Abysmal.

CoymayI kidded myself after the Middlesbrough match that that there would not be another home performance as bad as that for the rest of the season, well, in the very next game, a City side lacking in heart, fitness, bottle, leadership and, in some cases, interest in the proceedings were walloped 3-0 at Cardiff City Stadium by AFC Bournemouth in the Third Round of the League Cup.

If you were there a week ago, but missed last night’s game (there were only about 6,000 home fans there), then, believe me, this latest humiliation was worse, much worse.

In saying that, credit should go to the visitors who were bright, sharp, creative and motivated – it took them 33 minutes to put the tie to bed by scoring three times and, after that they were able to cruise through the game while giving the impression that they could easily have added to their lead if they had wanted to. Bournemouth’s bright, young manager Eddie Howe was full of praise for his side and, correctly and tellingly, credited them as much for their work without the ball as with it.

There were also the usual platitudes about having beaten a very good team from him – at least, I presume they were platitudes because if he really thought that the ease of victory was solely down to how good his players had been, then he might well be in for a rude awakening. The truth is that, while Bournemouth (who made seven changes to the starting line up for their impressive draw at Watford on the weekend), struck me as one of the better sides we’d played so far, it needs to be noted that they had nothing to beat – they won’t play a team, sorry, collection of individuals, like this Cardiff outfit again this season (I’m taking the glass half full approach there in hoping that the malaise affecting the club will be, at least partly, cured by the time we get to face Howe’s side again in the league).

Once again, the contrast between the way we let our opponents pop the ball about and the pressing game we faced when in possession was embarrassing. A common criticism of City this season is that they are not fit enough and, when you consider that we have yet to score a league goal beyond the fifty fifth minute, it’s easy to start believing there is something in this criticism. However, I’ve mentioned before on here that, as I’ve got older, I’ve come to appreciate more that what is going on in a team’s collective head is as important as, or maybe even more important than, it’s physical condition.

The aftermath of Bournemouth's third goal - I reckon the visitors could have ended up with six or seven if they'd really wanted them.*

The aftermath of Bournemouth’s third goal – I reckon the visitors could have ended up with six or seven if they’d really wanted them.*

Yes, City don’t look physically fit, but, for me at least, they are nowhere near mentally fit either. By this I mean, they lack the belief, character, confidence, commitment and poise that any squad as good as we keep on being told this one is should have. In game after game, I see no sign of the mindset which says I’ll do that bit more to help that team mate of mine in trouble, if I keep on making that run something will come my way eventually, I need to impose myself physically on my direct opponent, I need to do a lot more than just stand there with hands on hips when a team mate gives the ball away and, most of all, I see no one whose demeanour suggests they are thinking “I’ve got to lead by personal example”.

I daresay Ole’s thinking in putting together this unwieldy, underperforming and bloated squad that we are stuck with was that it would lead to a situation whereby players would come into the team desperate to prove themselves after finally being given a starting chance. Such an approach worked at Manchester United after all, but that doesn’t make it a surefire recipe for success – in fact, we are living proof of the potential drawbacks in adapting such an approach, just look what happened last night!

There were two obviously talented players given their chance to put down a marker for selection last night and they ended up being substituted with barely half an hour played. Indeed, one of those involved, apparently, preferred to stay at Cardiff in the face of reported interest from Celtic in the summer, while the other reiterated his commitment to honouring the contract he had signed with City when it appeared that the deal to sign him might be off after our relegation.

I thought Kimbo and Javi Guerra were a disgrace last night. Kimbo at least showed some urgency at times, but he was a shadow of the player who was instrumental in beating Man City last season and in general gave a good impersonation of someone who would have preferred to have been somewhere else.  As for Guerra, he did an impression of Robbie Fowler in  that first pre season match he played for us back in 2007 before heading straight off down the tunnel when Scott Young decided to take him off – thereby giving another clue as to what sort of morale and team spirit there is at the club currently.

