Wales recover from self inflicted selection wound to stay in running for last sixteen place.

It’s World Cup time again, the three games a day (actually make that four from tomorrow) groups make it a great time for the football fan who has the free time to watch the matches as they come at you thick and fast – there are other considerations with this particular tournament which I’ll come to later mind.

So far, we’ve had host nation Qatar being easily beaten by Ecuador in the opening game, England looking very impressive in thrashing a poor Iran side 6-2 and the Netherlands and Senegal playing out what looked like being a dismal goalless draw until two late errors by Chelsea’s Bernard Mendy handed the Dutch a 2-0 win. Oh, and we’ve also had the USA being held 1-1 by some place called Wales (I’m sure there must have been a few supporters of the opposition who had never heard of us before)!

Now and again as I watched the England and Netherlands matches, I’d have to remind myself that we were playing later on today, but it was only when I saw the team out on the pitch for the national anthem, that it really registered that Wales were part of this thing.

My first ever memory is of a nasty accident that happened to one of the kids at my third birthday party. That would have been some six or seven months after Wales had reached the Quarter Finals of the 1958 World Cup in Sweden, so while I am old enough to have lived through Wales’ first appearance at a World Cup, I have no memory of it whatsoever.

I make this the fifteenth World Cup I’ve watched (the first one was in 1966) and, for the first fourteen, it was a little like looking through a window at a party you weren’t invited to. That didn’t bother me mind because I’d quickly accepted that World Cups were for other countries, not us. If I’m being honest, I’ve never felt the sense of desolation that others have experienced when Wales’ qualification hopes were dashed for another four years because I’ve never had any real expectation that we’d ever make it to one.

I blame Joe Jordan to a large extent for that, the penalty he earned by punching the ball in the Welsh penalty area in 1977 instilled my fatalistic attitude towards Wales and the World Cup – that’s why Paul Bodin’s penalty miss in 1993 did not hurt me as much as it did many others.

Wales didn’t do World Cups in my mind and I long since became reconciled to me never seeing my country play in the sporting world’s greatest tournament.

Then, on a rainy Sunday in June we had more than our fair share of the luck we didn’t usually get in World Cup qualification to beat a country the rest of the world were backing and we were there – as alluded to above, it was only at a minute to seven tonight that I really believed we were mind!

As for the game, it reminded me quite a lot of the 1-1 draw with Switzerland last year to start our second successive Euros off. We were second best for long periods of that game and had to come back from a goal down and it was the same tonight – although, I’d say USA were more dominant in the first half than the Swiss, while our second half fight back was stronger tonight than it was that afternoon in Baku.

There seems to be general agreement that Robert Page got his selection wrong tonight and, believe me or believe me not, that was exactly what I thought when I first saw the team about an hour before kick off.

To me, it looked like a side picked to not lose the game, rather than try to win it – the omission of Keiffer Moore left us without a focal point to play off and was particularly puzzling.

I must admit to not being confident about tonight because America are a young, fit side that presses high up the pitch and we all know that Wales’ two most influential players are, to put it diplomatically, slowing down as they get well into their thirties. Put that with the absence through injury of Joe Allen and we didn’t look well equipped to cope with the American dynamism and pressing.

Apparently, the plan in Moore’s absence was to play around the press, but it never looked like happening. We started slowly and were lucky to get to the ten minute mark with the game still goalless as a below par Joe Rodon headed against Wayne Hennessey and then a few seconds later, Norwich’s Josh Sargent headed against an upright.

America were looking way too quick and powerful for a lethargic Welsh team, but the superiority was not being reflected in terms of serious goalmouth action until Christian Pulisic slid a lovely ball through to Tim Weah, the son of George, who calmly flicked past Hennessey to put his side ahead on thirty six minutes.

It was a question of Wales getting to half time just the one down from there and, having done so, Page brought on Moore for Dan James and the whole game changed. The American centrebacks had an easy time of it for forty-five minutes, but life became a struggle for them after that as Moore occupied them both in the air and on the deck.

