Last season revisited as City draw again.

CoymayHaving seen all of the competitive first team football we’d played this season prior to last night’s visit to Blackburn, it was hard to get back into the routine of relying on what the likes of Rob Phillips, John Hardie, Kevin Ratcliffe, Ian Walsh, Andy Legg etc. were saying about the action to form your immediate impression of how we were doing – this becomes doubly difficult when the messages you get are as mixed as they were during yesterday’s 1-1 draw.

With Blackburn still under some sort of transfer embargo (it seems a lot less rigourous than the one we had for much of 2010), not having won a match yet and  having lost key players like Rudy Gestede, Josh King and Tom Cairney in recent months, it seemed a good time to be playing them – especially when you consider Jordan Rhodes was out injured as well. We’d played pretty well in our first two league matches and our comeback from two goals down at QPR meant that although it was not a win in reality, it certainly felt like one at the final whistle.

Therefore, I was more confident about our chances of a win at Ewood Park than I usually am before away matches and, certainly for the first half an hour or so, it felt like my optimism had been well founded. Joe Mason, with a characteristically calm finish, had us in front in a league game for the first time this season in no time at all and it all sounded so comfortable as Blackburn laboured to get on terms. Trouble was, there wasn’t as much as you would have expected to hear about us having the chances to double our lead – in fact, there was next to nothing.

Instead, increasingly, it was Blackburn who were causing the commentators to raise their voices as we came under something of a siege in the minutes before half time. Although there were times in the second half when it sounded like City could regain their former serenity, the feeling I had as I listened to the final quarter of the game as the Blackburn pressure mounted and mounted was an inevitability that they would equalise and this they duly did when captain Grant Hanley was left unmarked on the far post after City looked to have initially dealt with one of many free kicks, corners and long throws into their penalty area.

Joe Mason's goal had more to do with a defensive cock up than it did with any great creativity on City's part, but at least he's got a goal behind him now and I still see the issue of who plays alongside him if our manager sticks with his intention of playing 4-4-2 to be of more concern than any debate as to his place in the team.*

Joe Mason’s goal had more to do with a defensive cock up than it did to any great creativity on City’s part, but at least he’s got a goal behind him now and I still see the issue of who plays alongside him if our manager sticks with his intention of playing 4-4-2 to be of more concern than any debate as to his place in the team.*

In the end , Blackburn almost ended up winning it and yet, for maybe more than half of the match, it sounded like we had the measure of our opponents, so did we get worse as the match went on or did our opponents improve?

In many ways, it sounded like a repeat of the 1-1 draw on the same ground we opened last season with – a dominant first quarter of the match which saw us a goal in front followed by a real struggle from which we escaped with a barely deserved point.

I remember at that time being shocked at how little of the ball we had over the ninety minutes, but that was when we were being told that we had the best Championship squad ever – over the months that followed, the sort of possession figures that were in the 60/40 region against us became something of a norm.

Although two matches (three if you also include the League Cup game with Wimbledon) where we had enjoyed more than 50 per cent of the ball hardly represents a big enough sample from which you can draw definite conclusions, it was still nonetheless satisfying to think that we may have turned a corner regarding a facet of the game which only saw bottom club Blackpool rated below us in the Championship last year – yes, I know possession stats aren’t the be all and end all, but, as a follower of the maxim which says your opponents cannot score when  you have the ball, I’ll always feel happier when we have it for the majority of a game.

If it’s too early to draw positive conclusions about how much of the ball we’ll have from a couple of matches, then it’s even more true that negative ones should not be taken from a single game. However, last night’s 58/42 breakdown in favour of  a Blackburn side whose main attacking ploy sounded like it was to put our keeper and defence under an aerial bombardment (hardly a tactic that  sees its user dominate possession normally) was an uncomfortable reminder that we are relying on a player coming back from a very long injury lay off and some tactical tinkering whereby a wide midfield player has to, in some ways, perform three different functions to try and put right the area of the team that caused biggest concern last season – it’s like using sticking plaster to try and stop a wing falling off a plane!

