Seven decades of Cardiff City v Coventry City matches.

Posted on December 28, 2022 by The other Bob Wilson

When Coventry came to Cardiff City Stadium in mid October they were bottom of the table and needed the help of the awful Bobby Madley to win 1-0. The hopeless referee’s disallowing of a Callum Robinson goal should have been the worst injustice City would suffer this season, but, by deeming Robinson being fouled by the goalkeeper in the penalty area and Gary Madine stamping on an opponent to both be worthy of a yellow card in the recent game against Blackpool, Josh Smith surpassed Madley.

That said, Madley’s howler came in a game which Coventry deserved to win for me and it was cleat that their position at the bottom was a false one brought on by them having to postpone a series of early season home matches.

Indeed, Coventry’s form had been so good since then that promotion rather than relegation looks the more likely way for them to get out of the Championship these days – although their upward momentum has stalled somewhat on the back of six goals conceded in their last two games.

Still, a visit from the 22/23 version of Cardiff City is the best cure for any Championship side that has suddenly started conceding goals. We’ve lost our two visits to Coventry by 1-0 since their return to the second tier and could have no complaints about the outcome on either occasion. I wouldn’t be surprised if tomorrow’s game ends up with the same score or maybe Coventry will manage more than just the one – nil seems right for us though.

Here’s the usual quiz on our next opponents, I’ll post the answers on Friday.

60s. This forward spent all of his country playing a hundred miles or more away from his birthplace in the north east of England. The first three letters of his first two clubs were the same, but he enjoyed far more success at the first of them, although his brilliant scoring rate at the second club persuaded Coventry to sign him after less than twenty games for them. He didn’t spend too much time at Coventry either, but he was there long enough to be on the winning side in a game against City. Having had a couple of transfers in just over a year, he was more settled at his next club, spending four years in blue in a side which was becalmed in the second tier throughout that time. The goals did not come as regularly as previously for him, but when he left for a non league club which sounded like it was named after a historic battle, his career goalscoring rate was not far short of a goal every other game, while his record at international level was even better. Who am I describing?

70s. The fact that a sports and school clothing business in Coventry bears his name is purely coincidental, but this midfielder made a positive impact when he began his career with the Sky Blues some three hundred and fifty miles from his birthplace. Early in a new decade, he was on the move after three years at Coventry and he was an unused sub in a European Cup Final for his new club, while he was in their team when they beat Barcelona 3-0. He was unable to establish himself though and, after a loan move to nearby animals, moved out of the Midlands for the first time in his career to join striped birds. Never a prolific scorer, he did manage a novel hat trick when scoring three penalties in a game for his new club, before a move back to one of his former teams and then a loan to Yorkshire, followed by a permanent transfer to footwear specialists. An injury forced his retirement from the game at the age of thirty, but can you name him?

80s. One meanders on a trip to Hartlepool? (4,7)

90s. These three players were all on the books of Premier League Coventry for a season in the mid nineties, but, within five years, they’d all played senior football for Cardiff City – name them?

00s. Who won a single Welsh cap while a Coventry player during this decade and later had three spells at Newport County, one of them while on loan from Eastleigh?

10s. Even more depressed Swansea fan/player maybe?

20s. Rib cake?

Answers

60s. Ray Pointer scored over a hundred goals for Burnley during his seven years with the club. Moving on to Bury in 1965, he scored seventeen times in nineteen league appearances for them before joining Coventry He scored thirteen times in twenty six games for the Sky Blues, but didn’t find the net in their 3-1 win over City in March 1966. Pointer signed for Portsmouth later that year and stayed until 1972, although his games per goal rate dropped to around one in five, he managed to take his career league appearances figure over four hundred before finishing his career with Waterlooville – Pointer scored twice in the three games he played for England while at Burnley.

70s. Andy Blair was born in Kirkcaldy, but moved to Coventry as a child and was in their team as a teenager. Blair was on the bench for Aston Villa’s European Cup win in 1982, but started for them in the European Super Cup win over Barcelona a few months later. Following a loan move to Wolves, Blair signed for Sheffield Wednesday in 1984 before returning to a Villa side now in decline two years later. A loan move to Barnsley followed and Blair played a few games for Northampton before knee problems forced his retirement.

80s. Dean Emerson.

90s. Willie Boland, John Williams and Tony Sheridan – the last named was an Irishman who was on Coventry’s books in 94/95, but never played a game for them. Sheridan was recommended to Coventry by Bobby Gould who came him a chance with City when he was our manager – Sheridan started in the FAW Premier Cup games at Cwmbran and Llanelli in 00/01.

00s. David Pipe played for Wales in a 2-0 defeat to the USA in San Jose in 2003.

10s. Jack Grimmer.

20s. Josh Eccles.

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023 | Tagged | Comments Off on Seven decades of Cardiff City v Coventry City matches.

Flat Boxing Day fare at Cardiff City Stadium – it’d be 0-0 if they were still playing now!

