We do have a reserve team after all……………..

they’ve played twice this week and I can’t avoid this feeling that they’ll be in action again next Saturday. Not too much on yesterday’s match from me because my second visit of the season to Spytty Park to watch a Newport County match meant that, apart from what was shown on the telly last night, I  have not seen, heard or read anything about it, so, I’ll just make a few general observations.

Firstly, it’s somehow typically Cardiff City that having brought in three or four top class players during the summer who had independent observers agreeing that we had one of the strongest squads, if not the strongest squad, in the Championship, we now find ourselves in a position where none of these players who were supposed to make the difference for us are in the starting line up because of injury or lack of match fitness. I still can’t get my head around all the injuries we are getting and, to repeat what I said on here after the Leicester match, it certainly begs questions about how training is structured on an individual and team basis at the club.

On top of that, the case of Danny Drinkwater has me wondering at the level of professionalism at Cardiff City. Dave Jones has said that the club weren’t aware of the player’s previous problems with the sort of thigh injury he is now suffering from but couldn’t someone have asked Drinkwater about previous injuries when he first signed for us ? Now, I accept that such a question might not have got an honest answer from a player who didn’t want to give the manager a ready made excuse to leave him out of the side, but a simple search for “Danny Drinkwater Huddersfield injury” on Google brought back  a couple of hits – the first being a very good thread about him on a Manchester United messageboard which mentions this story concerning the thigh injury he picked up at Huddersfield last season. Surely someone at the club could have done the same sort of Internet search beforehand and spoke to the player and Manchester United about whether his training needed to be structured in some way to reduce the chances of the injury recurring?

The other point I would make is about Dave Jones comments on Adam Matthews which, again, showed his tendency to name and blame younger players when they make mistakes, but not criticise senior players individually when they mess up. Of course Matthews was at badly at fault for his own goal yesterday, but to single him out for losing out to a very powerful player for the second goal seems very unfair to me and if questions are to be asked it should be concerning the centrebacks and, in particular, Mark Hudson’s part in the goal.

Finally on yesterday’s match, the side we have put out in our last two matches is one that has the look of mid table Championship team to it (it’s a worse side than last season’s), so should we really be too upset and/or surprised when it produces the sort of results and performances you would expect from such an outfit?

Moving on from the first team to our youngsters. I went to watch the Academy match with Fulham yesterday and I’m afraid that this season shows all the signs of turning into a long and hard one, in terms of results at least, for the Under 18’s. Yesterday’s 2-1 defeat was their fourth in five competitive matches so far and, in the early stages especially, it was one way traffic as Fulham created chance after chance. After a while though City managed to gain a foothold in the game and, although it was hard to see where a goal was going to come from, they were competing well when they fell behind in unlucky fashion as a shot from the Fulham centre forward rebounded off the post back onto his knee and into the net past a helpless Reece Ottley.

That was the only goal of the first half and at half time I decided to watch the Under 16s for a change and so only really got to have  a look at the Under 18s when there was a break in the play in the game I was watching. From what I saw though, the City team made a much better fist of it after the break as virtually every time I looked, it was them who were attacking. Sadly, the only exception to that rule came as I saw Fulham double their lead with another close in finish from their centre forward, but a couple of excellent long range efforts from Ibby Farah saw the first well tipped over by the Fulham keeper while the second rebounded off the underside of the crossbar back into play only for the loose ball to be headed over from a good position by one of our centrebacks.

There were other close misses as well, but the game was beyond City by the time Joe Ralls scored following a long throw in with the match going into it’s last minute. Not a bad performance overall then, but, unlike in previous years, I’ve not seen a player new to the team who strikes me as being a possible first teamer of the future – Farah is a good player at this level now, Ottley isn’t a bad keeper and Nat Jarvis is going to be available again soon, but they were with us last season and the new intake doesn’t look up to their levels at the moment. That’s not to say that there aren’t some promising first year scholars at the Academy – I was impressed by Oshilaja at right back yesterday and goalscorer Ralls has something about him, but based on what I have seen so far, the 10/11 crop of youngsters doesn’t compare too well with other years.

As for the Under 16’s, they drew 2-2 in an entertaining game which  saw the visitors finish much the stronger and so they would probably feel, with some justification, that they deserved the win. However,  the Under 16s certainly had their chances and if they could have got 3-1 up then I think they would have gone on to win and they certainly had two or three players who looked like they may develop into something.

