No late winner to paper over Welsh attacking limitations this time – a really bad night.

I said in my piece on the Belarus game that I would make a big supposition and assume Wales would be able to win their three remaining matches against the group’s weakest teams Belarus and Estonia, but I’m afraid that, with a team as short of goal power as this one is (it’s now sixteen goals scored in our last nineteen matches), I really should know better than to say such things.

Apart from the 3-1 win over a Finnish side that had a player sent off after ten minutes, Wales’ successful Nations League campaign was founded on a series of dull games where we hardly looked like scoring until we got the late goal which won us the three points and the home win over the Czech Republic in this World Cup qualifying group offered more of the same.

No side can live off such thin pickings indefinitely and tonight, against a team ranked 110th in the world, Wales’ attacking shortcomings were exposed as Estonia took their first point of their campaign with a 0-0 draw in which they came closest to scoring in the first half (Mattias Kait hitting the cross bar from twenty yards as Wales suffered another first half fade out) and could have pinched a win with a couple of late opportunities.

An Estonia win would have been an injustice mind, because, once Wales finally got an effort on target after a turgid hour, there were plenty more that followed and luck didn’t go their way when, after Estonia’s teenage keeper Karl Hein had made one of a number of good saves by blocking a Gareth Bale shot, the captain’s follow up header rebounded off an upright and out.

Estonia defended doggedly and their goalkeeper had a good night, but this is a team that had conceded a total of fifteen goals in losing matches against the Czech Republic, Belarus and Belgium – they aren’t a good side and they’ll probably lose their return matches with those three teams, but tonight they’ll have no reason not to believe that they can do the same again to Wales when they travel to Tallin next month.

Three or four years ago, I used to look at all the young, technically gifted, attacking players we had coming through and think that we’ll be scoring for fun around the time of the 2022 World Cup, but, for different reasons (David Brooks, like Aaron Ramsey, plays so few games for us due to injury that you tend to forget about him these days) most of them have flattered to deceive.

Dan James is the type of winger that tends to stay out wide and so he needs to be fed the ball as opposed to him going looking for it. Consequently, he can be quiet in games, but he showed again in the closing stages tonight that he definitely has something at this level, so I’d say he’s the only one of that younger attacking set that is fulfilling his early promise.

Of the others, Harry Wilson has shown on plenty of occasions that he is a very gifted technical player, but he is so one footed, as he showed within the first minute tonight as Chris Gunter’s best contribution of the match saw him burst down the right and cross low to Wilson who was clear of the last defender, but, as Danny Gabbidon observed in commentary, it was a ball which should have been taken with the right foot, instead Wilson opted to use his left and his shot drifted harmlessly wide – score that and the night would probably have turned into the comfortable victory it should have been.

Shortly after Bale’s header had forced Arsenal’s Hein into the first of his saves with the first on target effort by either side in the game, Tyler Roberts was played through by Joe Morrell I think it was, but, not for a second, did I have any faith in him scoring and Hein was able to make a fairly simple save. Roberts is another of those neat attacking players we specialise in, but he’s still seeking a role in the team – Wales have tended to use him up front, but no goals in seventeen caps I think it is now rather tells a story.

The fact of the matter is that, record scorer Bale apart, Wales’ most effective attacking player recently is someone who has spent the majority of his career playing in the lower divisions or in non league football, someone whose selection for his first cap was greeted by the words “Keiffer who?” – Wales are hardly free scoring when he plays, but Mr Moore’s importance to them was proved again in the last week despite him not having kicked a ball for the team.

There’s not much more I can say about the game really, except that Rob Page stuck with Allen/Morrell midfield combination and, although they both did some very good things in isolated incidents, they didn’t impress me as a partnership and haven’t done so for quite some time now.

With Matt Smith and Dylan Levitt having done so well in Finland a week ago, I’m somewhat baffled as to why, firstly, we’ve seen nothing of those two since then and, secondly, Allen and Morrell played the full ninety minutes of both of our competitive matches despite them struggling physically as early as the first half against Belarus.