With Ethan Ampadu having one of his best games in a Welsh shirt, the midfield was not the disaster area it had been before the break, but, rather like the Americans, there wasn’t a great deal to suggest that Wales could score now that they were beginning to get on top.

Ben Davies did force goalkeeper Matt Turner to tip his header over just after the hour mark and Moore would probably have been disappointed to have headed the resultant Harry Wilson corner just over after getting to the ball in front of Turner, but as the game ticked into the last ten minutes, it was hard to see where an equaliser was going to come from.

However, on eighty-two minutes, the old stagers Ramsey and Bale combined to earn a penalty. Up to then, the challenge of a World Cup had not proved incentive enough for Wales’ best two players to roll back the years. Truth be told, they’d both been pretty anonymous and neither could have had any complaints if they’d been subbed earlier, but Ramsey was able to flick a Brennan Johnson throw in on to Bale who drew centreback Walter Zimmerman into a rash challenge for what was a clear penalty.

Bale nervelessly put away the spot kick after a long delay and Wales might have won it when a cute Moore backheel sent sub Johnson clear down the right, but the angle was always against him and Turner was able to deal with his shot.

Johnson’s shot was one of just three on target efforts by Wales, but that was two more than the USA managed for all of their early superiority and I’d say that, in the end, Wales deserved their draw.

So, where does it leave our group? Wanting England to beat USA on Friday certainly to ensure their qualification before they play us and needing to beat Iran a few hours earlier when the temperature is going to be thirty degrees plus apparently.

If it’s that hot, our team with its combination of injury prone thirty something superstars and a nucleus of players not getting enough regular football will find it tough going. While there are always one or two sides at major tournaments who have a nightmare and perform nowhere near as well as they were expected to and it may be Iran are one of those this time, we can’t expect them to be as bad as England made them look. I think there’s a good chance that qualification in second place may come down to goal difference, but I would still gladly accept a single goal win on Friday.

Talking of Iran, the pleasure of seeing Wales at a World Cup is reduced a little for me because it’s being held where it is and includes countries like Iran with their shameful human rights record. Disgracefully, the corrupt FIFA got itself into a position whereby they were threatening captains of the seven European teams that were planning to have their skippers wear “one love” armbands advocating equality for all regardless of gender, race or sexual orientation with mandatory yellow cards.

This threat did the trick as far as FIFA were concerned and you can understand the seven countries (which included Wales and England) backing down to an extent, but I’d have loved to have seen them force FIFA’s hand by basically telling them to eff off. How would the organisation which only awarded the tournament to Qatar in the first place because of the bungs they received have reacted to that? How could they have reacted given that the consequences of them cracking down like they threatened to would have been disastrous for their gravy train? FIFA in its current incarnation is, hopefully, living on borrowed time and being forced to discipline players for advocating basic human rights would have, surely, accelerated the process.

Away from the World Cup, there’s still plenty of football being played. At the exact time Wales were playing America, City’s under 21s were turning out at Eppleton Colliery Welfare Ground against Sunderland in their latest Premier League Cup game. A couple of goals by Caleb Hughes, the second a free kick from thirty yards, were enough to give us a 2-0 win to follow up on a 4-1 win for the Under 18s at Millwall on Saturday where Cole Fleming, Dylan Lawlor, Tanatswa Nyahuhwah and Cody Twose were the goalscorers.

City’s women’s team continued their unbeaten start to the season on Thursday night with a 9-0 win over Abergavenny Ladies in a game played at Cardiff City Stadium in front of a crowd of over 5,000 – Phoebe Poole got a hat trick, Rihanne Oakley and Eliza Colley got two each and there were also goals for Danielle Green and Eliza Atkins. Then, on Sunday, there was a 3-1 win over Briton Ferry Llansawel in the Adnan Cup with further goals from Poole and Atkins plus one from Megan Bowen.

Also on Sunday, Callum Robinson got the goal as the Republic of Ireland laboured to a 1-0 win in Malta – there was some game time for Callum O’Dowda as well.

In the Hughadmit South Wales Alliance, AFC Porth went down 6-4 at mid table Cardiff Airport in the Premier Division, while Treherbert Boys and Girls Club moved up to fourth in the First Division by winning 6-2 at struggling AFC Whitchurch.