Sorry that I don’t have any names here because it was the first time I had seen any of them play, but it was hard not to notice the giant ginger haired centre half who, for obvious reasons, brought James Collins to mind – his game was a mixture of good and bad really with him being largely responsible for Fulham’s second equaliser, but there were also some moments of quality and skill, which coming from someone as gangly as him, surprised me. Others who took my eye were the number six in midfield who played one or two very nice passes while the two wide players provided a decent service to the lone striker who didn’t do badly against a couple of centrehalves who were bigger than him.

After that, it was on to Newport to watch County take on a Mansfield side who were occupying one of the Play Off positions going in to the game. With the match pitting the Holdsworth twins against each other as rival managers, there was also a chance that it would prove to be a feisty affair and, with a referee who had you realising that the officials you see every week in the Championship aren’t quite as bad as you sometimes think they are, there was too much whistle for it ever to be a really entertaining match.

Both sides finished with ten men and if you had told Keigan Parker ten years or so ago when great things were being predicted for him as a kid in the St. Johnstone side that in September 2010 he would be getting sent off for a petulant retaliation shortly after coming off the bench  while playing for Mansfield Town at Spytty Park, Newport in a Blue Square Conference match then he would have thought you were mad. That’s what a career that promised an awful lot has come to though – as someone once said to George Best, “where did it all go wrong?”!

The game was decided by a tremendous shot from Gary Rose on the hour following Newport’s first corner of the game and, with the prolific Craig Reid having hit the post in the first half, it was probably a deserved lead at the time but Mansfield reacted very strongly after Parker’s red card and probably deserved a point from the game by the end.

One of the reasons they didn’t get the draw though was that Martin John, in his second County match after signing on loan from us, got back to clear a shot off the line with impressive home keeper Glyn Thompson beaten. Although he got done by his winger once, John had a good game – I thought he was one of Newport’s best players and he looked confident and assured in most of what he did. On this evidence, he is comfortably good enough for the Conference and I see no reason why he cannot play a big part in what is looking more and more like a challenge for a Play Off spot from Dean Holdsworth’s enterprising team over the coming months.

Posted in General football stuff, Out on the pitch, The kids. | Tagged , , , , | 6 Comments

Did Alan Lee keep Dave Jones in his job?

The Cardiff City v Ipswich Town match on 24 November 2007 was just ten seconds old when home captain Darren Purse slipped when going to intercept what should have been a straightforward long ball forward. Purse’s error left ex City striker Alan Lee in the clear as on loan keeper Kasper Schmeichel advanced more in hope than anticipation of making a save. It looked odds on that City would go 1-0 down to what would probably have been the quickest goal ever scored at Ninian Park with only Lee’s iffy record as a finisher during his spell with us offering any hope to anxious supporters. In the event, Lee did miss his gilt edged chance, but, in his defence, he was very unlucky as his lob beat Schmeichel, glanced off the crossbar as it dropped and then bounced back into play off the upright.

Lee’s shot had managed to hit the woodwork in two different places (something which he could probably not manage to do again if he was given a thousand goes at it) and the home crowd breathed a sign of relief, but I wouldn’t mind betting that this was as of nothing compared to what Dave Jones must have felt like at the time.

The summer of 2007 had seen what had become the usual big money transfer out of the club – this time it was Michael Chopra to Sunderland in a deal worth up to £5 million. City didn’t spend a single penny of this money in transfer fees and yet they went into the new season with a sense of optimism not seen since the spendthrift early days of the Sam Hammam era. The reason for this was that the club paid very high wages to entice big name veterans Trevor Sinclair, Jimmy-Floyd Hasselbaink and Robbie Fowler to Cardiff where they joined other Bosman signings Tony Capaldi, Gavin Rae and Steve MacLean.

The signing of Fowler in particular created great public interest which was reflected in the enormous number of number eight shirts bearing the words Fowler and/or God sold  by the club in August and September of that year. Like so many purchases that seemed like a good idea at the time though, they quickly became something of a source of embarrassment as, after showing promise when he finally got himself something like match fit, our marquee signing became a very expensive drain on the club’s resources as he played no part at all in about two thirds of the season – all of this despite constant reports from City staff and the local media that Fowler was looking “sharp in training”!