It can be argued that, at that time, the two players being withdrawn were faring no worse than many others (e.g. Gabbidon, Cala, John, LeFondre and Maynard), but I would say that in most of their cases, those other five I named were showing at least some evidence that what was happening was hurting them and I thought Young was right to do what he did.

On the other hand, it has to be said that it wasn’t a good night for Messrs Gabbidon and Young. Gabbs looked very rusty – I appreciate that he has played very little football and really needs games to get up to speed, but wouldn’t it have made more sense to have done that in Development team matches first?

After doing well tactically at Derby, our pair of inexperienced managers came up with a formation which was akin to Ole at his most baffling – Maynard and LeFondre playing as wingers with Guerra and Kimbo through the middle in what looked like the first sighting of a genuine 4-2-4 formation since about 1972! I felt sorry for Gunnarsson and Adayemi as they tried, and failed, to counter Bournemouth’s five man midfield – neither of them turned in better than a five out of ten display, but, unlike others in the team, I found it hard to criticise their attitude.

I'm not sure whether these supporters leaving their seats after Bournemouth went 3-0 up were heading home or off for an early half time pint, but I'm sure there were some who decided enough was enough after just 33 minutes.*

I’m not certain whether these supporters leaving their seats after Bournemouth went 3-0 up were heading home or off for an early half time pint, but I’m sure there were some who decided enough was enough after just 33 minutes.*

City have got serious, serious problems on the pitch and whoever comes in as manager/head coach/Director of Football or whatever it’s being called today has a huge task on their hands. I’d say they have to totally transform morale within the squad, work on getting players physically fitter, get their tactical message across and understood and deal with the inevitable “advice” they will get from the Boardroom. I’m not as anti Russell Slade as most because I believe he might have some of the qualities needed to fire up these players and get them believing/interested/competitive, but, in truth, even Alex Ferguson would probably struggle to turn things around under the circumstances that exist at Cardiff.

Whoever the new man is, an on field leader who would knock a few heads together and provide an example to others would make such a difference in my opinion. Someone like a Graham Kavanagh at his best is needed, but, instead it looks like we are getting Ravel Morrison!

Morrison tweeted yesterday that he was on his way to Cardiff on loan until January while also having a go at his current club West Ham, so it looks like a car crash of a club is signing a car crash of a player. There was speculation that Morrison would be coming here about a month ago, but with the manager at the time no longer in place, you have to wonder who is making the decisions when it comes to transfer policy – in fact, in this case, you probably don’t, it doesn’t take much working out really given the player’s Manchester United roots.

Watching us plodding about the pitch in our Manchester United/Liverpool red while being stuffed by a side who, on the face of it, should not be in the same league as us (Bournemouth are yet another of those well run clubs with the sort of  recognisable footballing philosophy we lack mind)  made me think about how things have changed since Vincent Tan decided to become more hands on in February 2012. Yes, for a while he could point to his methods working, but since we got promoted it seems like everything that could go wrong has done so. Our league position is as bad as it’s been in nearly a decade, we have a playing staff and a ground that is too big for a club of our size, we owe about four times more than we did back in 2012 which means that we are unlikely to find someone who will buy us and it seems highly unlikely that Mr Tan will be able to recoup the money owed to him via the proceeds of success on the pitch, so it looks like a fire sale of players (many of whom are on contracts which will make them very reluctant to move) is on the cards if our owner decides he’s had enough of the shambles he’s played a part in creating.

* pictures courtesy of http://www.walesonline.co.uk/

 

Posted in Out on the pitch | Tagged | 6 Comments

Russell Slade the new favourite as Gabbidon and Young make their point.

CoymayI daresay there are fans of virtually every other team who say that, too often, off field matters become the main focus of attention at their club, but I firmly believe it happens more at Cardiff City than almost anywhere else. Yesterday morning I found myself thinking about who would be Ole’s successor and some of the truly bizarre rumours as to what the management structure will become in the coming weeks and then there’d be an “oh, and we’re playing today” which would float into the back of my mind.