It seems Jonny Williams influences international matches more than he does club games these days and I can understand to a degree why he was brought on after Wilson departed after thirty six minutes following a collision with Hein where he appeared to suffer a head injury. It seems to me however, that he is someone who is good for a twenty to thirty minute appearance – increasingly, he had nothing to offer as his sixty five minutes on the pitch ticked by.

It needs to be emphasized of course that Wales have been in a state of flux or maybe even inertia since Ryan Giggs stepped aside in November of last year and Rob Page’s record in that time of six wins, five draws and four defeats with thirteen goals scored and fifteen conceded is not a bad one. However, I don’t believe it’s quite enough to keep him in the job if and when Giggs leaves formally because, while that poor goals for figure received a boost on Sunday thanks to Bale’s hat trick which contained two penalties, it’s definitely on a downward curve. Also, after a long period where we were very tight defensively, we’ve started to concede two’s three’s and fours, something which was almost unheard of in the latter years of the 2010s.

It’s a testimony to how good a player Joe Allen was for us that the decline in his performance levels, entirely due to a combination of injury and the ageing process, is seeing us look much more porous as our midfield struggles, and often fails, to keep up with the pace and movement of our opponents. There was plenty of evidence of this on Sunday and it was there again, albeit to a lesser extent, tonight as out lowly opponents had the better of things in the closing stages of the first half as Wales, again, faded badly after a good start. The similarities didn’t end there either, because the first fifteen minutes of the second period saw us struggling badly to raise a slow and unimaginative tempo.

The introduction of Mark Harris again coincided with an improvement in the Welsh performance, but Page came across as limited tactically and in his use of substitutions against opponents that tired an awful lot in the last ten minutes or so. It’s this sort of thing which just leaves those question marks when it comes to Page’s suitability for doing the job he’s doing now as a caretaker on a full time basis.

For me, the onus is on Ryan Giggs to force the issue now by resigning as manager because this limbo is not doing anyone any good. While I appreciate that he is innocent in the eyes of the law until proven guilty and so him hanging on is justified to some degree, the honourable thing would be to step aside with the realisation that he is young enough to return to the job in the future if he is exonerated with his reputation intact. For now though, we’re in a position where our qualifying hopes are being damaged and there can be no medium to long term planning – also, it’s not really fair to Robert Page to leave things as they are.  

A far better result came from the under 21s who, after only drawing against Moldova at home in their first game in their qualifying group for the age group version of the Euros, went to Bulgaria and won 4-0 – Blackburn’s Jack Vale scored a hat trick and Crewe’s Billy Sass Davies got the other one. Sam Bowen played the full ninety minutes, while there was a first cap for Isaak Davies who came on for the last few minutes – Keenan Patten and Kieron Evans were unused subs.

Taylor Jones was in the Wales Under 19 team which ended their programme in the four team tournament they have been competing in over the past week with a 2-2 draw with Turkey thanks to a penalty equaliser scored in added time, but it was the only point they ended up with after earlier losses to Croatia and Austria.

It’s the time of year again when I ask readers of Mauve and Yellow Army to make a contribution towards its running costs. Before I go into detail about this, I should, once again, offer my sincere thanks to all of you who have helped ensure the future of the blog over the past three years through a mixture of monthly payments via Patreon, monthly Standing Orders into my bank account and once a year payments via bank transfer, PayPal, cheque and cash.

The first time I made this request for assistance, it was prompted by a need for funds to pay for three yearly web hosting costs which, frankly, I was in no position to meet following my move of house a few months earlier. However, I’m pleased to say that, this time around, the web hosting bill was settled back in June with none of the problems there were back in 2018.

Therefore, any monies received this year will go towards other running costs and, although it’s too early yet to make any formal commitments despite so many of the pandemic restrictions in Wales being lifted recently, I am minded to do another review of a season from the past book to follow on from “Real Madrid and all that” which looked back on the 1970/71 campaign. At the moment 1975/76, the first promotion season I experienced, looks to be favourite for the book treatment, which would mean a lot more trips back and forth to Cardiff than my finances have become used to over the past year and a half – hopefully, the majority of them will not have to be made via Radyr Cheyne!

