfield player after all! (5,5)

90s. He made five league appearances for Huddersfield during this decade, has a non playing connection with City and spent time pretty recently working as a Technical Director at a club in the Polish Second tier that was promoted in his first season there. When the next season wasn’t going so well, he had a game in charge as caretaker manager, then stepped aside for someone who he had worked with before – someone who had played a few games for us in the 80s. As far as I can tell, both men are still with the Polish club, but can you name them?

00s. Crap 70s glam rock outfit once turned down by Keith Chegwin does the pressing!

10s. Religious man with a form of acne?

20s. Wanderer meets Royalty!

Answers

60s. Allan Gilliver played for Huddersfield, Blackburn, Rotherham, Brighton, Lincoln, Bradford, Stockport, Baltimore Comets, Boston United and Bradford again during a playing career lasting thirteen years – he also worked in a variety of roles for Bradford after he retired from playing.

70s. Alan Gowling began his career with Manchester United before moving on to Huddersfield where he experienced relegation in consecutive seasons. Still good enough for the top flight though, he joined Newcastle and scored their goal in the 1976 League Cup Final. He then spent four years at Bolton before finishing his career at Preston.

80s. Steve Doyle.

90s. Kevin Blackwell was Assistant Manager to Neil Warnock at City from 2016 to 2019, he has also worked with former City full back John Carver and now both men are working at Polish club Lechia Gdansk.

00s. Kenny Irons.

10s. Dean Whitehaed.

20s. Dion Charles – The Wanderer was a hit for Dion (and the Belmonts) in 1961. 

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023 | Tagged | Comments Off on Seven decades of Cardiff City v Huddersfield Town matches.

And, with one bound, Cardiff City are free (at least I think they are).

Cardiff City found the ideal time to put together what was possibly their most complete home performance of the season as, with nerves beginning to jangle as their home goalless run stretched into an eighth half, they scored twice in the space of three minutes early in the second half. The quick fire one two was enough to secure what was a pretty comprehensive 2-0 win over a Bolton side that had been thought of, in recent months, as the one team that could deny us an automatic promotion place.

I must admit Bolton looked pretty ordinary this lunchtime, but I’d prefer to say that was down to us rather than carry on about how poor a side our opponents, who’d lost just one of their last sixteen league games, were.

Things have got much tougher for us since our 5-2 loss at Plymouth in February. Since that match, we’d won just two in seven. However, I’d say we’d only played poorly against Lincoln and Blackpool in that stretch of games, while I reckon we were just okay at Barnsley. In the other four matches we were good in gaining big wins at Doncaster and Exeter, we were playing well against Wycombe until Gabriel Osho’s red card and we deserved to beat Peterborough.

However, outside of the two 4-0 away wins, so much of the other five matches was taken up by us labouring to break down a massed defence and the fact that we only scored twice in those games tells you that our labours were largely in vain.

In the early games, that was primarily down to a lack of creativity, but, more recently I’d say it was more shooting that was either substandard or over ambitious (or a combination of them both) that was holding us back.

So, we were in an odd situation whereby everyone outside the club was telling us we were going up automatically, but, with wins stubbornly refusing to come, there was a growing feeling, especially among supporters old enough to recall the disaster that was our end to the 08/09 campaign, that we may be beginning to see the onset of a collapse that would make what had happened seventeen years ago look prosaic by comparison.

I can’t verify whether this is true or not, but I read on social media this morning that City had never gone four consecutive home league games without scoring before*. Yet, as we failed to cash in on our dominance in the first half, I was thinking that the team which had been the highest scoring Cardiff side of recent seasons was on its way to creating an unwanted club record.

The main talking point beforehand regarding BBM’s team selection was who was going to play alongside Will Fish at centreback? With Osho suspended and injury doubts concerning Calum Chambers and Dylan Lawlor, we were down to the bare bones. 

In the event, Chambers didn’t make the squad, but Lawlor was able to start although the occasional hobble by the young Welsh international gave the clue that his troublesome toe was still bothering him.

Alex Robertson for David Turnbull in midfield was no surprise, while Cian Ashford’s absence from the squad was, seemingly, down to a back issue – Chris Willock was the predictable replacement for him.

All of this meant that Yousef Salech remained on the bench as Omari Kellyman continued as a false number nine with Rubin Colwill tending to operate just behind him.

While Kellyman was praised by some for his work off the ball at Peterborough, he was pretty anonymous in terms of a goal threat. However, here, within ninety seconds or so, he had the best chance to have come his way in the last three or four games as he combined fluently with Willock with the latter’s back heel into the Chelsea loanee’s path putting him in one on one with Jack Bonham, but, from about ten yards out, Kellyman’s angled shot was kept out by the keeper.

Willock has been quiet recently, but he was on his game here as he and Joel Bagan combined to give veteran Cyrus Christie a difficult afternoon. Within minutes, Bagan and Willock were involved again as Alex Robertson tried the same type of shot he scored from at Exeter recently, but, this time, Bonham reacted well to tip the effort from twenty yards over the bar.

However, in spite of City’s left flank operating well, most of the chances we had in the first half came from our right through the Rubin Colwill, Perry Ng, Ollie Tanner trio

When Ng burst infield after more slick passing, his low cross was met on the edge of the six yard box by Robertson, but his effort came back off the crossbar. I’d thought Kellyman could have made more of his earlier chance, but Robertson really should have broken the deadlock with this close range miss.