Given how truly wretched 2014 has been so far in playing terms, I suppose it may well have been a case of what happened between Wednesday and Friday being almost a welcome distraction from the miserable performances City fans have had to endure over the past nine months -actually, make that a year because, once we’d won at Fulham to complete a short welcome to the Premier League honeymoon when we kidded ourselves for a while that we could survive quite easily, it’s been a real grind since losing to Newcastle in early October 2013.

In many of the bad defeats we suffered as relegation became an inevitability, the fact that we were up against good quality opposition could at least act as some sort of salve for the hurt being felt, but Tuesday’s no show against a Middlesbrough team who had to be no more than ordinary to be comfortably better than us, was as poor as anything I’ve seen during our annus horribilis when you consider the league we are now playing in.

So, the thought of City going to a Derby side who, Champions Leicester apart, were the best side I saw in the Championship last season and who looked to be coming to the boil nicely after a draw at leaders Forest and a midweek win at Blackburn was not a prospect to look forward to.

Aron Gunnarsson gets quite a bit of flak from City fans these days, but , although I accept it's not saying much, I reckon he's been one of our better players lately.  Here, he has just put us 1-0 up after hooking in from close range following a corner.*

Aron Gunnarsson gets quite a bit of flak from City fans these days, but , although I accept it’s not saying much, I reckon he’s been one of our better players lately. Here, he has just put us 1-0 up after hooking in from close range following a corner.*

The feelings of foreboding weren’t helped by the fact that the team were in the hands of two men who, as very popular players with the club, would have the goodwill of all supporters behind them, but were, when all’s said and done, complete novices when it comes to managing and coaching at this level.

Those pictures of Danny Gabbidon jumping on Scott Young’s shoulders after the latter’s winning goal against Leeds back in 2002 had been replayed a few times over the past few days – City were big underdogs that day and, in my mind anyway, a City win yesterday was less likely than it had appeared on that explosive January afternoon twelve years ago.

I got a bit more optimistic when I saw the team the caretaker managers had picked – for me, it had a more solid look to it than most of Ole’s selections and I liked the idea of having Anthony Pilkington and a fit again Craig Noone in there to utilise the flanks. The team lined up in what was certainly more of a Malky like 4-5-1 than it was an Ole type 4-3-3/4-5-1 with the main question about it being the one often asked when we played this system under Mackay – did we have anyone in the midfield five capable of giving worthwhile support to our lone striker?

The question became irrelevant during a totally one sided first half because we never had the opportunity to get anyone close to a labouring Kenwyne Jones – we were just concentrating on trying to keep Derby out. Given, the one way traffic towards our goal during the opening forty five minutes, we defended well. When the home side did manager to work an opening, David Marshall made good saves, but, with Bruno Manga and Matt Connolly to the fore, there weren’t too many scary moments when you consider we only had possession of the football for 23% of the time.

That said, the contrast between the two teams was pretty frightening from a Cardiff perspective. Derby wanted to play the game at pace and took quick restarts whenever they could – they passed the ball quickly and accurately and their full backs were playing more like wingers. Now, I know that, as an away side down on confidence, City would be looking to slow the game down as much as possible. However, as you watched our laboured backwards and sideways passing, which would would almost always end  with either a pass back to Marshall or a lump forward from close to our goal by a defender or midfielder and contrasted it with Derby’s crisp passing (albeit their players were never put under the pressure when in possession that ours were), it was hard not to think of an FA Cup match where a bunch of plucky non leaguers are interested in nothing more than hanging on to a 0-0 scoreline against vastly superior opponents.

I don’t think this expensively assembled squad of ours is capable of playing with the pace and urgency that Derby showed and questions have to be asked as to how fit some of them are – yes, Kenwyne Jones had a thankless task yesterday, but I agreed with Radio Wales’Kevin Ratcliffe when he questioned his fitness levels after the game (it says so much that Jones can look so immobile at times and yet you get the feeling that he is quite a bit fitter than he was last season!).

