Seven decades of Cardiff City v Sunderland matches.

Our fixtures so far for this season have followed an odd pattern. At home,
we’re going to face the three sides (QPR, Sheffield Wednesday and Rotherham)
who were probably the trio most tipped to go down by pundits who had a go at
predicting how the table would end up in May in our first five games.Add in
winless Swansea and a Coventry side still looking for their second victory of
the campaign and it’s safe to do say that we could have had a more testing
introduction to our season at Cardiff City Stadium.

By total contrast, we are having to endure the away start from hell!
Leicester, most people’s tip for the title, Leeds and Ipswich were all fancied
for a top six finish and now on Sunday we go on our longest away trip of the
season to face a Sunderland side that reached the Play Off’s last season and
are probably the form team in the division on the back of three straight wins
gained with a goals tally of 11-2 in their favour.

Based on what we’ve seen so far, City will be very competitive like they
certainly were at Leicester and Ipswich (ironically, the one game we didn’t
lose, at Leeds, was probably the worst we’ve played in an away game so far). Realistically
however, we’ll be kept waiting a bit longer for our first away win in the
league – the very impressive victory by a virtual second eleven at a previously
unbeaten Birmingham in the League Cup should not be forgotten mind.

Here’s seven Sunderland related questions going back to the 1960s with the
answers to be posted on here on Monday.

60s.Born in a capital city, this defender was a one club man, following an
unsuccessful trial with Burnley as a teenager, who was forced to retire from
the game because of back problems at the age of thirty one. He made his debut
for Sunderland at eighteen in a game at Plymouth (the city he was to pass away
in some sixty years later) and became a regular for them for around a dozen
years.

He stayed in the game after retirement mostly as an Assistant manager, but
when he was given the manager’s role on a temporary basis at another northern
club, he did such a good job in steering them to a sixth place finish from what
had been a relegation struggle until he took over, that he more or less had to
be given the job on a full time basis. However, the feeling that he was only
keeping the seat warm for someone else was given credence when he was sacked
just five games into the nest season.

Internationally, he played more than thirty times for his country and was
also used twice as an Assistant to the manager when they competed in a World
Cup Finals tournament, who am I describing?

70s. Judging by the fact that this Lancastrian forward had three spells with
his home town club in a career which saw him represent another dozen teams, the
lure of home was always strong. The first of those three spells at home got
Sunderland interested and he was soon snapped up by them as a teenager. Over
two seasons he became a pretty regular starter in the Second Division for the
Roker Park side with a good, if not spectacular, goalscoring record. His next
move took him to the First Division where he was supposed to be a replacement
for a player who was scoring goals for England in a World Cup Finals tournament
a decade earlier, but our man’s upward mobility ground to a halt to such an
extent that he was released on a free transfer a year later.

After that, he became the archetypal lower league journeyman, although in
amongst all of the free transfer moves was a return home which went well in
terms of goalscoring at least. After this, apart from brief spells to the north
west and north east, all of his wandering was done in the Lancashire/Cheshire
area.

One consequence of having so many clubs was that he has a claim to fame –
apparently, he has turned out for more FA Cup winning clubs than any playerr in
the game, but can you name him?

80s. Sounds blunt and dull to me!

90s. Lend my villa to European leader. (4,8)

00s. This defender was setting records on the international stage as a
youngster (it only lasted for one game), but his club career was mundane by
comparison.. He appeared for Sunderland against City in a losing cause during
this decade before a possibly unique occurrence of him being loaned to the same
club three times in succession without the move ever becoming a permanent one.
Instead, he moved to rivals of ours before, finally, signing for the club he’d
been loaned to so often some five years after his last temporary spell there.
There was a sixth loan move of his career to shoe makers before a departure
from the game at twenty nine which offered brutal confirmation of youthful
promise coming to nothing. Who is he?

10s. Something of a lingering presence in the background in the very
watchable Sunderland documentary series from a few years back, he was capped by
England at the age of twenty, in February 2017, he ended a drought of 1,370
days without winning a Premier League game in which he had started the match
and he’s now playing in Australia – who?

20s. A knave, yet a treasure at the same time

 

Answers

60s. Belfast born Martin Harvey made more than three hundred league appearances for Sunderland before injury forced him to retire in 1971. He was manager of Carlise for a while and also did caretaker jobs at Plymouth on a couple of occasions besides being Billy Bingham’s Assistant Manager with Northern Ireland at the 1982 and 1986 World Cups.

70s. Wayne Entwhistle has three spells with his home town club, Bury. Sunderland paid £30,000 for him as an eighteen year old and he was signed by Leeds two years later as a potential replacement for Allan Clarke, but the First Division was a step too far for Entwhistle who dropped out of league football for a while before a second spell a Bury where his goalscoring record ensured that there were plenty of suitors when he, invariably, became available as he tried unsuccessfully, to live up to his early promise.

