Weekly review 23 August 2020.

Only a shortish piece this week because work on the book commemorating the win over Real Madrid fifty years ago in March and the 1970/71 season in general is taking up a lot of my time at the moment as I try to get things in order for the self publication through Amazon’s Kindle Create software – more to follow on this in the coming weeks.

In saying that, it’s been a quiet week all round really on the City front, so it would not have been a lengthy review anyway, but one definite piece of transfer news is that Danny Ward has completed his return to Huddersfield Town following the running down of his contract with us.

Danny was always a popular member of the squad with supporters and I think his goalscoring stats in terms of minutes per goal, shots per goal etc. were probably as impressive as anyone else’s at the club while he was with us, but he was one of those players who seemed to be most effective coming off the bench as exemplified by his contributions against Bristol City and Derby in recent weeks.

As far as arrivals go, it seems increasingly likely that Dion Sanderson will be returning here for another loan spell from Wolves as Neil Harris looks to address what is the obvious problem area within the squad currently – right back.

There was a story in the local media this week that said the arrival of a right sided defender was “imminent” and it also talked of us wanting to add one other player, but no information was given as to who this was or what position they play in.

The first team squad returned to pre season training last Monday after a very short break and we now know who they will be facing on September 12 in their opening game because the Football League fixtures for 20/21 were released on Friday – here is our full Championship programme for the new campaign which also has confirmation that we have been paired with Northampton in the First Round of the League Cup which will be played in a fortnight’s time.

It’s hard to know exactly what effect Sheffield Wednesday’s twelve point penalty for FFP breaches will have on the outcome of our first Championship match. It’s a hefty punishment, but logic dictates that it’ll be less of an encumbrance for any team when they still have plenty of games left to recover their situation than it would be when they’re, say, half way through their season – I’m sure it’ll be something that will play little part in City’s preparations for the game.

Presumably, the upcoming week will see the first team squad playing a practice game or two, but they’ve already started for the under 23 Development team who have been in action against Connahs Quay Nomads and Cardiff Met in the past ten days or so and there has, apparently, also been a match with Barry as well. As to what happened in these behind closed doors fixtures, well there seems to be a bit of a behind closed doors mentality when it comes to giving out any details at all about them. Nothing at all is known about the Connahs Quay game, it was said by a messageboard contributor that we were beaten 4-1 by Barry, but there’s been nothing in the way of confirmation of this. However, the club’s website is at least carrying video footage of highlights from the Cardiff Met match which shows that City turned a 1-0 half time deficit around as they completed a 3-1 win.

There was a somewhat disturbing story this week regarding Emiliano Sala as the fall out following his death in January 2019 continues – albeit at a very slow pace. It’s impossible to know exactly what is going on here and allowances have to be made for the current circumstances which make this a very testing time for all football clubs, but stories like this look dreadful for Cardiff City and it seems to me that it would be in the club’s best interests to issue some sort of statement giving their take on things.

There’s a significant anniversary next Friday as well because on 28 August 1920, City played their first game as a Football League club when they recovered from conceding an early goal to win 5-2 at Stockport County in the newly formed Second Division. The honour of scoring our first goal in the new competition fell to Jimmy Gill, a £750 signing from Sheffield Wednesday who was the first player brought in to the club following their election to the Football League.

Gill became City’s top scorer in that first season as they finished runners up to secure promotion and he played in the FA Cup Semi Final against Wolves which finished as a goalless draw, but was missing from the replay at Old Trafford where a couple of hotly disputed early goals helped the midlands team on their way to a 3-1 win.

The City team beaten 3-1 by Wolves in an FA Cup Semi Final replay at Old Trafford in their first season as a Football League team;-
Left to right,  George Beare, Billy Grimshaw, Fred Keenor (who scored our goal from a penalty), Bert Smith, Charlie Brittan, Ben Davies, Arthur Cashmore, Albert Barnett, Billy Hardy, Jack Evans, Jimmy Blair.

Once again, can I make a request for support from readers by them becoming my Patrons through Patreon. Full details of this scheme and the reasons why I decided to introduce it can be found here, but I should say that the feedback I have got in the past couple of years has indicated a reluctance from some to use Patreon as they prefer to opt for a direct payment to me. If you are interested in becoming a patron and would prefer to make a direct contribution, please contact me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com or in the Feedback section of the blog and I will send you my bank/PayPal details.

Posted in Cardiff City Books, Out on the pitch, The stiffs | Tagged , | Comments Off on Weekly review 23 August 2020.

A new book for a new season – 1970/71 remembered.

It’s the time of year when I ask readers of Mauve and Yellow Army to make a contribution towards its running costs again. Before I go into detail about this and what I hope you find an exciting development for the new season, I should, once again, offer my sincere thanks to all of you who have helped ensure the future of the blog over the past two years through a mixture of monthly payments via Patreon, monthly Standing Orders into my bank account and once a year payments via bank transfer, PayPal, cheque and cash.

I make this year’s request while acknowledging that the last few months has seen everyone in the world having to face up to what will hopefully turn out to be a one off situation which has meant that life has not been what used to be called normal for any of us. For many, Covid 19 has meant financial hardship and I fully appreciate that there may well be some readers who have provided a donation to the blog in the past and may wish to do so now, but, completely understandably, will not be doing so because Mauve and Yellow Army is a very long way down their list of priorities at the moment.