Fowler’s struggles mirrored those of the team – with Sinclair also spending most of his time in the treatment room, it was only the canny but largely immobile Hasselbaink of the three expensive veterans who was providing anything like value for money as City found wins very hard to come by. QPR and Norwich were beaten on their own grounds by September 1, but after that there had been just the one victory (at home to Burnley) in twelve league matches as the natives grew increasingly restless with a side that was failing to play to it’s potential in all areas of the pitch. Of course, the man who had put this misfiring team together was far from immune from criticism and things came to a head when the visiting support turned on the manager and players when City were beaten 3-0 at Charlton in a match that was as one sided as the scoreline suggests it was.

Only goal difference was keeping City out of the bottom three at that time and so it was not too much of  a surprise when some of the Monday morning national papers were reporting that the decision had been taken to relieve Dave Jones of his job. Although Peter Ridsdale was later to deny that sacking our manager was ever an option at the time, the old adage about there being no smoke without fire seems entirely appropriate here and I will always believe that there was more to those stories about Dave Jones’ days at Cardiff being numbered than just media guesswork. Whatever the truth though, Mr Ridsdale told a meeting of supporters on the following Monday evening that  Dave Jones was staying but this didn’t stop the rumour growing that Dave Jones had been told that he had two matches to save his job.

A fortnight’s break for International games between the Charlton defeat and the Ipswich match took the heat off Dave Jones a little by the time the team were in action again, but I am sure that the mood would have started to turn ugly very quickly if Lee’s lob had gone in instead of bouncing to safety -with the side’s confidence being so low, there has to be a doubt whether they would have recovered from going a goal down so quickly. In the event though, a Jekyll and Hyde Ipswich side that almost entirely owed it’s place in the Play Off positions at that time to their 100% home record (they had only four draws to show from their eight away matches), barely threatened again after that as City gradually took command of the game. In saying that though, a Steve Thompson effort that produced a smart stop from popular former City favourite Neil Alexander in the visitor’s goal was the only direct threat to Ipswich until City took the lead around the half hour mark with a goal completely out of keeping with the generally poor quality of the game.

A sweeping length of the field counter attack was started by Capaldi who fed the ball on to Thompson who showed great touch and awareness to find Gavin Rae bursting forward. Rae took the ball on to Paul Parry who showed why Dave Jones has always been keen on playing left footed attackers on the right and vice versa by cutting inside and drilling a left shot from the edge of the penalty area past Alexander and into the net. City spent the rest of the first half on top as they searched for what would surely have been a decisive second goal, but the second period offered mediocre fare as both teams tended to cancel each other out – Parry did make himself a hero at the other end of the pitch as well by blocking a Tommy MIller effort on the line, but City held on to their lead to record a vital win. When Schmeichel’s heroics earned them a goalless draw in a televised match at Leicester two days later, the two games Dave Jones had, apparently, been given to save himself had passed off almost as well as he could have hoped for.

Despite an awful performance and result in the next home game as Charlton barely broke sweat in winning their return fixture with us, the threat to Dave Jones’ job seemed to pass after that. The Ipswich win was one of four home matches over the next couple of months decided in our favour by single goals around the thirty minute mark and these were the foundation for an improvement over the second half of the campaign which saw us finish comfortably in mid table while reaching the FA Cup Final. Although the signing of the three veterans had to be viewed as an expensive flop, the goals of Parry and Joe Ledley, the excellence of Loovens and Johnson at centreback and the emergence of the highly talented Aaron Ramsey all helped to ensure that Dave Jones’ hold on the manager’s job has never been remotely under the same sort of threat that it was when Alan Lee’s lob hit the woodwork nearly three years ago.

24 November 2007

Cardiff City 1 Ipswich Town 0

City Schemichel; Gunter, Loovens, Purse, Capaldi; Parry (1), Rae, McPhail, Ledley (Whittingham); Hasselbaink, Thompson (Johnson); Subs (not used) Oakes, McNaughton, MacLean

Ipswich Alexander; Wright, Bruce, DeVos, Harding; Walters, Miller, Garvan (Clarke), Williams; Counago (Haynes), Lee; Subs (not used) Supple, Wilnis, Legwinski

HT 1-0

Att. 15,173

Posted in Memories, 1963 - 2023 | Tagged , , | 4 Comments