So, City went in at half time having played four halves of football during which they had barely created a chance or forced a goalkeeper into a save (Pilkington had a shot which flew yards high and wide, but I cannot remember another goal attempt in the first half yesterday) and, yet, in another example of what a strange game football can be, they had scored twice before the second half was ten minutes old.

It took the old faithful of a set piece goal to end the drought when Pilkington’s far post corner was nodded back by Connolly for Aron Gunnarsson to hook in from close range and then Peter Whittingham hammered in a second four minutes later when Jones did well to force an error out of a defender and Pilkington was able to provide the scoring pass.

If City could have held on for another ten minutes or so, then, perhaps, Derby heads would have dropped and the game could have been seen out quite comfortably, but the home side hit back hard – substitute Jordan Ibe soon reduced the arrears and there were six minutes left when Craig Bryson’s twenty yard shot flew in via an upright to make it 2-2.

Of course, there was disappointment at City having let a two goal lead slip just like they had done against Norwich, but, all things considered, a draw was a very good result considering the build up to the game and it should be seen as a feather in the cap of the novice managerial combination who certainly improved things at half time by getting their team to stay ten to fifteen yards further up the pitch – there’s still an awful lot for the new regime to do and the possession figures still make for worrying reading, but the second half represented some progress and, hopefully, confidence levels will be lifted a little.

If Internet rumours are to be believed, then City may well have a new man in charge by the time they play Bournemouth in the League Cup on Tuesday. Leyton Orient manager Russell Slade answered “I think they may have requested permission to talk to me. But I’m uncertain. I’m a little bit in the dark.” when asked about reports linking him with the City job and since then there has been Twitter claims by a journalist who has worked for the Times that the deal has been done.

Leyton Orient manager Russell Slade has come in from rank outsider to odds on favourite in the race to become City's next manager in the past couple of days.

Leyton Orient manager Russell Slade has come in from rank outsider to odds on favourite in the race to become City’s next manager in the past couple of days.

If this is the case, then City will be getting an ex teacher who never played the game at professional level and has spent most of his managerial career in the lower divisions. Furthermore, Slade was given one more game to save his job last weekend after his side (who were beaten on penalties in the League One Play Off Final last season), dropped closer to the bottom of the table. Since then, Orient have picked up four points in two matches, but, on the face of it, Slade coming to Cardiff would appear to be another whacky moment in the madcap world of Vincent Tan’s Cardiff City for the headline writers to drool over.

Scratch a little deeper though and it’s possible there might be a little method in the madness this time. Slade is quite highly regarded and, with the spirit in the City camp looking to be very low to this outsider, his reputation of being an excellent man manager and motivator may be relevant. The 53 year old is also someone who has never paid a fee for a player in four years in charge at what I still call Brisbane Road and is someone who seems to revel in that fact. Quite where a philosophy like that would fit in at a club where managers have become used to being given huge sums to spend over the past few years is hard to see.

To a degree, I can see that Slade might be a contender for the “Head Coach” job which involved him working on the playing side of things and leaving transfer dealings to the owner, Chairman and a newly created Director of Football. However, it seems to me that this would be wasting another of the man’s talents – his eye for a footballer. Apparently, in one night Slade found Michael Tonge, Richard Montgomery and Phil Jagielka for Sheffield United after all three had been released by other clubs as youngsters.

It seems to me that there is one scenario whereby appointing Russell Slade makes a lot of sense and that is if Vincent Tan has decided that the spending on players has to stop (or be cut back at least). If Cardiff City are set on “downsizing”, then Slade’s talents look to be very useful indeed, but, to get the best out of him, I would argue that he needs to be used as a traditional manager, not someone who has no say on player recruitment and works to a Director of Football.

*Picture courtesy of http://www.walesonline.co.uk/

 

 

 

 

Posted in Down in the dugout, Out on the pitch, Up in the Boardroom | 5 Comments