A defeat for the seniors, but still a great few weeks for Welsh football.

Posted on November 14, 2015 by The other Bob Wilson

CoymayPlease don’t read this as any sort of doing down of Wales’ achievement because it isn’t meant to be, but the increase in the number of teams taking place in the Finals competition of the tournament which had always had more qualification places available for European teams than the World Cup anyway, made Euro 2016 the easiest tournament to qualify for in senior international football for eligible nations.

In the event, the manner of Wales’ qualification meant that there was a very good chance that they would have made it to France next summer in the days when the European Championship Finals was a sixteen team tournament rather than a 24 side one, but my purpose in calling the qualifying group procedure which ended last month the easiest ever was wholly to do with our opponents last night.

For me, the biggest story of the qualifying phase was the Netherlands’ staggering failure to even make it to the Play Off stage for teams that had finished third in their group – it’s amazing that the tournament next summer will go ahead with one of the true powers of European football over the past forty years not represented.

As to why they won’t be there, well the Dutch international squad is traditionally not the happiest of camps – moulding the collection of egos that represent the best footballers in your country must be a tough task for any international manager/coach, but, arguably it’s tougher than anywhere in Europe if you happen to have the Dutch job.

Even so, although there has been the occasional failure to qualify for major tournaments in the past, I’m pretty sure I’m right when I say the Dutch have never finished fourth in a qualifying group since they became a true international power in 1974 when their superb team really should have become World Champions.

So, the failure of the Dutch team in 2015 represents a low point in the last forty years for that country. However, the evidence of last night’s win 3-2 win at Cardiff City Stadium over a Welsh team depleted of their two biggest players as well as what are probably their two top strikers suggested that there could well have been a different outcome for them if they had been able to call on the injured Arjen Robben for their final few group matches.

Robben, for some reason booed throughout the game by sections of the 25,000 plus crowd, was excellent. He scored twice and was denied a hat trick by a superb save by Wayne Hennessey just after the break, having earlier fired just over and he also put a great chance wide just before his match winning goal.

That effort was taken calmly and well, but it was his first,  a fine solo goal as he ran thirty yards with the ball cutting in front the right all the while and taking his time before shooting past Hennessey, which emphasised that this was one of the true greats of modern European football in action. The whole episode seemed to take about fifteen seconds, but at no time did I feel that it would end in anything but a Dutch goal, such was Robben’s control and mastery of the situation.

I can remember having a similar such feeling during Wales’ 3-1 win over Iceland in March 2014, when Gareth Bale skinned an opponent out on the right touchline around by the halfway line, before heading infield towards goal and, although the whole thing took a long time, in football terms at least, you just knew the best player on the pitch was going to end up scoring.

It’s a bit too easy and simplistic to say that the only reason the Netherlands won was that they had their matchwinner available and playing and we didn’t have ours. However, although they retained possession well and, generally, put their opponents goal under slightly more threat than Wales did, there was an overall brittleness about the Dutch which suggested that they are/were very reliant on Robben.

Indeed, even with the Bayern Munich star, there was a definite feeling within the ground that the match was turning in Wales’ favour after their second equaliser and I’d say it’s fair to argue that Wales lost because they were chasing the win – I doubt it if the Welsh defence would have been left as undermanned after the ball had been lost just inside their opponents half for the winning goal if competitive points had been on offer.

Given what we saw during their qualifying campaign where success was founded on a great defensive record which helped to overshadow the fact that we were, by some distance, the fifth lowest scorers in our group, this was a strange Welsh showing. The backline looked creaky at times, while, at the other end of the pitch, we were much more dangerous than I for one expected us to be beforehand.

I commented on how I thought attitudes might have been different last night if competitive points had been at stake, so, for now at least, I’m going to assume that Wales will be less easy to break down when the serious stuff starts up again than they were when they were opened up pretty easily for Bas Dost to head the Dutch in front on thirty two minutes and they won’t be as wide open to a counter attack as they were with both Robben’s goals.

So, to match the current feelgood factor surrounding the Welsh team, I’ll instead concentrate on the pluses from last night. For me, the biggest by some distance was the very promising performance of Tom Lawrence in his first starting appearance for his country.

Given the lone striker’s job against the Dutch back three, Lawrence kept them honest with a mixture of pace, skill and a little bit of strength. On the down side, his finishing when he had been played into promising positions was indicative of someone who only scored eight times in his fifty senior appearances at club level, but if he can keep on showing the qualities we saw last night, then he’ll create goals for others, even if he doesn’t get too many of them himself.

On that performance, Lawrence has to be in the Welsh squad for the Finals (I suspect he always was going to be anyway mind), but, more than that, he has to be a serious challenger for a starting place over in France as well. Although I’ve been pretty impressed with what I’ve seen of him at Blackburn this season, last night was the first time I’ve seen why he was so highly regarded at Manchester United in his teenage years.

