Seven decades of Cardiff City v Reading matches.

City’s best twenty four hours of 2023 so far concluded with defeats at Swansea and Stoke respectively for Blackpool and Huddersfield, two of the three sides below us in the table. Wigan, the other team in the relegation places, followed up their vital win over Huddersfield (to be managed by Neil Warnock from this weekend) with a good 1-1 draw at in form Bristol City, but the opportunity is there for City to put real distance between themselves and the bottom three with a won over Reading tomorrow at Cardiff City Stadium.

Reading have a poor away record, but that is counterbalanced by us being probably the team with the worst home record in the EFL over the past three seasons and the fact that Reading very rarely lose in Cardiff these days.

Unfortunately, Sky coverage means a Friday night kick off at 8 pm (can’t ever remember us kicking off a home game that late before in my time supporting the club),. Therefore, the answers to the questions below will be posted on here on Saturday morning.

60s. A forward born not too far from Reading in a place where City almost came a cropper in the First Round of the FA Cup once, he did well enough at Elm Park with his first club, to get himself a move to the Second Division to a club which was so right for someone with his surname. He was able to maintain the scoring rate of around a goal every three games that he enjoyed at Reading with his new club, but when they were promoted, he dropped out of first team contention and ended up on loan to a Fourth Division side quite nearby that got him wearing blue again after a few seasons in a completely different colour. . he. stayed in blue at his next club where, again, he didn’t have to travel too far and, if anything, his strike rate improved, but not by enough to prevent his side being relegated to the fourth tier. During this time, he was frequently loaned to American clubs during the summer and he also returned to Reading temporarily. There was also a loan to a side from the north of England that played in a blue and white combination. He finally moved to the USA permanently, but it did not go well for him in the capitol and he was soon back in England playing in a team managed by Ron Atkinson. Once again though, his stay was only a brief one and he finished his playing days with a team which no longer exists, but, briefly, made it into the Football League – the modern day version of the club play on an artificial pitch and look like they will be dropping further away from the EFL at the end of the season. Can you name the player described?

70s. This forward cum midfielder was clearly rated highly in his early days as a footballer as future European Cup winners, First Division Champions and FA Cup winners all gave him a contract, but, after not playing a league match for any of the three, his first team debut came at Nuneaton Borough. However, his form in the part time game attracted the interest of Football League clubs and he was able to eke out a journeyman’s career in the lower divisions over a dozen years. He played his first Football league games at a club which has changed its mind over a letter “S” down the decades and he experienced a managerial great in action in his first job. He then moved on to Reading for four years into the early seventies with his most notable feat being his Player of the season award – ironically, shortly after receiving the award, he scored the own goal that relegated Reading to Division Four! He played most games (over one hundred and twenty of them) for his final club and had Neil Warnock as a team mate for a while. He also wore their red twice against City and was a scorer of a late winning goal against us at the play area which was home to them, but his second encounter with us ended in 1 -0 defeat at Ninian Park on a bone hard pitch. Can you name him?

80s. This Lancashire born forward’s first football was, in fact, played in the stockbroker belt at non league level, but the game then took a back seat for a while until a very brief, but noteworthy in terms of goalscoring, few games for Reading. His football career really took off at his next club after an obstacle to his progress in the game was removed and his exploits with this team earned him a big money move to a side which wore the same colours in combination if not identical kits. The next two years saw three loan moves and a bit of a stalling in his career before a move to the capital to play in the same colour combination which could not be called a success either. It was his next move, to male animals, that saw him make a big impact and he was soon the subject of a six figure transfer to a club where I recently saw him on a You Tube video of a game which saw him sent off and then trying to climb the walls of the players tunnel as he left the pitch in an attempt to get at supporters who were giving him stick! A move to his native county was next as he kept on scoring goals at a good rate and he made it into the new Millennium with stripy scamps before ending his Football League career on the south coast. Who is he?the

90s. Robot many use with Welsh house. (6,5)

00s. Speculation on “the man in the street”?

10s. He played for City against Reading during this decade and is currently in Clover with the Queen – who?

20s. Unholy Promises once at Reading, now Cambridge.

Answers.