Posted on December 27, 2022 by The other Bob Wilson

I honestly don’t think there’s a great deal I can write about tonight’s 0-0 draw with QPR at Cardiff City Stadium – nothing earth shattering or even original at least. The match just offered further confirmation of what was known already – although it is a bit out of the ordinary for even goal shy Cardiff City not to register a single on target effort in a match.

Thankfully, a welcome clean sheet meant that a QPR side that had won 1-0 on their last two visits to Cardiff did not repeat the feat this time. However, it’s easy to be taken in by the London team’s impressive 1-0 win at Deepdale, Preston in new manager Neil Critchley’s first game in charge, but the blank they shot here in his second one means that it’s just two goals in eight matches for Rangers now and, on this evidence, you can see why.

To be fair, the visitors did have the game’s one on target effort, a weak free kick by Chris Willock from twenty-five yards straight at Ryan Allsop and, if I was to be charitable, you could say that Ethan Laird’s mishit cross that Allsop, opting for safety, turned over his crossbar late on could count as another attempt on target.

For City though there was nothing to work Seny Dieng in the QPR goal – eleven goal attempts offers confirmation that there should have been, but, having admitted for the first time that City could go down this season following last weekend’s 1-1 home draw with Blackpool, there was nothing this evening to make me change that opinion.

This really was like a lot of games we’ve failed to win this season in that we did not get what we deserved from the ninety minutes. Yes, QPR may have forced our keeper into one or two saves, but the better chances were ours. While this was no Blackpool where a confident team used to scoring would have netted three or four, Rangers would have lost this evening against virtually every other team in the Championship if the game had panned out the same way.

The visitors’ best spell came in the twenty minutes or so leading up to the half hour mark when City struggled to cope with the running power of teenager Tim Iroegbunam. Twice Ryan Wintle fouled the Villa loanee as he made runs through the midfield to give QPR shooting opportunities from twenty-five yards out – Kennet Pall was wide with the first one and the second produced that shot from Willock which barely troubled Allsop.

The most dangerous shooting attempt from a free kick came from Rubin Colwill in the early minutes of the game. Yes, having begun to think that City were holding him back until May to protect him from his growing pains, Colwill started tonight!

You only have to have read what I’ve said up to now to realise that Colwill didn’t transform our attacking play – in fact, he probably stood out most for his defensive work and tracking back. However, his free kick was well struck, but never really looked like it was going to curl back on target after starting out a yard or two outside the post.

City’s best first half chances fell to Callum Robinson and Perry Ng from good Wintle crosses, but on neither occasion did their headers threaten the goal – Robinson also sent a snap shot from the edge of the penalty area over, but it was poor fare from both teams in the opening half.

The second half offered more – or at least it did from City. Rangers remained very passive and ended up taking off all of their front three and found themselves increasingly pushed back.

As happens quite often with this City side, they show themselves to be quite good at certain aspects of the game, but it all dissipates once things like neatness in possession and a desire to find space are transferred into our attacking third of the pitch.

Once that happens, you see wrong options taken and poor passing take over. On the occasions when this doesn’t occur and a player is presented with a decent chance, the finishing is not there as the collective lack of confidence which must follow from a scoring record as bad as ours takes over.

It was there when we were able to open up a defence that was the most impressive thing about QPR tonight. Kion Etete, set up by a combination of Callum O’Dowda and Colwill, took a decent touch, but then squeezed his shot a yard wide from about eight yards out. I wouldn’t blame Etete too much for that miss, but when he was presented with a better opportunity by Mahlon Romeo’s header shortly afterwards, his shot from twelve yards was rushed, wild and well over the bar.

It took City about eighty-five minutes to earn their first corner and the unmarked O’Dowda met Joe Ralls’ flag kick with a header that was about was a foot or two wide with replays showing that sub Mark Harris might have been able to turn the ball in if he’d made an effort to reach it.

Rangers woke from their attacking slumbers to give City one or two alarms in added time, but a pretty miserable spectacle ended goalless with the feeling persisting that some of the City sides of recent years with less individual talent than this squad would have found a way to win a match like this 1-0.

After the game, Mark Hudson made optimistic noises as far as matters off and on the pitch are concerned. The off field matter was the embargo the club are under for not paying Nantes the first portion of the Emiliano Sala fee – apparently negotiations are ongoing (he didn’t say with whom) and it seems there’s a chance of the embargo being lifted. That doesn’t sound too convincing to me, but it was compared to the on field stuff our manager came out with.

Here Hudson talked of City showing they can compete against the best teams in the division, but does he really believe QPR, with their recent scoring record, really qualify for such a description? Unfortunately, the most convincing thing Hudson said about City’s performance was that our forward players lacked belief.

Anyway, on to happier times, a further reminder that my book on our 1975/76 promotion is on sale now in paperback form or as an e book – it’s called Tony Evans Walks on Water and can be bought from Amazon at

Posted in Out on the pitch | Tagged | 4 Comments