Posted in Football in the Rhondda valleys., Wales, Women's football | Tagged , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Why are Cardiff City so crap at home?

On 16 November 2019 Cardiff City appointed Neil Harris manager to replace Neil Warnock and after a 2-2 draw at Charlton to begin with, he faced successive home games against Stoke and Barnsley. Back in the fairly early days of this blog I mentioned how hopeless City are at winning both matches when they play games at Cardiff City Stadium within three or four days of each other. I’d say that we’ve now made the transition from hopeless to dreadful in that regard, but Harris managed to follow up a 1-0 triumph with a 3-2 beating of Barnsley.

Harris never managed to build the “fortress Cardiff City Stadium” mentality though despite that promising start, but he’s in good company – Mick McCarthy failed, Steve Morison failed and now Mark Hudson is failing.

Since beating Barnsley just under three years ago, there surely cannot be many, if any, teams in the EFL with a worse home record than City. If you include today’s 1-0 loss to Sheffield United, Cardiff have played seventy regular season home league matches since that Barnsley win and their record reads won twenty three, drawn nineteen and lost twenty eight – adding in Play Offs and cup matches doesn’t help matters either because we’ve lost more of those than we’ve won during the time in question.

That really is a record of underachievement made all the more remarkable by its longevity. Lots of teams have the occasional poor season at home, but, following a start which offered hope that they could make playing at home the advantage that it should be, City have now lost more than they’ve won at Cardiff City Stadium in 22/23 and are therefore on course to emulate their “achievement” of 20/21 and 21/22.

In 19/20 City won only four out of thirteen home games after those two initial home wins under Harris, but only two were lost as we secured a Play Off spot.

Since then, it’s been downhill all the way as eight wins and nine defeats in 20/21 was followed by seven wins and twelve defeats in 21/22 and now four wins and five defeats this time around – I find why this should be impossible to explain.

20/21 was the season where crowds were not allowed into games because of Covid and it was noticeable that there were a lot of teams which reacted badly to not having their fans in the ground to the extent that City’s poor home record that season was far from the worst around.

However, things have got worse since then despite having the fans back in the ground. More than half of our home league games were lost last season and we’re now into familiar territory again with today being our third home loss in four games.

Vincent Tan must surely have noticed the differences between what he saw on Tuesday at the Hull defeat and what it was like at the stadium the last time he saw a game there. That was the last home match in our Premier League season in 18/19 when Crystal Palace won here 3-2 to confirm our relegation.

For a start, there were, almost certainly, more than twice as many people in the ground than there was on Tuesday. Of course, such a drop in numbers would have an effect on the level of support the team received but it seems to me that watching what has been three years of failure by your team on its own patch is bound to have made supporters more negative and impatient than they were when we were being relegated with a fair amount of honour intact three and a half years ago.

I’ve heard the usual cliché from the opposition today about “Cardiff is a hard place to go to”, but it isn’t at all, it’s easy and has been for years!

For example, Sheffield United went to the top of the table with their win today, so it’s not as if we were beaten by a bunch of mugs, but this was a Blades team very heavily hit by injuries which lost another player, Jack Robinson, through injury inside the first ten minutes.

Despite this, the visitors were in complete control for nearly all of the second half this afternoon. It was embarrassing at times how much Sheffield were on top and I seriously doubt that a City player touched the ball in the opposition penalty in the thirty minutes after the restart.

What happened in the second forty five minutes was in complete contrast to what went on in the first forty five. City were never as dominant as their opponents became, but all of the worthwhile chances were theirs and I can’t help thinking that the huge majority of sides in this division would have found a way to take advantage of one of them.

Visiting goalkeeper Was Fotheringham could only wave at Ryan Wintle’s beautifully struck twenty five yarder which flew less than a yard wide and he’d also given up on Callum Robinson’s header a few minutes later which went a foot wide.

