Weekly review 12/7/24.

Finally, some transfer news to convey with City, seemingly, on the brink of announcing the arrival of two players, both of whom I’d rate at a higher level than I was expecting from us this summer.

The first one to emerge was QPR forward Chris Willock who was strongly linked with City on Wednesday. The rumour gathered pace an hour or two later when QPR confirmed that Willock had left the club after his contract had expired and talks about him renewing his deal had failed to reach a positive conclusion.

After that, the links with City only grew stronger and major outlets like the BBC were soon reporting that it was, to all intents and purposes, a done deal. Given that Erol Bulut has also talked about what he thought Willock can bring to his team, it’s clear that the deal is definitely on, but, surprisingly, it hasn’t been confirmed yet.

Willock is twenty six and can play on both wings or as an attacking central midfielder. As is the case with most signings City, as a Championship club, make, there is an element of risk involved in the transfer. Willock has a patchy fitness record and his figures in terms of goals scored and created have not been as good as they were in the first half of his four years with the Shepherd’s Bush club.

However, this drop in output came from a very high peak. In 21/22, Willock scored seven times and provided an assist for another eleven in his thirty five appearances for QPR and he and Ilias Chair were regarded as being among the Championship’s most creative attacking midfield pairings.

Willock started his career with Arsenal and gained some first team experience with them when playing in the League Cup – also making an impression on Arsene Wenger to the extent that the former Gunners manager described him as a “very interesting” player. Willock signed for Benfica after leaving Arsenal, but played only B team football for the Portuguese team over the next three seasons, while also being kept waiting for a first team start while with West Brom on loan. Ironically, when Willock did play some senior football during another loan spell, at Huddersfield, one of the two goals he scored for the Yorkshire team came against the Baggies.

Willock signed for QPR for a reported fee of £750,000 in October 2020 and his first goal came against us in a 1-0 win for QPR at Cardiff City Stadium three months later in what was Neil Harris’ last game as City manager. Willock played a total of 144 games for QPR (40 of them as a sub) in all competitions and scored 20 times for them.

The obligatory highlights video for Willock is impressive and, notwithstanding that injury record and his drop in output recently, I think it’s fair to say that, this time at least, the talk that City have beaten a few other interested clubs to capture a player’s signature has some truth in it.

Back in 2014, Calum Chambers was 19 years old and winning his 3 England caps while also earning a big money move from Southampton to Arsenal. Obviously, the fact that he looks to be signing for a Championship side before he has turned 30 suggests that things have not quite gone as predicted for Chambers since then, but, if he does sign for us (he was reportedly taking a medical yesterday), it will be the first time he has played outside the Premier League in his career.

Chambers started out with Southampton, but only played just over twenty matches for them before signing for Arsenal where he played around 120 times in all competitions over a period of eight years. There were a couple of loan moves for him during this time, both for seasons with sides that ended up being relegated -Middlesbrough in 17/18 and then he spent the next season at Fulham.

It was during his spell at Craven Cottage that the game i remember most from his career was played. Chambers started at right back at Cardiff City Stadium in October 2018 and Josh Murphy gave him a very torrid afternoon in a match which we ended up winning 4-2 – I say a torrid afternoon, but in. fact it only lasted twenty six minutes for him as he was withdrawn. The early change was described as being down to injury at the time, but there were plenty present that day, who will always believe that it was down to Fulham throwing the towel in so to speak in that particular contest.

I should say here that, even if Chambers’ withdrawal that afternoon was tactical, he recovered to the extent that, while best known for playing centreback or right back, his switch to a central midfield role for the rest of that season saw him winning Fulham’s Player of the Season award for a side that finished below as both teams dropped back into the Championship.

Chambers left Arsenal in January 2022 to sign for Aston Villa on a free transfer and had played for them thirty times by the end of 23/24. Back in January, Villa manager Unai Emery said Chambers was free to leave the club and, apparently, we were interested in taking him on then, only for him to opt to stay and fight for a first team place – an injury crisis meant that Chambers was able to get back into first team contention at Villa for the closing games of the season.

Again, there are questions which arise with a signing like this, because it seems pretty clear now that Chambers will never hit the sort of heights that were being predicted for him a decade ago, but I go back to that stat about him having played all of his career in the Premier League – for me, it’s a compelling argument when it comes to this signing. While the fact Chambers only made five appearances for Villa last season suggests that now is the right time fot that proud record to end, you’d like to think that, even if he is not the player he once was, he would still fall into the category of a good Championship performer.

It seems that there could be a third newcomer announced in the next day ro two, but, sticking with the two that would appear to be signing for us, a common connection between them is Arsenal – Aaron Ramsey may not have had the hoped for impact on the pitch last season and, at the moment, it’s hard to see him doing so in 24/25 either, but I wonder if he has played a part in attracting Chris Willock and Calum Chambers to the club?

Meanwhile, the first team have begun their warm up games. Bath City were beaten 5-1 in a behind closed doors game last Saturday with Kion Etete (2), Yakou Meite, David Turnbull with a penalty and Dimitri Goutas scoring the goals, but there was a 1-0 defeat at Leckwith to Kidderminster Harriers in the first open to the public match on Wednesday evening.

Ramsey (who was at Wimbledon), Horvarth, Ng, Romeo, Collins, O’Dowda, King and Etete were among the players missing for various reasons from the Kidderminster game which, like so many early pre season friendly encounters, was in reality two matches of forty five minutes with both teams making eleven changes at half time.

In many ways, the game(s) was like so many we’ve seen at Cardiff City Stadium in the last four years with the away side scoring before half time and then hanging on to their 1-0 lead in the face of not very effective Cardiff pressure through the second period. City had their best attacking moments while it was still 0-0, but, Isaak Davies missed the sort of chance I’d back him to score from 8 times out of 10 because of a poor first touch after being put through by Rubin Colwill and it was the full Wales international who came closest to scoring with a shot from 18 yards which hit the upright.

The only goal came in the minute before half time when Jak Alnwick made a good save to keep out a close range Kidderminster header and the ball then rebounded off Joel Colwill (who made a decent first of playing at right back overall) and trickled into the net.

On the balance of play, City were unlucky to lose. They probably deserved to win actually and I’m not going to get too worked up about the outcome, but what I would say is that, no matter what the excuses, we should really be beating a team from four levels below ua and the lack of an any real sort of end product for the vast majority of the ninety minutes was disappointing given who we were playing against.

I’ll finish by noting that there are two more matches being played on the trip to Austria which will start in just under a week’s time – on 25 July we’ll be playing another Bundesliga 2 team in Hertha Berlin and two days before that, we’ll face Mamelodi Sundowns, the South African Champions on the 23rd.

Posted in Out on the pitch | Tagged , , , , | 6 Comments

Weekly review 6/7/24.

A few things to report this week. For example, those of us who won’t be celebrating our sixtieth birthday again will have noted that the club’s pre season fixture list was completed with a significant game that will have sent us veterans back fifty six years to 1968 as we recall a Semi Final in the European Cup Winners Cup.

Almost certainly unfairly, I have had whatever the opposite of a soft spot is for HSV Hamburg ever since they beat us in the last minute of said Semi Final thanks to a goalkeeping blunder. It’s amazing to think that it all occurred more than half a century ago and I really should be more mature than to let the defeat fester for all of this time, but I’m not and I have to admit that it’s been a source of amusement to me that Hamburg have struggled so long and so unsuccessfully to get out of Bundesliga 2 since they were relegated in 2018 – especially as their City rivals St Pauli were promoted in 23/24.

Historically, Hamburg are one of Germany’s biggest clubs and it really does show that the Championship has a serious rival for the title of Europe’s top second tier in Bundesliga 2 – certainly, in terms of some of the stadiums you’ll find in the respective leagues it does.

There is another link between the teams in that they have both had Robert Glatzel leading their attack in the last five years. – if you looked solely at his record of eleven goals in fifty eight appearances at City compared with his sixty nine in one hundred and nine for Hamburg, you’d conclude that standards are lower at Hamburg.

However, that is to ignore a couple of things, Glatzel is back on native soil with Hamburg and, although I don’t remember anything to suggest he found it a problem to settle at Cardiff, you have to remember that we are a team that, Kieffer Moore apart, strikers tend to struggle to make an impact. Certainly in terms of goals scored ,- I would argue that this is down to the fundamentally defensive outlook that City have had since the time Glatzel played for us, but I say that while admitting that I have become somewhat obsessed lately with what I see as our boring style of play, so maybe I’m overstating things there – what I will say mind about our style and Robert Glatzel during his time with us is that it was not designed to play to his strengths.

All in all, Hamburg should be favourites when we meet them during our Austrian training camp on Sunday 21 July as their usual position near to the top of their strong league is higher than ours has been in our tough division for the last three seasons, but, perhaps, this will be nullified by the fact that it will be our fourth pre season game, we’ll be three weeks off our first league game, whereas it will be five or six weeks for Hamburg.

At under 21 level, things are taking shape with the announcement that twelve Academy youngsters have signed professional deals with the club – this is a few more than you’d expect normally and it tends to back up my view that the club have a very good crop of players around the age of seventeen/eighteen coming through currently, as is evidenced by the fact that two of them have already played for the first team.

The under 21s have already been boosted by the signing of four new players – Griffiths is a former Swansea goalkeeper, Ghabehan was at Port Vale for a portion of last season, Reindorf was, seemingly, very highly rated during his time at Norwich and Pearce had loan spells with Torquay, Weston Super Mare and Dover last season (intriguingly, Soccerbase says he also scored six times while playing twice for Eastbourne on loan, but i suspect that’s a mistake!).

New signings below first level then, but the summer continues to be a non event in terms of signings for the first team with the club denying any interest in either of two Icelandic international full backs who were linked with us last week. That’s it really, apart from some online hints that at least one potential signing is still involved in the Euros, so there won’t be any concrete news on that one until the country (almost certainly Turkey I’d guess if there is something to this rumour) concerned has been eliminated.

It’s also being said by some online that it’s doubtful whether we’ll hear anything positive on new signings before the week in Austria. if true, this is far from ideal because we’ll have played half of our pre season games by then and the time available for integrating them into the squad for the start of the league campaign will be limited.

I’m going to finish with another sport and mention Glamorgan’s incredible tied game against Gloucestershire which ended on Wednesday. There is so much I could write on this game, but I’ll just point out that at lunch on day one, Gloucestershire were 88-8 after being put in by Glamorgan – have a look at the scores from the game to see how it developed from there.

There’s a schoolboy error at the start of the piece, but, otherwise, it’s a decent report on what happened on an incredible last day which saw the action continued right down to the final ball of the final over – in that respect I suppose it was a proper tie.

It was Glamorgan’s first ever tied County Championship match and reminded me of a great book from around forty years ago called Cricket’s Fifty greatest matches (or something very similar to that). It featured reports on fifty games from throughout the game’s history with most of them being played in the County Championship. From memory, Glamorgan featured just the once – it was from the year following that game against Hamburg mentioned earlier when the County Championship title came to Wales for the second time in 1969.

Again, the game went right down to the last ball, with Glamorgan beating Essex by one run thanks to a run out. The win came very late in the season and it made Glamorgan favourites to win the title. Their victory was duly confirmed when they beat Worcestershire at Sophia Gardens a few days later. In terms of significance, the Essex game was the more important given that we seem to be heading for a mid table season this year because we cannot turn draws, or ties, unto wins, but I’d still say that last week’s game was the best in Glamorgan’s long history in the County Championship.

Posted in Cricket, Out on the pitch, The stiffs | Tagged | 5 Comments