As always, the blog will still be free to read for anyone who chooses not to make a donation towards its running costs and, apart from the one in the top right hand corner which is to do with Google Ads, you will never have to bother about installing an ad blocker to read this site because there will never be any.

Finally, as mentioned earlier, donations can be made through Patreon, PayPal, by bank transfer, cheque, Standing Order/Direct Debit and cash, e-mail me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com for further payment details.

Posted in Wales | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Bale makes himself even more of a Welsh legend with hat trick in crucial win.

It wasn’t enough to punish Wales as much as they were punishing Belarus for the sanctions that are in place against that country by sending them almost a thousand miles further than they would have had to go without those sanctions. Once the Welsh had travelled the 2,500 miles to the new venue, Kazan in Eastern Russia, they were faced by a pitch that was not fit for international football as evidenced by the huge divot that was formed when Gareth Bale fell and sustained what could have been a serious knee injury in the second half of today’s match.

To go with these setbacks, Wales were without thirteen players for reasons of injuries, Covid rules, suspension and Visa difficulties (what was that one all about?), so we had the likes of Chris Gunter making a rare competitive start and Brennan Johnson and City’s Rubin  Colwill making first competitive starts.

Wales started with Danny Ward in goal, a back four of Gunter, Chris Mepham, James Lawrence and Ben Davies, the Euros pair of Joe Allen and Joe Morrell in central midfield, Johnson, Bale and Dan James in front of them and Colwill as what I think was meant to be a false number nine, but he ended up being used as a target man to me.

That’s nowhere near what I would call a full strength Welsh team and so, when you consider all of things I listed in the first few paragraphs, it shouldn’t come as too much of a surprise that they produced a disjointed and sketchy showing punctuated by expensive individual errors and a worrying lack of defensive conviction in a match that everyone was saying beforehand fell into the must win category.

Yet, somehow, I’m still not sure how, win they did to give themselves the chance of overhauling the Czech Republic to take the runners up spot which, realistically, is the best we can hope for I feel because the Belgians will surely be over the hill and far away if they beat the Czechs at home today.

Belgium showed that they are not infallible in the Euros and the Czechs were able to put Wales behind the eight ball early on in the group by drawing with the team ranked number one in the world in Prague, so the possibility exists that we can take at least a point off the Belgians again when they come to Cardiff. However, it remains a real long shot for me and we need to hope they do us a favour tonight and we can go to the away match against the team we scraped a 1-0 win over in March knowing that a draw should see us finish above them.

I’m making a big supposition there mind that we should be able to do what I’m pretty sure Belgium and the Czech Republic are very likely to do and that is take twelve points off the group minnows Belarus and Estonia.

Actually, describing Belarus as a minnow is a bit harsh because their ranking of ninety first in the world makes them that sort of team sides like Wales and the Czechs should beat, but, as we should have found today, they have it in them to spring a shock.

Nevertheless, I would expect us to beat them in Cardiff and we should have too much for an Estonia team ranked one hundred and ten in the world which has conceded fifteen goals in losing their three group matches so far.

Since the 2016 Euro qualifying campaign, Wales have made a habit of winning matches like today’s and the script is usually the same with strong defending to the fore as clean sheets were embroidered with, very often, a single goal margin of victory.

This was much, much different as Wales, led, then trailed for around a third of the game before winning it well into added time!

That they were able to do this was down to, arguably, Wales’ greatest ever player who ended his run of fifteen games without a goal for his country, by netting his second hat trick for them, with this one being much more important than the one he scored in the rout of China in what was essentially a friendly match three and a half years ago.

Bale, like too many of his team mates, was guilty of sloppy play at times, but we would have lost today without him. True, two of his goals were penalties, but the first one especially would have been a real test for him given Wales’ recent record from the spot and his awful miss against Turkey in the Euros and while his third, with the clock showing three of the scheduled four added minutes played, would probably not get into a compilation of his top fifty goals, it still took a fair bit of scoring.