60s. Peter Silvester signed for Norwich (Sylvester was a cartoon cat that was always trying to, unsuccessfully, catch a canary named Tweety) from Reading and, after a loan spell at Colchester, signed a permanent deal with Southend. Silvester was loaned out Reading and Blackburn during the four years he spent at Roots Hall as well as various American clubs and he eventually signed for one of them, Washington Diplomats, permanently. Within a few months though, Silvester was back in England playing, briefly, for Ron Atkinson’s Cambridge United and then there was a short spell with Maidstone United

70s. Terry Bell had spells with Forest, Man City and Portsmouth before turning up at Nuneaton after being released by all three of them. Bell played under Brian Clough at Hartlepool(s) before signing for Reading in 1969 and he was their Player of the Year in 70/71. His final club was Aldershot and he was in their sides which played us during the 75/76 season.

80s. Phil Stant played for Camberley Town before being drafted to the Falklands to fight in the 1982 war. Upon his return, Stant scored twice in four matches for Reading before Hereford United bought him out of the army to give him a contract. Stant’s goals got him a move to Notts County, but it needed a drop into the fourth tier with Mansfield to begin the phase of his career where goals came most frequently for him. Stant signed for City around Christmas 1992 and had a tempestuous, but successful, stay at Ninian Park. His two and a half years with City took in a game at Stockport in 1995 when he was sent off and then tried to climb over the players tunnel wall to get at the home fans who were taunting him. Stant signed for Bury after City, then played for Lincoln (where he was manager for a short while) and Brighton before playing for a variety of non league sides (two of which he also managed) over the next few years.

90s.  Martyn Booty.

00s. (Average) Joe Gamble.

10s. Adam Matthews plays for Cypriot side AC Omonia which has two nicknames, the Clover and the Queen.

20s. Unholy and Promises are, apparently, songs by Sam Smith whose namesake is a footballer who played for Reading and is currently at Cambridge United.

.

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023, Out on the pitch | Comments Off on Seven decades of Cardiff City v Reading matches.

Thankfully, Cardiff City stumble at the final hurdle in their longest run without a win pursuit!

“What takes from Bonfire Night to St. Valentines Day?” sounds like the first line of what could be a brilliant joke, but the punch line of “Cardiff City to win a game.” would be likely to draw bemused looks from most people – for a few thousand from south Wales though it would bring a satisfied smile.

City’s bid to equal the club record for the longest run without a win failed well into the final stretch tonight as they completed a double over Birmingham City with a 2-0 victory at St Andrews to leave them one short of the fifteen which would have given those involved not immortality, but notoriety.

It was surely inevitable that when a win finally came, it would not arrive with a footballing classic, it would be scruffy, mostly dull and probably by 1-0 and it was all of those things except for the suggested scoreline because we managed a second in the fifth of six minutes of added time.

In fact, for eighty-four minutes, I was thinking I was watching a kind of replay of the recent away games at Blackburn, Luton and Hull – all matches of low quality that the home team edged by a single second half goal.

We were well in all three of those matches, but it’s probably true to say that we didn’t deserve to get more than a single point out of them. Tonight though, I think we were deserved winners even if for most of the time, a goal looked as far away as ever in this season which seems set to see a record low scoring total for a campaign of forty games plus – it may well turn out to be our worst in seasons with less matches than that as well.

It’s been a bit of a mystery to me as to why City have made so little use of a three central defenders system in this season of struggle and tonight I was pleased and surprised to see that Sabri Lamouchi went with what was very close to the team I would have selected. A back three of Perry Ng, Cedric Kipre and Mark McGuinness were flanked by wing backs Mahlon Romeo and Callum O’Dowda. There was a midfield three of Romaine Sawyers, Andy Rinomhota and Ryan Wintle and Sory Kaba and Kion Etete formed a two man attack (I would have had Callum Robinson in for Etete).

Going with two big men up front predictably led to a more direct approach and the sight of Ryan Allsop coming up to the halfway line to take long free kicks into the Birmingham box was a depressing sight for me because it was a throwback to a type of football I’d hoped we’d left behind us..

I’ll come back to talking about our play at the top end of the pitch later, but I must say that at the other end, three at the back definitely worked as I cannot remember a more comfortable away game defensively for us all season.

A feature of this season has been the number of times I have related that there were only one or two occasions when we looked like we might score, but, this time, the boot was on the other foot – Joe Ralls, on as a sub, made a great late block to foil young Welshman Jordan James when a Birmingham equaliser looked inevitable, Troy Deeney had the ball in our net, but was, rightly, ruled offside and I started getting twitchy when the towering Lukas Jutkiewicz moved his position to target Ng rather McGuinness, but the only home on target effort of the game came when his header had most of the pace taken off it by a defensive block and Allsop saved easily.