Captain Grant Hanley is in glorious isolation as he nets a deserved 87th minute equaliser for his team - although the goal didn't come directly from a set piece, there was enough in the brief highlights package I've seen to confirm that the defensive weaknesses from that facet of the game apparent at QPR haven't gone away yet.*

Captain Grant Hanley is in glorious isolation as he nets a deserved 87th minute equaliser for his team – although the goal didn’t come directly from a set piece, there was enough in the brief highlights package I’ve seen to confirm that the defensive weaknesses from that facet of the game apparent at QPR haven’t gone away yet.*

While Kagisho Dikagcoi’s presence and Joe Ralls’ versatility have made a difference in possession figures so far, the evidence is that, up to now, increased possession does not really equate to more shots on goal. The 37 league matches played under Russell Slade’s management last season saw us have an average of about 3.6 shots on target per game, so far we’ve had 11 efforts this time around in our three matches. So, there is an improvement, but it’s only a marginal one.

Now, I’ve not got anything to hand to show how our average of 3.75 shots on target per game compares to the rest of the league, but, over the whole of last season only four teams had fewer shots at goal than us and only six clubs had a lower percentage of shots on target than us, so my guess is that our current figure would see us about two thirds of the way down the table when everyone has played three matches.

I deduce from this that we lack creativity and that we need a central midfielder who could provide that just as much now as we did back in the spring. Now I say this knowing that a midfield could be laying potential goals on a plate only for poor strikers to put these very presentable chances either high or wide, but how many bad misses from City’s strikers (or any one else for that matter) can you recall so far this season? Joe Mason made a mess of a good chance at QPR, Anthony Pilkington probably should have scored from an opportunity he had in the first half of the same match, but, apart from that, I’m struggling to think of any – I can’t even remember Alex Revell having a goal attempt of any description in a league game so far!

Sorry for sounding a bit like a scratched record about our central midfield, but my report on them so far would read “better, but still in need of much improvement”. With our meat and two veg manager showing no inclination to try a more exotic or sophisticated tactical cuisine, I struggle to see how we can see truly significant levels of improvement from what has so obviously been the weakest part of the team since we returned to the Championship – I appreciate Russell Slade is limited by budget constraints as to how much he can do to address problem areas, but, with our one genuine summer addition to the squad not even getting off the bench at Blackburn, wouldn’t a central midfielder on loan have made more sense than yet another winger?

*pictures courtesy of http://www.walesonline.co.uk/

Posted in Down in the dugout, Out on the pitch | Tagged , | Comments Off on Last season revisited as City draw again.

Wharton makes his point.

CoymayHaving gone with a very young team for the 2-1 defeat at Coventry in their first competitive match of the season last week, the opening home game of the campaign last night saw a change of emphasis as more players with first team experience were brought in with Matt Kennedy and Kadeem Harris starting along with Semi Ajayi who was an unused sub in the first team’s opening two games.

By contrast, opponents Sheffield Wednesday had a squad without a single name I recognised and one look at their starting eleven confirmed the impression given by the team sheet that it was a very young side indeed – I did overhear some Wednesday fans behind me saying that the centre forward George Hirst was the son of David Hirst. I often moan at how anyone who played as a sub for thirty seconds twenty years tends to be labelled a “club legend” these days, but in David Hirst’s case, the term is justified at Hillsborough.

So, on the face of it, this seemed like an ideal opportunity for City to pick up their first points of the season – possibly with a big win. In the end, that’s how it turned out with the 3-0 scorleine possibly flattering Wednesday a little, but for the first three quarters of the match, the visitors did a more than adequate job of containing a toothless Cardiff side and it needed the introduction of someone who has been in danger of becoming a forgotten man at the club over the past year or so to turn things around.