However, it seems no one else can match Entwhistle’s feat of playing for eight clubs that have won the FA Cup in their time (Bury, Sunderland, Leeds, Blackpool, Wimbledon, Bolton, Burnley and Wigan).

80s. Frank Gray.

90s. Andy Melville.

00s. For a short while, Lewin Nyatanga was Wales’ youngest ever player, the appearance of a certain Gareth Bale in Nyatanga’s second match for his adopted country ended that record. Myatanga was loaned by Derby to Sunderland in the autumn of 2006 and was in their side which was beaten 2-1 by us at the Stadium of Light. Later that season, Nyatanga was loaned to Barnsley for the first time, before two more of them followed in the next year. However, when Nyatanga moved on from Derby, it was to Bristol City in 2008 and he only got to sign for Barnsley some five years later. After that, there was a loan to Northampton, but nothing after that once his Barnsley contract ran out.

10s. Jack Rodwell.

20s. Jack Diamond.

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023 | Tagged | Comments Off on Seven decades of Cardiff City v Sunderland matches.

Best home performance in ages sees Ramsey less Cardiff climb into the top ten.

I said on the messageboard this morning that, looking beyond all of the extra stuff that goes with the south Wales derby, all we’ve done so far this season is beat two sides in the bottom three of the Championship.

 I did qualify that by saying that a virtual second string side were very impressive in beating Birmingham in the League Cup and that we appear to have a goal threat of a kind we never came close to having last season, so I accepted it was a harsh judgment, but, for me, there was a degree of realism to it- it was still too early to start thinking in terms of top half finishes or anything better than that.

Although I would still urge caution, it does become harder to think things could all fall apart in a similar manner to the last two seasons after tonight’s breathless 3-2 win over beaten Playoff finalists Coventry at Cardiff City Stadium.

The first thing to say is that City don’t do two wins from a midweek/weekend or weekend/midweek pair of home games or at least they don’t do it very often – I’ve no idea when it last happened, but I remember spending some time a few years ago going back to the turn of the century checking on this and, as I recall, I didn’t have to use the fingers on two hands to count them.

Since then, our record in this respect has probably got worse if anything, so to do what we’ve done in the last few days is impressive, especially when a month ago it was hard to see where the next home win was coming from – now we have three straight victories on our own ground, something we couldn’t manage last season.

It will be the Swansea game that will live longer in the memories of supporters in years to come of course, but I must say that I thought we played better tonight – we were up against better opponents and yet although there were nearly twelve frantic minutes of added time to endure, I don’t think Coventry could have too many complaints about the outcome.

City were without the in form Aaron Ramsey who was not even in the match day squad and Ollie Tanner, the hero of Saturday came in for Yakou Meite as Joe Ralls took over the captaincy on his return to the starting line up.

Coventry, on a run of four successive draws, have spent a lot of money during the summer and, on this evidence, will need time to bed in fully with all of the changes to their squad, but I’m pretty confident that they will be Play Off challengers this season – put it this way, anyone saying we’d not beaten anyone of any substance yet will have to revise that opinion now!

City made an uncharacteristically bright start to a home game as the confidence gained from the derby win shone through with the ball being moved crisply and well. One such example of this good interplay led to a corner on eight minutes taken by Ralls which was nodded in from six yards out by an unmarked Dimitrios Goutas for his first goal for the club and our first set piece goal of the League season – for all that Ramsey has been very good since returning here, I think I’d rather have Ralls taking corners than him for a few reasons, one of which being that Joe is better at taking them!.

Quite how City’s centreback was left in such glorious isolation is hard to figure out, but I’m sure Coventry boss Mark Robins will be spending some time talking about set piece defending in the coming days.

City were on top for a good twenty minutes after that as good work down the flanks led to crosses from either wing that Ike Ugbo was very close to reaching.

All the while though, Coventry were working their way back into the game. Certainly, the visitors’ share of possession began to rise (it ended up 65/35 in their favour), but, although our goals against record would not suggest it, it seems to me that we’re a lot more organised out of possession under our new manager.

Although the balance of power was shifting, there wasn’t much to suggest an equaliser was coming and Ugbo was about a foot away from making it two when he connected well on the half volley with a cross by Ryan Wintle.