I first asked for help from readers two years ago at a time when it appeared likely that the blog would have to wind up due to a bill for the biggest of the charges I have to pay to renew web hosting fees.

This was the most urgent of the three targets I set out back in 2018 and was both surprised and elated to discover that enough was raised to pay the bill within a matter of weeks and, with some offers already received as to how a similar problem can be avoided when it’s up for renewal again next year in place, I do not envisage the same worries in the future.

The medium term goal was that the day to day running costs of the blog be covered and this has happened, notably when I needed to change my printer/copier/scanner twice in a year.

Finally, I set as a long term goal that money received could be utilised towards the writing and publishing of another Cardiff City related book to follow on from The Journey Back which I co wrote with Richard Holt in 2013.

I’ve dropped the odd hint on here that I’ve been working on such a book over the past year or so and I’m pleased to say that I’m on schedule to be in a position whereby something could be published by the target date I had set of Christmas of this year.

That date is an important one because on 10 March next year it will be the fiftieth anniversary of Cardiff beating Real Madrid at Ninian Park in the first leg of a Quarter Final tie in the European Cup Winners’ Cup, so any book commemorating the fiftieth anniversary of that event becomes a bit of waste of time if it comes out after that!

My plan originally was to make the book solely about the pair of matches against the club that was probably the most successful and famous in the world during the second half of the last century, but it did not take me long to reacquaint myself as to what an amazing season 1970/71 was for the club – in fact, I’d nominate it as the most memorable one in my City supporting life dating back to 1963.

So, the scope of my “project” was quickly expanded a long way further than that fortnight I mentioned earlier into a record with analysis of a ten month period which had a huge impact on the club City became and I would argue that impact is still being felt now.

As a result, quite a bit of my time last summer was spent making trips back and forth to Gabalfa library in Cardiff looking at old copies of the Western Mail, South Wales Echo and Football Echo studying the stories which would form a background to what I would write.

Over the course of the season just finished, I have been working on the book itself and am happy to say that it is now virtually finished,save for a proof reading that is about two thirds completed and coming up with a better title than “Real Madrid and all that” which is what I’ve called it up to now.

To give an idea of what the book will entail, it starts with a description of Jimmy Scoular’s early time at City with brief summaries of each season and some thoughts on transfers/memorable games etc. before concentrating on the 70/71 season with descriptions of each match based on a combination of my memories and the media reports I’d read on them.

There will also be details of both teams for each game, attendance details, goal times etc. provided by Richard Holt in the format used for the Journey Back and where I was able to find video recordings of the games, I include the ip addresses so that any readers can watch the pictures as well.

The book is slightly autobiographical in that, especially in the earlier years, I quite often refer to my parents’ reaction to events and I also go beyond the football occasionally to mention things that took my eye as I worked my way through those newspapers from half a century ago.

Broadly speaking, the season I concentrate mainly on is divided into chapters covering each month, but I devote one to each of the matches with Real Madrid and another one to the sale of John Toshack to Liverpool in November 1970. I say it myself, but I would not be surprised if the Toshack chapter is as through an examination into that very controversial transfer as there has been in the fifty years that followed it, I found it fascinating to write because it brought back so many memories and, in truth, I’d not realised the huge impact it had at the time.

City reaching the Youth Cup Final provides an interesting backdrop to what the first team were doing as the season reaches its climax and after a review of how things ended, I end with a chapter on what happened in the years that followed – for me, the club was never the same after 70/71.

There are some black and white pictures included, but, unfortunately, none of Peter King’s best goal I’ve ever seen City score in an incredible defeat by Middlesbrough which effectively ended one player’s career at the club. However, as I’m sure even some of you too young to have seen it in the flesh will have already watched it on the You Tube video that I give an address for!

I’m fairly confident that I will be able to get the book published in some format or another pretty soon, but I think it is most likely that it will only be available through Amazon in e book and, hopefully, paperback form.

Back in 2013, thanks to the help of Richard, a couple of other individuals and a loan from a group of other supporters, we were able to get The Journey Home published ourselves which meant it could be sold in some shops throughout Cardiff and from the Supporters’ Trust Office before and after matches – we were also able to offer a discount to Trust members who bought the book.

Although I think this becomes less important this time around because no one can be certain when we will be allowed to attend matches again, my hope was that I could aim for something similar with this book and therefore offer a discount to those whose support for Mauve and Yellow Army has been so much appreciated, but, although I’ll try to come up with something if I do go down the Amazon route, it may be that I’ll not be able to.

Just to repeat something I’ve said at this stage in the past two years – the blog will still be free to read for anyone who chooses not to make a donation to its running costs and, apart from the one in the top right hand corner which is to do with Google Ads, you will never have to bother about installing an ad blocker to read this site.

Finally, as mentioned earlier, donations can be made through Patreon, PayPal, by bank transfer, cheque, Standing Order/Direct Debit and cash, e-mail me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com for further payment details.

Posted in Cardiff City Books, General, Patreon | Comments Off on A new book for a new season – 1970/71 remembered.