That was it really, City were in charge against a side that had scored six in winning their last two matches against Swansea and West Brom.

There were signs why the home side had scored so often recently because there were flashes of play suggesting that they could pass the ball at pace just around our penalty area, but there was not the necessary accuracy from them most of the time and on the others, there was always a grey shirt there to break things up when Birmingham looked like clicking into gear.

That’s not to say it was a packed City defence throughout. The two wing backs were very willing to get forward and prompt attacks – Romeo in particular was adventurous and it was a good run by O’Dowda which won the free kick that produced the opening goal.

So, I’d say the system worked well, but I have to qualify that by adding that the wing backs’ sense of adventure was not reflected by the goalmouth action it produced. The long ball approach saw us as toothless as normal with Kaba and Etete being dominated in the air and it was invariably a home player who got his head on the ball when our big men from the back came up for set pieces.

Kaba, who certainly likes a spectacular volley, was well off target with his first attempt at one in an opening half almost devoid of action. His second attempt was closer, but, in truth, it still ended up yards wide and then his more conventional third effort from a Wintle free kick flashed a foot over after a much better connection.

That was, far and away the closest we came to seeing an end to the stalemate until our first goal arrived very late on, but Connor Wickham, who finally completed his free agent transfer today, made an encouraging first contribution within seconds of coming on with Robinson to form a new front two with a good turn and shot which finally forced home keeper John Ruddy into action.

City were able to get the ball down and play a little bit in the game’s final quarter and began to take control of the midfield as a result, but, I must be honest and say I was settling for a 0-0 even when we were awarded that eighty fourth minute free kick on the edge of the penalty area for the aforementioned foul on O’Dowda.

My lack of expectation only grew when I saw that it was Ng who was going to take the free kick, but, as the saying goes, oh ye of little faith! Ng stepped up and curled his shot high and wide of Ruddy right up into the corner of the goal that he was never going to reach – the best compliment I can pay the scorer is to say it was like watching a right footed Whittingham!

Understandably given the run they were on, City concentrated on preserving their lead after that and were very grateful to Ralls following their one piece of unconvincing defending of the night.

There was another goal though when, rather than head for the corner flag, Robinson took a pass from Wickham, dribbled past two defenders and scored with a shot which probably left Ruddy very annoyed at being beaten on his near post.

It was good to see Allsop running the length of the pitch to join in with the wild celebrations in front of the City fans as it suggests that at least the spirit in the squad is strong for the battles to come, but this one only lasted a few seconds more after Birmingham restarted and finally City have the win which, surely, could not have been delayed much longer.

The first team’s result was not the one which ended the run of eleven consecutive defeats the seniors, under 21 and Academy sides had been on mind as last night, the under 21s drew 2-2 at Swansea. Darren Purse’s side trailed for much of the game, but sub Morgan Wigley equalised with about a quarter of an hour left, then a Gavin Whyte free kick put us ahead a few minutes later, only for Swansea to level things up shortly afterwards.

A couple of other things to report as well. First, I make no apologies for repeating the message of my last posit on here about Jason Bowen;

“This morning the Supporters’ Trust have sent out the following message to members;-

Dear Member,

As you may know former City stalwart Jason Bowen has been diagnosed with Motor Neurone Disease. In order to raise funds to support the ongoing cost of Jason’s treatment the Club are organising a bucket collection prior to kick off of the Reading home game on 17th February. The club are looking for volunteers to assist with the collection. If you would like to help out please meet at the Fred Keenor Statue at 6pm.

Alternatively, contributions can be made directly to Jason’s GoFundMe page a link to which can be found below

https://www.gofundme.com/f/jason-bowens-motor-neurone-disease-treatment

Keith Morgan

Chair

I’m putting the message on here for readers who are not Trust members and had not been aware of the news of Jason’s diagnosis with this awful condition which broke last week.

As someone who is firmly in the give ex players space camp, I’ve never met Jason, but have often seen him down the years at Academy and Under 21s games watching his son’s Jaye and Sam playing for City – he was a great servant to the club and deserves the support of all City fans at this difficult time, I hope you can make a contribution either on Friday night or via the GoFundMe page above,”

Also, there are still a few signed copies of my latest book “Tony Evans Walks on Water” available from the Trust Office (near Gate 5) on matchdays at the reduced price of £9 for Trust members.

Posted in Cardiff City Books, Out on the pitch, The stiffs | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Thankfully, Cardiff City stumble at the final hurdle in their longest run without a win pursuit!