The opening quarter of the game offered little hint of the drama to come as Wales had a grip on things due in no small measure to the early goal that should have made things a lot less tricky than they turned out to be. It came after a corner had been partially cleared to Ben Davies who then clipped a lovely, cute straight pass of the type that analysts say are so difficult to get right into the path of Bale, who got a touch to take him wide of advancing keeper Chernik who proceeded to knock over the Welsh captain for a clear penalty that saw Bale send him the wrong way.

Allen could have made it two, but his well struck effort from around the penalty spot was too close to Chernik, then the best Welsh move of the day saw quick passes exchanged down the right with Bale’s cross meant for Johnson scrambled behind for a corner.

Maybe it was all a bit too comfortable for Wales, but, around the twenty five minute mark. They began to start losing the challenges they had been winning, Belarus, who must be given credit as well for their improvement, were able to play through our press, while their own became more effective.

It felt like a momentum change, but there had been no real threat to the Welsh goal when Gunter chased back a long, high punt which he allowed to bounce a yard inside the penalty area. Doubts were expressed in the commentary box about the awarding of the penalty which followed on the grounds that if there was any contact made, it was slight, but by trying to deal with the high bouncing ball with his foot rather than his head, the experienced right back was, surely, making a rare international mistake.

Ward dived the right way for the penalty, but Lisakovich, the player fouled, placed his shot perfectly and the keeper never had a chance of making a save.

Lisakovich became the most influential player on the pitch for the rest of the first half as the Welsh defence endured as poor a fifteen minutes as I can remember in a long time.

Within ninety seconds, Belarus were in front. Colwill has to accept a share of the blame for losing the ball on the halfway line, but he had a right to expect far better from those in red behind him than he got.

Lawrence in particular was culpable as he got himself in a terrible position to deal with Lisakovich  and in no time the speedy forward was beyond his marker and in on goal with Mepham drawn across to try and deal with him. This left Sedona completely unmarked and he beat Ward easily from ten yards when the inevitable pass came.

Lawrence really was struggling at this point, but there were others as well – after the game, Rob Page said they had discussed the Belarus counter attack thread, but the way they chose to deal with it suggested the conversation was along the lines of “this lot are so slow that you don’t have to worry at all about them counter attacking”.

In truth Belarus should have had four by half time -Sachivko headed a corner wide from the edge of the six yard box when it looked easier to score (although maybe Lawrence did just enough to put him off). Then, after another rapid counter attack which left the Welsh defence gasping behind them, Belarus probably were looking to score the perfect goal as Klimovich curled his effort about a foot wide after taking too long to get his shot in.

Wales had offered nothing going forward themselves in this awful spell and although they improved in the second half as Belarus opted to sit back on their lead, a Johnson shot tipped over by Chernik apart, there was no sign of a Welsh equaliser when Page decided changes were needed.

Predictably, it was the youngsters Colwill and Johnson who made way and the City man has come in for some messageboard criticism for his showing.

I think this is harsh on two fronts, first Colwill did pretty well when Wales were on top and he can’t be blamed solely for the fade out which followed – there were far more experienced Welshmen who were struggling badly at this time.

More importantly though, we’re talking here about a teenager who, as far as I’m aware, until 2021 had played all of his Cardiff career as someone who would almost always have team mates in front of him when he received the ball and this enabled him to play to his creative strengths. Since coming into senior football for club and country he’s spent much of his time playing with his back to goal as a target for his colleagues. It’s asking an awful lot for any player to learn a new way of playing the game while stepping up a class or two – clearly Messrs McCarthy and Page have forgotten far more about football than I’ll ever know, but it seems to me that many of Colwill’s strengths are nullified when he’s asked to play as a target man.

How well or badly the youngsters did is up for debate, but I don’t think the view that Wales improved with the introduction of Jonny Williams and Mark Harris is.

By rights, Williams should be nowhere near the Wales team now. He plays in the Fourth Division now and finds club football a much tougher challenge now following his time at City which was something of a non event. However, here he was the Williams Wales have seen so often as he caused more problems for Belarus in those areas that are now called between the lines than any Welshman had done beforehand.

If anything though, Harris, on his Wales senior debut, was more impressive as his combination of clever and elusive movement and surprising strength and speed helped make Wales more of a problem for the Belarussians than they’d been for a good forty minutes or so.