However, the game soon had its second set piece goal when Jak Alnwick got a decent punch on a corner,but the ball went straight to a Coventry player some thirty yards out who fed Liam Kelly on the edge of the penalty area. What happened next could have been pure luck as the contact from Kelly found its way to Matt Godden who shot home from eight yards, but I reckon it was a a clever, perceptive pass from the Coventry captain not some sort of mishit shot or flukey rebound – it was Godden’s fifth goal of the season and he’s an experienced goal scorer at this level, so you could be critical of the defending which left him with that much room I suppose, but I don’t think we did too much wrong really.

Coventry, buoyed by being on level terms, had the better of the rest of the first half as City found themselves pushed back more, but there was no more scoring in an entertaining forty five minutes which had seen City score their first home goal in the opening half in five league games.

City again started a half better as the game settled into a pattern which saw the visitors continue to have more of the ball without doing a great deal with it, while we were more direct (not in a long ball way) and urgent in possession which meant that Coventry’s defending had to be somewhat more “last ditch” than ours.

Coventry brought their Japanese international Sakamoto on to play as a more attacking right wing back. His arrival was greeted with great enthusiasm by the visiting fans and you could see why as his side did carry more of an attacking threat after his introduction.

However, Sakamoto had to be regarded as culpable to a degree when City regained the lead on sixty one minutes with a lovely goal which began as they neatly played through Coventry’s press and the ball was eventually worked to Wintle who clipped over a cross which Karlan Grant, stealing a few yards on Sakamoto, met with a diving header from twelve yards past former City keeper Ben Wilson to score his first goal in over a year.

According to plenty of West Brom fans, Grant is lazy and hardly a team man, but here he was tireless in his defensive work despite being, like a few of his colleagues, out on his feet in the closing stages and seemingly carrying an injury, yet he stayed on for the full one hundred and two minutes somehow!

Coventry came close to levelling for a second time as City failed to deal with a cross from their left and Alnwick was forced to make his best save of the night from Kasey Palmer’s low shot from pretty close in.

The match was now an entertaining watch for any neutrals present, but for City fans used to seeing their side lose leads this season, it became a fraught one until Kion Etete came on for Tanner and emulated the winger’s achievement on Saturday of scoring within a minute of taking the field. The young striker matched his tally of three from last season as he ran onto a Perry Ng pass (Ng was excellent tonight and my man of the match) as Coventry’s defence seemingly waited for a linesman’s flag to be raised (either for offside or for the ball having gone out of play before Ng played his pass) to impressively beat Wilson with an angled shot from twelve yards.

That goal should have given City some breathing space, but, as mentioned earlier, they were really struggling to last the pace having put in such a big effort on Saturday – indeed, even Mr perpetual motion Manolis Siopis (who has made such a difference to our midfield) had to come off to be replaced by Ebou Adams for the closing minutes.

Etete’s goal came on eighty four minutes, but it turned out that there was still almost twenty minutes left to play so Coventry would have thought that the game wasn’t beyond them yet and, with five of the signaled ten minutes of added time played, Godden got his second with a header from a cross by substitute Atari.

Although this made for a very tense finale, especially considering that the ten minutes of added time was extended well beyond that, Coventry never got themselves into positions to really threaten City again after it became 3-2 and the biggest talking points were whether referee Sam Allison, who I thought contributed to the entertainment by letting lots of things go that more fussy officials would not have tolerated, was right to only show yellow cards to Coventry defenders Latibeaudier and McFadzean? My opinion was that a yellow was right for the latter as there was a teammate close enough for him not to be considered the last man as he brought down Etete, but the former was lucky to escape a red card for a nasty tackle on Siopis while it was still 3-1.

So, with six more games to be played tonight which will almost certainly result in us dropping a few places, City currently find themselves in the giddy heights of ninth position for what it is worth at this time of the season. Anyone watching us play last season would be amazed that we’re currently averaging almost two goals a game and they probably would be a little surprised that we have conceded as many as twelve in seven games. However, I’d say our performances so far merit a top half position and, while it’s still too early to make too many predictions, you would have thought that things cannot deteriorate enough to see us struggle as much as we did last season – we have much more attacking pace and goal power this time around.

There were also matches played at under 18 and under 21 level today. The under 18s continue to struggle as they went down 3-1 to Bournemouth in what I think was a League Cup game – whatever it was, it was the first game played at the new Academy headquarters in Llanrumney.

Swansea were able to exact a small measure of revenge for their weekend defeat when they came out on top in a Third Round Nathaniel MG Cup game when they entertained City’s under 21s while both sides’ first elevens were in action. Swansea came out on top only because they won a penalty shoot out after the match finished level at 1-1 after ninety minutes with Keiron Evans scoring a second half equaliser for us. Unfortunately, the shoot out was one of those that is decided by a single miss from the spot and this time the player concerned was Fin Johnson.

Posted in Out on the pitch, The kids., The stiffs | Tagged , , | 3 Comments