Perhaps a few regular members of the team would have known that the Under 21s have had problems scoring goals lately in home games, but I suspect it’s only boring stattos like me who are even aware of things like the fact that they had only found the net in one game at Cardiff City Stadium in 2015 before last night. Nevertheless it put me in a frame of mind where I was just not expecting to see a goal from City  – my old failing of reading too much into things surfacing again then and yet, for long stretches of last night’s game, City played as if they were all too aware of this fact and, not only that, they were intimidated by it.

Inside the first thirty seconds City moved the ball out to put right back Jazzi Barnum-Bobb in a decent crossing position in pretty impressive style, but nothing came of it and this turned out to be a preview of what was to come over the next sixty five minutes or so. Wednesday had a pretty limited game plan whereby they were content to get eight outfield players (often more than that actually) behind the ball and hope to use their speed on the break to nick a goal (once they broke very dangerously from a City corner with the carelessly struck shot that ended up high among the Canton End seats coming some ten seconds or so after Kennedy had taken his flag kick).

Despite their negativity, Wednesday could claim the only on target effort for most of the first half as an early shot was comfortably dealt with by home keeper Luke O’Reilly. At a conservative estimate, City must have had about 65 per cent of the possession, but they were doing little worth noting with it. The plan seemed to be to get the ball out wide and find space to deliver a cross. With a surfeit of neat, technically good, players in the middle of the park, they were able to do this – the problem was that the final ball nearly always lacked the required quality or imagination.

Rhys Healey looks like he may have grown and filled out a bit in recent months, but even so he was giving an inch or two to the visiting centrebacks and with him often being the only target for crosses from open play, it needed more thought than just knocking over routine high balls in his direction. Wednesday may have been younger than City, but they still generally had a height advantage on their opponents – there was a credible aerial target to aim for when Ajayi came up for free kicks and corners, but if they could deal with him, then Wednesday probably felt there they were safe when defending dead ball situations.

The enormous distance Ajayi was able to get on his defensive headers was one of the few things which took my eye from a City perspective in the first half – there was another quietly assured and impressive showing from young Robbie Patten in the holding midfield role as he carried the form he showed for much of the Academy team’s 14/15 campaign on into the higher level and the likes of captain Tommy O’Sullivan and Harris showed what tidy players they can be on occasions, but none of it really suggested much in the way of an end product.

Nevertheless, the closing minutes of the half did offer some hope as a brave block by visiting captain Will DeHaviland diverted a goal bound Harris shot for a corner and the winger wasn’t that far away with another effort shortly afterwards, while Kennedy saw an angled effort turned for a corner by McDonagh in the Wednesday goal.

Mention of Kennedy takes me on to the show boating he was coming out with in front of the Grandstand in the opening stages of the second half. Now I’m not averse to City players indulging in such tricks at all, but I’m much more impressed with them when we are goals ahead and the game is won. Fair play to Kennedy, he was playing very well by the end showing  a level of skill and creativity which was worthy of a much higher standard match than this, but if I had been a Wednesday defender watching all of those tricks while it was 0-0, I would have been thinking something like “yeah, very good, but what are you actually doing to hurt us”?

Anyway, I should mention that, although they were probably even less of an attacking threat in the second forty five minutes than they had been in the first, the visitors did come the closest there was to a goal for three quarters of the match when half time substitute Warren Clarke fired narrowly over the bar within seconds of coming on – for the rest of the time it was more backs to the wall defence by Wednesday with increasing hopes that they could keep a clean sheet.

By now, City were at least getting a different sort of cross into the box, but it was typical of the way things were going that, after a fine run, 17 year old left back Rhys Abbruzzese’s low cross to around the penalty spot was overrun by about four attackers. However, a miskick by a Wednesday defender presented the ball to O’Sullivan twenty yards out only for his quickly hit shot to be turned around the post by McDonough. Still, City were getting closer and it did offer the hope that they could break the deadlock – it was now that the change which transformed things took place and within ten minutes City were coasting at 3-0.

The shirt Theo Wharton is wearing here betrays how long he has been playing for us at youth/development level. Over the past year or so, its looked at times like he was slipping down the midfield pecking order at Cardiff, but, even if he ends up not having a long term future with us, performances like last night show he is good enough to play in the Football League somewhere over the coming years.

The shirt Theo Wharton is wearing here betrays how long he has been playing for us at youth/development level. Over the past year or so, its looked at times like he was slipping down the midfield pecking order at Cardiff  rather than climbing it. However, even if he ends up not having a long term future with us, performances like last night show he is good enough to play in the Football League somewhere over the coming years.

In January it will be four years since Theo Wharton made his first team debut when he came on as a sub in a 4-2 defeat by West Brom in a Third Round FA Cup tie, but I probably first saw him play about two years before that. It didn’t take long for me to be impressed by him and, until last season, it seemed to me that he may well make it into the first team on a pretty regular basis. As the years went by I became convinced that Wharton had virtually all of the attributes a modern central midfield player needs – he had great stamina, was no slouch, had a wiry strength, could tackle well, could pass well and had quick and skillful feet, but last season didn’t go well for him as he missed a fair portion of it through injury and, when he did come back late on in the campaign, his game did not have it’s usual “snap” to it.

I mentioned the young team the Development team put out last week and it absolutely amazed me that Wharton was, first, on the bench and, second, not used at all – I can only assume that he wasn’t fully fit, but then why bother having him in the squad in the first place?

Now, it may well be that Wharton will have to leave Cardiff to play first team football, but, as soon as he replaced Jamie Veale, who certainly didn’t look out of place at this level, he played with the sort of dynamism in the middle of the park that many say the first team lacks. With his first touch, he flicked the ball around an opponent and ran thirty yards with the ball only to slightly delay his pass to Healey with the result that the striker wandered offside.

There was a double irony to what Wharton did next. My one consistent criticism of him has been that he doesn’t score enough goals and yet, with Wednesday having dealt so well with high balls into the box until then, they left Wharton unmarked as he headed Kennedy’s corner in from six yards.

You often hear that it’s so much harder physically to play without the ball than it is with it and this seemed particularly relevant to Wednesday after they went a goal behind as a combination of tiredness and, probably disappointment at the realisation that there was, almost certainly, no way back into the game for them left them looking very deflated. The visitors were there for the taking now, but, to be fair to City, they did a very good job of cashing in on their opponents discomfort.

Within six minutes it was 2-0 as Wharton put in a fine tackle to win the ball around the half way line, fed O’Sullivan and burst forward on to the return pass to finish impressively from about fifteen yards. No sooner had Wednesday restarted than they were picking the ball out of their net for a third time – Healey eventually finishing things off this time time after McDonough blocked O’Sullivan’s shot.

Healey had made a habit of scoring at least once in a home game at this level in his early years with the club, but he looked a player down on confidence for much of this match, yet, in many ways, his performance matched that of his team as he improved markedly in the last twenty minutes. Healey now began to win a few of those crosses in the air, heading straight at McDonough  when well placed and then glancing a more difficult chance narrowly wide, before he showed that strikers instinct, which I believe comes naturally to him, when quickly turning and firing a twenty yard shot narrowly over to end one of the best moves of the game.

Some of the close passing and control with Kennedy, Wharton and O’Sullivan in particular to the fore in the closing stages was a delight and it was a shame that Russell Slade, who had to leave at half time, saw the pretty turgid opening forty five minutes rather than what followed it. Truth be told, there will be much tougher tests to come over the coming months than this, but, at least, a few of our younger players were able to send out a reminder of their capabilities, with one of them in particular letting everyone know that he was still very much around.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in The stiffs | Tagged , | Comments Off on Wharton makes his point.