To his credit, Robertson was getting into plenty of advanced positions though as he played more as a second number ten in an attacking 4-1-4-1 formation. Bolton, for their part, appeared to have noted how we’d struggled to break down massed defences in recent weeks and were happy to frequently get eleven men behind the ball – all this in a game which, it seemed to me, they had to win if they wanted to make the top two.

Robertson later headed a Colwill cross not too far wide and Ng then manufactured a shot from the edge of the penalty area which passed a lot closer to the far post than Bonham was expecting it to.

Bolton were somewhat fortunate to be level in a game they had definitely been second best in. Yet, they would have been aware of the sense of anxiety surrounding City and they got a little more ambitious as half time approached with Ng doing well to get his head to a dangerous far post cross with Thierry Gale behind him well placed to score.

City had come out and scored very early in the second half on Monday after a frustrating first period, but they did better than that this time as they found themselves two goals to the good by the fifty second minute.

Any half time debate as to how we could end our barren scoring run at home would surely not have included the sort of header from a corner that Sean Morrison or Aden Flint used to score. Word is that we don’t score such goals any more, but when Bagan swung in a perfect near post corner, Kellyman came off his man to glance in a header across Bonham from six yards. Bolton had defended pretty well up to then, but they would have been fuming to concede such a cheap goal.

Just as on Monday, City breaking the deadlock was quickly followed by another goal, but this time pressure from our opponents gave us the opportunity to break at speed as possession was turned over.

We went on to score the latest in the long line of quality goals we’ve got this season. Robertson was the instigator with a strong burst past an opponent as he ran some thirty or forty yards with the ball before finding Willock whose assured finish from fifteen yards across Bonham went in off the far post.

Tanner had a shot pushed out by Bonham after very good pressing by Colwill and then the winger’s shot was deflected just wide as City looked to kill the game off, only for the visitors to finally show some attacking teeth as Sam Dalby headed against the outside of the post. 

In truth though, Bolton barely threatened again as City saw out the game pretty comfortably with Ryan Wintle coming as close as anyone to the game’s third goal as his effort was deflected wide following the partial clearance of Tanner’s low cross.

Although City’s nineteen goal attempts (five on target) was low by recent standards, this was a more assured and complete performance by them with their forward pressing being especially impressive. Fish and Lawlor ensured that Nathan Trott had little to.do and there was nothing I could be too critical of really, hence my view that it was one of our most complete displays of the season.

On second thoughts, there was one thing. Although the grappling matches we get at set pieces remains my biggest on field bugbear in the modern game, catching it up fast is the fairly recent development whereby goalkeepers go down with a non existent injury somewhere around the twentieth minute to bring about a “time out” where instructions can be fed to to the players based on what’s been happening early in the match.

Bolton were at it today, just like Peterborough, Blackpool etc, etc before them, but, in the second half, it was our turn as the largely unemployed Trott somehow needed treatment. To be fair, it’s not a form of cheating we resort to that much, but, let’s not make out we’re somehow more “noble” than our opponents! As I’ve mentioned before on here, you give players, managers and coaches an inch and they’ll take a mile – as soon as they see others getting away with something, they’ll start doing it.

I’ve virtually given up on the authorities doing anything to stop the alternative “sport” which breaks out every time a ball comes into a penalty area from a set piece, but, surely, ending these tactical injury breaks is something that can be easily done?

Bolton’s defeat means we only need one more point to be sure of finishing above them barring a truly mad change in both sides’ goal differences, while two draws will be enough to ensure the same applies to Bradford following their home defeat to Stevenage (who are making themselves big favourites to capture the fourth Play Off spot). Now it seems like Stockport are the side most likely to pip us for second place – they can finish on eighty five points and their run in doesn’t look too demanding, but, again, our far superior goal difference means that four points from our last five games will be enough to finish above them.

Talking of our next five games, other results at the bottom mean that our penultimate opponents, Northampton, are all but down despite them not playing today. The Cobblers can only reach the same number of points as Wimbledon and Leyton Orient, the two sides currently just outside the bottom four have, if they win their remaining five matches and, even then, they’re relying on big changes to everyone’s goal difference to be able to scrape clear of the relegation places.

No news yet on the under 18s’ game at Wigan this morning (it’s been posted on social media though that we lost 4-0 to the side that tops the Northern section of our league). The under 21s were 2-1 winners at Sheffield Wednesday yesterday with our Twitter account saying Trey George got both goals, while Wednesday’s account maintains George got one and Jake Davies was sent off for kicking the corner flag after scoring the winning goal! I’ve now seen video highlights of the game and it certainly looks like George got the goal with Davies having an assist, but there’s nothing there to indicate that anyone kicked a corner flag and was subsequently was shown a red card – that’s not to say that the sending off never happened as the video only shows a few seconds after the goal!

Finally, Ton Pentre were 3-2 winners at AFC Penrhiwceiber in the Highadmit Championship in the only game played by the various Rhondda teams covered by the blog.

Posted in Football in the Rhondda valleys., Out on the pitch, The kids., The stiffs | Tagged , , , | 8 Comments