Wales had to rely on more Belarus indiscipline for the equaliser midway through the second half though as Davies was bowled over by Ebong for a needless penalty as he contested a header a good fifteen yards from goal.

Bale stuttered in his run up this time, something that had me thinking he was going to miss, but,, again he found the net to get his team an equaliser they didn’t really deserve.

Knowing a draw was no good to them, Wales strove for the lead, but, in doing so, left themselves open to the counter attack, so there were some nerve shredding moments as they just about managed to keep Belarus in check.

Up the other end, Harris worked the room to put over a great cross that saw Bale go down in much the same manner as Davies had done about ten minutes earlier. It looked a good shout for a third penalty, but there was never much chance that it would be given – the odds on any team getting three penalties in a match must be tens of thousands to one.

With two minutes left, Bale lined up a free kick which was about as far out as his goal in Andorra seven years ago in a similar type game was, but, this time, his shot flew just wide as the goalkeeper collided with a post in his anxiety that it might be going in.

That seemed to be Wales’ last chance, it was to be a draw then, but, all of a sudden, defeat looked on the cards as Lisakovich beat the Welsh centrebacks in one final counter attack that saw Ward, who’d been something of a second half spectator, foil him with a fine save at the expense of a corner.

Attention turned to Lisakovich leaving the field to be substituted after what might have been a man of the match before one last shock to give the game a final score line that wasn’t really fair, but so vital to the visitors..

All of a sudden, Harris was free of his marker and moving in on goal, it looked like there was going to be a fairytale ending to his full Welsh debut, but Chernik saved and then, when the ball broke back to the City man, his follow up effort was deflected towards goal only for it to be cleared off the line by a defender.

From here, the ball broke to James, whose effectiveness had largely been blunted by a pitch on which the ball didn’t run well, and the new Leeds signing improvised a cross to Bale whose ten yard shot had just enough strength to beat Chernik and roll gently into the net for the goal which means Wales live to fight another day – especially as Belgium lead the Czechs 2-0 as I write this (it finished 3-0 and Wales can move above the Czechs with a game in hand if they beat Estonian on Wednesday)..

Just a few words about other Wales age groups, Cian Ashford played the first half of a very creditable 1-1 draw against their English counterparts at Under 18 level, while there were no Cardiff players in the Under 19 side beaten 3-1 by Austria in the friendly mini tournament they are competing in to leave them without a point from their two matches.

It’s the time of year again when I ask readers of Mauve and Yellow Army to make a contribution towards its running costs. Before I go into detail about this, I should, once again, offer my sincere thanks to all of you who have helped ensure the future of the blog over the past three years through a mixture of monthly payments via Patreon, monthly Standing Orders into my bank account and once a year payments via bank transfer, PayPal, cheque and cash.

The first time I made this request for assistance, it was prompted by a need for funds to pay for three yearly web hosting costs which, frankly, I was in no position to meet following my move of house a few months earlier. However, I’m pleased to say that, this time around, the web hosting bill was settled back in June with none of the problems there were back in 2018.

Therefore, any monies received this year will go towards other running costs and, although it’s too early yet to make any formal commitments despite so many of the pandemic restrictions in Wales being lifted recently, I am minded to do another review of a season from the past book to follow on from “Real Madrid and all that” which looked back on the 1970/71 campaign. At the moment 1975/76, the first promotion season I experienced, looks to be favourite for the book treatment, which would mean a lot more trips back and forth to Cardiff than my finances have become used to over the past year and a half – hopefully, the majority of them will not have to be made via Radyr Cheyne!

As always, the blog will still be free to read for anyone who chooses not to make a donation towards its running costs and, apart from the one in the top right hand corner which is to do with Google Ads, you will never have to bother about installing an ad blocker to read this site because there will never be any.

Finally, as mentioned earlier, donations can be made through Patreon, PayPal, by bank transfer, cheque, Standing Order/Direct Debit and cash, e-mail me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com for further payment details.

Posted in Wales | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Bale makes himself even more of a Welsh legend with hat trick in crucial win.