Besides Lawrence, other youngsters to impress with their attacking play were George Williams who, as he often did before his injury last season, showed that he has the ability to go past players at this level and Emyr Huws who repeated the good impression he had made in his earlier appearances and this time topped it with a powerful headed goal to make it 2-2 after Wales had caught their opponents dozing with a short corner routine.

Dutch keeper Jasper Cillessen is helpless as Emyr Huws' header finds the corner of the net for Wales' second goal, but what took my eye in this photo was the state of the pitch. For the first time in a few years, the playing surface at Cardiff City Stadium attracted criticism - it looked to me as it was cutting up a bit against Reading and it was a factor on the game last night. The very wet weather of recent weeks could be the cause of the problem I suppose, but, with Cardiff being the wettest city in the country apparently, it's hardly as if this hasn't been a factor at times during the years where the pitch has looked in perfect condition from August to May.*

Dutch keeper Jasper Cillessen is helpless as Emyr Huws’ header finds the corner of the net for Wales’ second goal, but what took my eye in this photo was the state of the pitch. For the first time in a few years, the playing surface at Cardiff City Stadium attracted criticism – it looked to me as it was cutting up a bit against Reading and it was a factor on the game last night. The very wet weather of recent weeks could be the cause of the problem I suppose, but, with Cardiff being the wettest city in the country apparently, it’s hardly as if this hasn’t been a factor at times during the years where the pitch has looked in perfect condition from August to May.*

The cross for that goal was provided by Joe Allen who showed that, whatever his future might be at Liverpool under their new management, he is good enough to play Premier League football every week. Allen was one of a few in the team who would have welcomed the opportunity to play a full ninety minutes after not figuring too often for his club lately –  Joe Ledley (who made scoring look easier than it actually was  when he followed up to make it 1-1 after Allen’s penalty had been saved) and James Chester (a bit rusty with his distribution) were others.

So, a good night overall for the senior side I’d say, but, having commented on notable achievements for Wales at Under 16 and 17 levels in my piece on the Reading match, there have been two results in the last couple of days which suggest that we have some strength in depth at the levels below the seniors.

Firstly, Wales’ Under 19s opened their qualifying campaign for the UEFA age group Championship with a fine 3-0 win over hosts Georgis. The format for this group is similar to the one used at Under 16 and 17 levels recently in that one country hosts the four sides with all games played within a five or six day period.

So, Wales top the group at this early stage having blitzed the home team with three first half goals – congratulations to City’s Rhys Abbruzzese (Cameron Coxe also started the game and Lloyd Humprhies came on as a sub) who opened the scoring with a fine shot from twenty yards.

Wales will be facing Austria (who beat Albania 2-1 in the match between the group’s other sides) in less than an hour’s time as I type this and Abbruzzese and Coxe start again, with Mark Harris being bought in to take the City contingent up to three – hopefully the team can ensure qualification before they play the Albanians early next week in their final match.

A few hours before last night’s match, Wales’ Under 21s made it ten points from a possible twelve in their qualifying group with a hard fought 2-1 win over Armenia in Bangor. Declan John captained a team, in which Tommy O’Sullivan also started,  which made heavy weather of beating the group’s bottom team, despite going ahead inside ten minutes thanks to a Ellis Harrison penalty. Wales lost their way after a dominant first half and conceded an equaliser on the hour, only for Harry Wilson to come up with the winner a minute into added time.

Wales are in Bangor again when they entertain Romania on Tuesday and a look at the current group table (as shown in this piece on yesterday’s match) shows how important the game is. There is still plenty of time for things to go pear shaped, but, having, already drawn in Denmark, Wales are definitely in a promising position at the moment.

So, having had positives in defeat for the seniors and successes all the way for age group teams, men’s football in Wales looks as healthy as I can remember it being. However, as people sought to listen to reaction to the match on their radios as they got back to their cars after the game, all they heard was about terrorist attacks in Paris  that had, it’s now known, killed three people who had gone to watch their country play a football match in the Stade De France.

The death toll was far greater at the Bataclan concert hall where people who had gone to enjoy music were killed indiscriminately and, currently, the death toll from the various incidents is being reported as more than 120.

On occasions like this, football seems an irrelevance and I did think seriously about not doing a piece on a game which I suspect will be known in years to come as the match that was played on the night Paris was devastated.

One thing social media certainly doesn’t lack is people who will tell you they know exactly how the problems which are making this world an increasingly dangerous place can be resolved (peacefully or not). I cannot make such claims myself because what we saw last night is beyond my level of understanding.

However, my instincts (which I accept could easily be wrong) tell me that those who support the perpetrators of last night’s atrocities do not want people to try to carry on as normal. Of course, it’s impossible to act as if nothing has happened, but, I decided, in my own very small way, to not be swayed from what I was going to do today, tomorrow, next week, next month – to do otherwise is,effectively, to let the terrorists win.

*photo courtesy of https://www.flickr.com/photos/joncandy/albums/with/72157661177400235

Posted in Wales | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on A defeat for the seniors, but still a great few weeks for Welsh football.

As bad as I’ve seen from the Under 21s.

Posted on November 10, 2015 by The other Bob Wilson

CoymayWhen I started this blog over six years ago, one of the things I decided I’d do was to be generally positive about the matches I watched below first team level – even in the most awful of games I’d try to temper criticism by finding something praiseworthy to say about some aspects of what I had watched.

However, I don’t think that task has been any harder than it is after the miserable ninety minutes I spent watching City’s Under 21 side lose 2-0 at Leckwith yesterday afternoon to a Barnsley team whose record going into the match was played eleven, won one and lost ten.

I’ve just watched the two and a half minutes highlights package of the match on the club website and can confirm that, apart from two incidents which would have stretched the whole thing just beyond the three minute mark, the person doing the editing has captured everything worth recording that happened in the game – it was desperately poor stuff most of the time.

I think all I can do in the search for positives is say that three players in the City side should probably be exempt from too much criticism, but, in reality, in only one of those cases would it be because they had played pretty well.

For me, the one member of the team who could be reasonably satisfied with his performance was goalkeeper Luke Wakeman – there were some fine saves among the few that he had to make and he couldn’t be blamed for either goal.

Of the others, Eli Phipps only lasted around twenty minutes before going off with an injury sustained as he challenged for a through ball with the Barnsley keeper and a defender and, although he was at fault with the opening goal, I suppose allowances have to be made for Ben Turner who played for an hour in what was his first competitive appearance of the season after injury.

Overall though, it was a thoroughly miserable performance by City. With Barnsley mostly content to sit back and defend an early lead, the almost complete failure to create anything worthwhile in open play despite all of the possession and territorial advantage they enjoyed was, for me, the biggest single indictment in a match full of poor decision making and execution from those in City shirts.

I’ve seen plenty of players like Robbie Patten, Jamie Veale, Macauley Southam and Tyler Roche in recent years and know that they are capable of a lot better than what they showed yesterday. Patten is a player I like and I think his poor showing could be dismissed as a one off, while Veale’s neat technique and impressive vision usually marks him out as someone who can find a pass to unlock a defence. Roche has pace, the quality so many say the first team lacks, in abundance and Southam has an ability to find space in forward areas and can finish well, but none of them contributed anything which suggested they were capable of breaking down Barnsley’s massed defensive ranks.

Only Matt Kennedy looked like he might be able to create something, but he spent much of the afternoon running down blind alleys and, without Phipps to aim for, City didn’t really have the personnel with the presence and goal instincts to take advantage of the succession of crosses he put in. To be fair, the lack of a natural striker for most of the game made life hard for City, but you would have thought they could have come up with something more to test a defence which cannot have been the most confident given the way the season had gone for them so far.

I don’t know how much of the match Russell Slade watched (he passed by me on the way to taking a seat in the stand with about twenty minutes left), but, I would have thought that what he saw would have made him even more sure that his comments about the club’s Academy not producing the goods in recent years were justified.

Speaking as someone who has been a persistent critic of his attitude towards youth development, I have to admit that there was hardly anything on view yesterday to suggest our manager was wrong in his opinion, but I would argue that this is one of  those what came first, the chicken or the egg situations. Was yesterday’s awful showing simply down to the fact that our youngsters aren’t good enough or was it an inevitable consequence of an ethos at the club in which young footballers are not getting the encouragement and, possibly, standard of coaching that they should be receiving as they try to make what has to be the hardest step of all in their careers – into the first team?

What I will say, is that, apart from Declan John (who, for a variety of reasons, has not played many games this season and was absent again yesterday on Wales Under 21 duty), I don’t see anyone who is consistently putting in performances which merit consideration for a place in the first team squad.

However, I maintain that the end of last season represented an ideal opportunity to give some of our young players the odd five or ten minutes of first team action here and there which, I believe, would have given them a completely different mindset to take into the new campaign.

Russell Slade talked recently about how sending players out on loan to play first team football was his preferred way of bringing on youngsters on pro contracts. That all sounds pretty reasonable to me and I certainly wouldn’t say that our manager is wrong in thinking that, but the performance of one of our players yesterday, who has just come back from a loan spell with a League Two club, illustrates that this policy can prove counter productive at times.

Now, I’m someone who has questioned the thinking behind bringing in Semi Ajayi in the summer, while at the same time releasing a home grown centreback in Josh Yorwerth who is good enough to be a regular starter for his country’s Under 21 team. However, I acknowledge that Ajayi has the physical attributes to be a very commanding performer and his Arsenal background has helped ingrain an approach which sees him try to play out constructively from the back – I accept that he has potential and that he was a natural candidate to be loaned out in the way our manager prefers.

Semi Ajayi pictured in action for AFC Wimbledon in a loan spell that began well for him, but ended with him out of the team after injury and the concession of five goals in two matches.

Semi Ajayi pictured in action for AFC Wimbledon during a loan spell that began well for him, but ended with him out of the team after injury and the concession of eight goals in two matches.

Unfortunately, having suffered a head injury while at AFC Wimbledon, which their manager Neil Ardley says affected his confidence, Ajayi was far from the imposing performer I’ve seen him be in the past yesterday – his decision making was poor, his distribution hurried and ragged and he received the game’s only yellow card for a poor challenge which would have seen him being shown a red if the ref had decided to punish him in the same way for a similar foul about half an hour earlier.

I should mention again here that it’s easy to fall into the trap of reading too much into yesterday’s very poor showing, but I can’t help thinking that, as our Under 21s are also known as the club’s Development side, are these young players actually being “developed” under the current approach at Cardiff?

Certainly, Semi Ajayi’s game has not developed this season, in fact I’d say it’s gone backwards. Similarly, Russell Slade has talked of Tommy O’Sullivan’s game stagnating at Under 21 level (I agree that he wasn’t playing as well as I’d seen him do often in the past), but it’s an accusation which, even if you leave yesterday’s match aside, could be directed at a few in the team which faced Barnsley.

Going back to Josh Yorwerth, his loan from Ipswich to Crawley has been extended to three months on the back of him playing a central part in seeing that club rise up the League Two table thanks to a run of four wins in the six matches he has played.

Last week, Yorwerth was interviewed about how his stay at Crawley was working out and contrasted the encouragement he has received from his manager at Ipswich, Mick McCarthy, and Crawley boss Mark Yates with what he saw at Cardiff, saying “At Cardiff the manager didn’t even give youngsters a chance to go anywhere near the first team, even in training.”.

I must say that I was not surprised in the slightest by what Yorwerth had to say because it only confirmed the impression I’d formed over the past thirteen months about our manager’s attitude towards young players. Of course, in the interests of balance, I need to say here that my view is formed entirely as an outsider who never sees what happens on the training pitch and that, by its very nature, youth development takes time and so, if changes are being made under this manager, it will not be clear if they’ve worked or not for some time yet.

Even so, yesterday’s game is the tip on an iceberg which, for me, has seen a slight decline in standards on the playing front at Under 18 and 21 levels since Russell Slade was appointed and I firmly believe that any measured and impartial analysis of the job he has done so far at Cardiff would have to conclude that he is coming up short when it comes to getting the best out of the Academy system he inherited, both in terms of utilising the players within it and getting value for money from it.

I suppose I should say a bit about what actually happened yesterday (it won’t take long!) before finishing. After a quiet opening few minutes, City’s defence went through a torrid spell which saw Wakeman come to Ajayi’s rescue as he was out very quickly to dive at an opponent’s feet after the defender’s underhit and careless back pass. A minute later the keeper did well to turn aside a free kick given for a foul after City had, again, given the ball away needlessly on the edge of their own penalty area, but he was unable to bail out Turner when his backpass gave a Barnsley striker the chance to advance and confidently slot home.

For a long period after that, City offered no goal threat whatsoever, apart from a cross by left back Dylan Rees which gently hit a post after everyone had missed it, but, if they did have a dominant spell in the game, it came in the minutes before half time. Given the lack of creativity on show, it was no surprise that Barnsley only looked like losing their lead from dead ball situations and, when they came under sustained pressure as the interval approached, decent deliveries from Kennedy saw right back Ashley Baker (who has a good record for scoring from free kicks and corners) denied by a clearance off the line and Turner by the whistle of a referee, who always seemed very keen to penalise the attacking side at set pieces, after his emphatic header had found the net.

For the whole of the second half a limited Barnsley outfit had little trouble keeping City out – indeed, the only attacking “highlight” of the half I can remember came when one of the subs ballooned a shot over from about fifteen yards out.

The closing minutes saw Barnsley given more room to exploit as City pushed men forward in the search of an equaliser and Wakeman was forced into another good save before being given no chance with a well placed shot from fifteen yards to seal the victory – there was not even time to restart the match after that and so the fifty or so spectators were finally put out of their misery!

Posted in The stiffs | Tagged , , | 4 Comments