However, Robinson really should have scored and the same applied seconds before the half time whistle when Mark Harris was presented with a great chance by defender Steve Balham, but the striker’s touch wasn’t sure enough and when Robinson tried to follow up, his effort was blocked.

Too often, City were let down by anxious touches in promising positions and this led to rushed, off target goal attempts – it was all completely typical of a side with the worst goalscoring record in their division.

It was all change from the moment Cedric Kipre passed straight to Sheffield sub James McAtee in the opening minutes of the second half to present the visitors with their best chance so far. That opportunity was botched, but Sheffield drew strength from the incident and City were placed under intense pressure for the next ten minutes. The home side were lucky to come through a series of free kicks and corners where Sheffield players got their heads on the ball first unscathed.

While City we’re still definitely second best, there were signs that they were lifting the siege somewhat around the hour mark, only for them to then concede the winner to an unusual source when right wing back George Baldock burst past a weak challenge from Neils N’Kounkou to fire a fierce low shot past Ryan Allsop on his near post.

Ordinarily, questions would be asked about a goalkeeper being beaten in the way Allsop was, but, for me, the power of Baldock’s shot was the main factor in beating the keeper and I don’t think he could be blamed for it.

In fact, I’d say there were a couple of good saves by the City keeper which kept his side in the game after they went a goal down. At the time, it didn’t seem to be make too much difference such was Sheffield’s dominance, but in the closing stages there were a couple of presentable chances for sub Sheyi Ojo.

I wouldn’t blame Ojo much for failing to score with a header when completely unmarked some teelve yards out, but he should have done better than jab his first time shot wide when Mahlon Romeo’s pull back found him in a similar position deep into added time.

While the likes of Kipre can get away with a bad error these days, it seems that when N’Kounkou and Ojo make them they nearly always cost us and with us now just a point off the drop zone, I look forward to players like Rubin Colwill, Isaak Davies and Joel Bagan being fit enough to feature regularly after the World Cup, because we’re carrying one or two passengers at the moment.

After the Hull game, Vincent Tan wondered about a Welsh millionaire taking over the club and talked about how we could reach the Play Offs and could end up winning them with a bit of luck. Now, I’ve defended this squad and said they aren’t as bad as some make them out to be, but we’re no way a top six side – how can we be when we’re the lowest scoring side in the Championship and we lose more than we win at home?

Relegation is a far, far more likely outcome than promotion for this squad, but I’m still confident they’ll stay up. However, if it doesn’t happen this season, we’re going to get relegated soon if you keep on running the club as it has been in the last few years Mr Tan. If money is too tight to bring in better players, then at least get someone in who knows more about football than the current hierarchy at the club does and, although, you clearly do not want to, I can’t help feeling that you have got to stop appointing managers from within the club.

A little bit of good news was that the under 18s picked up a good win as they came from 1-0 and 2-1 down to win 3-2 at Coventry – Morgan Lewis, Gabriele Biancheri with a penalty and Trey George scored the goals.

In the Highadmit South Wales Alliance League, AFC Porth’s struggles continued in the Premier Division with a 5-0 home defeat by Tonyrefail Boys and Girls Club, while Treherbert Boys and Girls Club scraped past bottom of the First Division Penrhiwceiber AFC 2-1 at home.

As mentioned this time last year, I decided to do another review of a season to follow on from Real Madrid and all that which was about 1970/71. This one is about the 1975/76 season and will be called Tony Evans walks on water. I finished writing the book over the weekend and now it’s a question of tidying it up, proof reading, inserting a few photos and designing a cover  before sending it off for printing.

As always, the blog will still be free to read for anyone who chooses not to make a donation towards its running costs and, apart from the one in the top right hand corner which is to do with Google Ads, you will never have to bother about installing an ad blocker to read this site because there will never be any.

Donations can be made through Patreon, PayPal, by bank transfer, cheque, Standing Order/Direct Debit and cash, e-mail me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com for further payment details.

Can I end by thanking all of you who read and contribute towards the blog in the Feedback section, but, in particular, a big thank you to all who have donated in the past and continue to do so now.

Posted in Football in the Rhondda valleys., Out on the pitch, The kids. | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments