Seven decades of Cardiff City v Leeds United matches.

Let’s start with some good news, City’s under 21 team made it through to the Quarter Finals (they’ve been drawn at home to Cardiff Met) of the Nathaniel MG Cup with an enjoyable 2-1 win over Merthyr at Leckwith on Tuesday night.

In a first half which resembled a game of attack v defence, City created the sort of chances that, despite the evidence of our own eyes, our manager insists the first team are missing in every game, and missed them all to go in at the break somehow level at 0-0.

The irony was that Merthyr came out with a more aggressive attitude in the second half and were dominating the opening minutes of it when City took the lead as Michael Reindorf’s shot proved to be strong for the visiting keeper and found the net.

For a long time, that goal looked like it would be decisive despite play switching from end to end as Merthyr chased an equaliser. City gradually reasserted their authority though and a second goal arrived just before the ninety minute mark when the impressive Trey George chipped the keeper – the ball looked to be on it’s way into the net, but Reindorf touched it in from point blank range, thereby provoking unsuccessful Merthyr appeals for offside.

Despite Noah Smerdon pulling a goal back almost immediately from a corner, Merthyr had run out of time and so were left to reflect on a match in which they made a decent contribution to the entertainment, but could have few complaints about the outcome.

Yesterday we had what’s been called a passionate defence of his management of the club by Erol Bulut – I gave my response to the story on the messageboard I use this morning;

“I watched it as well and found it truly weird, I knew what was coming because I’d read the Wales Online report about him “coming out swinging”, but any boxer at a decent level who does that tends to end up being counted out flat on his backside within a round or two. No, this “swinging” was more akin to someone who gets in a fight in the taxi queue outside the Philharmonic on a Sunday morning, wild, unconvincing and sounding pissed.

Despite knowing what was coming, I was still flabbergasted both by how someone can be so deluded and how his rantings were indulged by the fearless gentlemen of the press asking the questions.”.

I accept it could be called unfair because both of the teams involved were a lot better than us last season, but the time my attitude to our manager changed to one of I’d not be bothered in the slightest if he were sacked can be traced to the home defeats by Leicester and Leeds within a few days of each other over the Christmas/New Year period. It was if we went out for those two games with the height of our ambition being to keep the size of our defeat down to manageable proportions.

Although I see no other outcome than a Leeds win tomorrow, let’s hope we at least have a go, rather than sit back and wait for the inevitable – despite what Erol Bulut might think, the overwhelming majority of City fans would respond positively if his team gave the home crowd something to get excited about as opposed to the sort of stuff normally served up at Cardiff City Stadium under his management.

Here’s the usual quiz with seven questions on Leeds dating back to the 60s – the answers will be posted on here on Sunday morning.

60s. This forward’s route into senior football just would not happen these days. He was sought first by Leeds as a sixteen year old, but he turned down a professional contract, preferring instead to remain an amateur. He worked as a miner for a while, but when National Service took him “abroad”, his goalscoring exploits for Army teams persuaded the biggest team in the locality to sign him. Wearing red now, he did well at senior level in the professional game and his speed and finishing soon had clubs at a higher level interested. He would spend much of his career playing for Yorkshire clubs and he stayed in red with the first of them as he became part of a squad that almost provided a new competition with a shock first winner. Leeds got their man at the second attempt and he became an established member of a team which was taking the initial steps on their journey to the top of the domestic game. The jump to the First Division proved to be a step too far though and so he moved a short distance to play in stripes, but, with his pace on the wain as he reached 30, he again struggled and it wasn’t until he returned to hsi first club that he began to score goals at his old rate. After that, he signed for bitter rivals for a short while before dropping into non league football, can you name him?

70s. Born in a place in Lancashire once famous for its Dynamos, this full back cum midfield man started off at the further away of the two clubs which constitute one the most intense rivalries in England. His first club wasn’t always successful, but, as, maybe, the best player in the squad at the time, he was often linked to bigger clubs. When he did move on, it was to a Leeds side that weren’t one of the powers in the land any more, but were still an established top flight club. That situation changed while he was at Elland Road and Leeds were still in the second tier when he left them to sign for the team he supported as a boy – the side that were the rivals of his first club. His last move saw him becoming more dynamic as he returned home and dropped into non league. The personal life section of his Wikipedia entry contains just one story about how he was arrested in 2008 for slapping a female police officer who had caught him urinating in the street – he was given a conditional discharge and ordered to pay £60 costs after admitting to the charge, but who is he?

80s. Did this defender own a spaniel in his time with Leeds? (4,5)

90s. Disciple with banal issue by the sound of it.

00s. Gangrene version as pursued by City twenty odd years ago! (4,6)

10s. Royal family of Cowboys perhaps!

20s. Which member of the current Leeds squad has a winning goal against Spain at a major tournament in his CV?

Answers

60s.Don Weston signd for Wrexham when his goalscoring exploits while on National Service attracted the attention of Football League clubs. Second Division Rotherham paid £10,000 for his services and he was part of a team that took a 2-0 lead into the second leg of the Final of the first ever Football League Cup competition, only to go down 3-0 at Aston Villa in the return game. Don Revie then paid £18.000 for Weston and he was joint top scorer in the Leeds team which was promoted from the Second Division in 1963. Finding the adjustment to the top flight difficult, Weston signed for Huddersfield, only to struggle again and he eventually returned to Wrexham before he played a few games for Chester before he left league footballer.

70s. Colne born (Colne Dynamos were possibly the biggest non league club in England in the mid to late 80s before they were denied entry into what is now the National League following a promotion from the Northern Premier League in 1990 because their ground was deemed not good enough – with this news, the former pro footballer who had been bankrolling the club decided to dissolve it after an attempt to ground share with Burnley failed), Kevin Hird signed for Blackburn in 1973 and made over one hundred and thirty league appearances for them before a move to Leeds in 1979. Hird spent five years with Leeds, playing close to two hundred league games, before signing for Burnley and then finishing his career with a spell at the ill fated Colne Dynamos.

800s. Neil Aspin.

90s. Simon Grayson.

00s. Sean Gregan,

10s. Stuart Dallas,

20s. Ao Tanaka scored the winning goal for Japan against Spain in the 2022 World Cup game that enabled his team to qualify for the knock out stages.

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023, The stiffs | Tagged , | Comments Off on Seven decades of Cardiff City v Leeds United matches.

Unless just a one goal defeat represents an improvement, it’s the same old problems for Cardiff.

It may only be five games into the season, but, after today’s 1-0 loss at Derby County, I’m struggling to find reasons why this campaign won’t turn into a long, very tough relegation battle. One point, one goal scored and eleven conceded are reasons enough to feel downbeat about what the next eight months will hold, but I’m starting to get very concerned about how some sides predicted to struggle are putting a substantial number of points between them and us so early into the season.

Pre season predictions tended to think that three out of he following five would be relegated – Derby, Oxford, Portsmouth, Plymouth and Blackburn. Well, today’s win takes Derby to nine points which is the same as Oxford (a certain Mark Harris was chosen as Championship Player of the Month for August) after their win over Stoke today. To be fair to Blackburn, they’re shaping up as automatic promotion contenders after their 3-0 win over Bristol City as they sit in second position with eleven points. Plymouth beat Sunderland, who had a 100 per cent winning record before today, 3-2 to record their first win and move to five points. Portsmouth entertain West Brom tomorrow and still await their first win, but they have had a tremendously testing opening sequence of games and three draws from four games so far suggests they are going to be very competitive.

All of those clubs have played at least one match so far to a standard we can only dream of currently and, like every other team in the division, would rate a game against us as eminently winnable.

Tonight, there are plenty of calls for Erol Bulut to be sacked. Now, I’m no fan of our manager and, to be frank, I would not have shed a tear if he’d left at the end of last season. Instead, the Cardiff Board decided to give him a two year contract and, although the sale of Mark McGuinness went a long towards balancing the books, Bulut was given the biggest transfer budget this summer of any City manager since Neil Warnock in 2019 following our relegation from the Premier League.

Whether all of the players signed in the summer were Bulut’s picks is doubtful, but, even so, this can be classed as his team now. Therefore, it was hard to have much sympathy with him when he complained on the day after the transfer window closed about a lack of pace in his squad.

However, I wonder what our manager thinks of the decision to sign a striker for millions and then loan him out to Vincent Tan’s other club? All of this of course in a team with that single goal scored in four hundred and fifty minutes of league football! 

The breakdown in relations between Vincent Tan and then manager Malay Mackay back in 2012 might well have originated from the moment when Mackay described expensive teenage striker Andreas Cornelius as a “project” and now, a dozen years later, we have the club explaining away the mad decision (mad, at least, without a fuller explanation as to the reason for it) to loan Roko Simic to Kortrijk in a manner which strongly suggests that they see him as another project!

After the home defeat against Middlesbrough, our manager stated that the fortnight before his team played again would enable him and his analysts to study the stats from games played so far. Quite why they were unable to do that before then was not explained, but an emphasis on fitness was the order of the day and changes were promised.

Bulut was as good as his word when it came to the changes – there were six of them from the Middlesbrough game. Some of those missing out were due to injury (eg Aaron Ramsey and Jesper Daland), but Ethan Horvath, Alex Robertson, Yakou Meite (who wasn’t even in the squad) and Chris Willock were all dropped.

In came Jak Alnwick, Dimitrios Goutas, Joel Bagan, Joe Ralls, Rubin Colwill and Anwar El Ghazi, with Callum O’Dowda switching to the wing after previously featuring at left back. Another injury absentee was Callum Robinson which meant that Wilfried Kanga and youngster Michael Reindorf on the bench were the only strikers in the squad – have I mentioned before that loaning Simic to Kortrijk was barmy!

All of the changes made no difference, in my eyes anyway, in terms of dynamism, pace and fitness. Derby were better than us in all of those departments and were worth more than the one goal win which at least brought to an end that long run of losing matches by a two goal margin or more.

City fought hard, passed it quite nicely at times, but to no real effect in terms of adding to their miserable goals for record and it was telling that two of home keeper Zetterstrom’s most awkward moments came when keeping out potential own goals by team mates.

Colwill had an early sight of goal and shot powerfully from fifteen yards, but the angle was against him and Zetterstrom’s save was a fairly easy one. After that the game settled down with Derby looking the more likely largely because of their habit of making progress down their left.

It was through this source that the game’s decisive moment arrived just before the half hour mark as full back Callum Elder combined with former City winger Nathaniel Mendez-Laing to get the better of Perry Ng and El Ghazi and Elder’s low cross was knocked in first time by an unmarked Kenzo Goudmijn from ten yards despite there being three defenders pretty close by.

Fair play to City, they responded by quickly forcing three successive corners and from the first of them Eiran Cashin the Derby captain glanced his header towards his own goal, but Zetterstrom reacted quickly to keep the ball out and then got up in time to divert Goutas’ follow up wide.

Alnwick made the first of two or three good saves to deny Mendez-Laing and half time was reached with City yet again trailing (the’ve been in front this season for no more than the half an hour or so after Mark McGuiness’ header in the League Cup win over Bristol Rovers).

Will Fish came on to replace Ng at the interval and the centre back’s composed debut was the best thing about the second forty five as he suggested that he, Daland and Callum Chambers can be a trio of effective ball playing defenders who could improve our goals against record at least.

Ollie Tanner, Willock, Robertson and Cian Ashford all came on as well during the second period, but City still looked too ineffective and lacking in confidence to suggest they had an equaliser in them.

The one exception to this rule occurred with about twenty minutes to go when the ball was moved smoothly through the Derby midfield and defence and threaded to Tanner who took a good touch to come inside his marker. The angle wasn’t perfect, but it was a decent chance for the winger, yet the finish was wild as he opted for power and the ball flew well over the bar.

The one other half chance we had was when effective pressing by O’Dowda won him possession out on the right with an undermanned home defence in front of him. From here though, it became an illustration of why we’re going to find it so hard to break out of this goal scoring famine – the winger’s pass to Colwill was poorly placed and so all Rubin could do was nudge the ball slowly through to Kanga. The centre forward did well today in his hold up play I thought, but the poor guy must have forgotten what he should do in the position he found himself in now given the non existent service he gets and all he could do was dribble a shot into Zetterstrom’s hands from eight yards out.

Derby should really have got the two goal win they deserved right at the death when Alnwick and Manolis Siopis (who did really well defensively in the main in the closing minutes as City chased an equaliser) were unable to prevent former City midfielder Ebou Adams from having a run in from half way by himself to complete the formality of netting against his old club only to, inexplicably, shoot wide.

It was. perhaps, a fitting end to a game of no great quality. It sounded like the players were greeted by boos from sections of the away supporters as they went to salute them at the final whistle and you get the feeling that things are coming to a head as our beleaguered manager’s players did little to keep him in his job.

While the first team struggles, the senior age group sides are doing pretty well. The under 21s drew their Cup game at Ipswich 2-2 with Cody Twose and Trey George the scorers, while the under 18s were 2-1 winners against Crewe at Leckwith this lunchtime with Dan Ola and Jake Davies getting the goals.

In local football, draw specialists Treherbert Boys and Girls Club made it four one pointers in six in the Ardal League South West when they shared the spoils 1-1 at Swansea University.

Ton Pentre’s struggles in the Highadmit South Wales Alliance Premier Division continued with an 8-0 loss at leaders Cardiff Airport, while in Division One East, Treorchy Boys and Girls Club drew 2-2 at Tongwynlais.

Posted in Football in the Rhondda valleys., Out on the pitch, The kids., The stiffs | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments