There was an interesting thread started on the City messageboard I use this morning (by a Welsh Reading fan of all people!) about this season’s Championship – apparently, the average goals per game is down from something like 2.6 last season to 1.9 something this time around.
I need to qualify what I say about the competition this time around for now, because I’ve watched far less of it than I would normally have done in late October for a variety of reasons, but I wasn’t too surprised at that stat because the games I have seen this season have tended to be very cagey affairs, especially during the first forty five minutes, and, to be honest, they been pretty short of entertainment.
So, by the standards of 20/21 at least, tonight’s 1-1 draw between City and AFC Bournemouth at Cardiff City Stadium represented something of a goal fest and it’s also good to report that it was probably the best Championship game of football I’ve seen so far this season.
Much of the credit for that should go the way of the visitors – Neil Harris has said when asked about our poor recent home results that opposing sides come here these days prepared to sit back and wait for their chance, but Bournemouth had an attacking outlook right from the start of the game and, in truth, probably were just about worth all three points.
However, a depleted and squad rotated City side were in the game throughout and they would have taken heart from picking up a first home point of the season against a good team while showing some promising signs as far as their attacking play was concerned – it was definitely the best I’ve seen us look going forward this term.
The injury which forced Greg Cunningham off early on at Preston on Sunday turned out to be a hamstring strain which will keep him out for a few weeks according to our manager (it meant that Greg was able to provide a very good co commentary of the game on the club’s website though) and, with Joe Bennett still not considered fit enough for a return to first team action, there was a gaping hole at left back. This would probably have been filled by Leandro Bacuna if it wasn’t for the fact that he was needed at right back to replace Jordi Osei-Tutu who was not risked after he went off early at Preston with what was described as a tight hamstring.
Therefore, we were treated to the very rare sight of a former City Academy player starting in a league game for the senior team as Joel Bagan was given the chance to build on a promising performance against Reading in the FA Cup last season and an encouraging loan spell at Notts County which saw him play at Wembley in a Play Off Final against Harrogate.
I’ll come back to Bagan shortly, but, given we were missing three specialist full backs, it was something of a surprise to see both Joe Ralls and Keiffer Moore dropped to the bench as Will Vaulks and Robert Glatzel were given a chance to impress.
I can only assume that, having served his one match ban for his red card at Blackburn, Lee Tomlin must have an injury issue as well because he was not included in our eighteen as Gavin Whyte was given one of the substitute berths.
I mentioned earlier that tonight’s game was the best I’d seen in the Championship this season, but I certainly wasn’t thinking that at half time. While not quite the cagey opening halves that have been the norm in 20/21, it certainly had the same feel as the Sheffield Wednesday and Reading defeats as we struggled to make an impression.
City did cause a sometimes sloppy Bournemouth side a few early problems with an effective high pressing game which saw Sheyi Ojo playing a full part in what I thought was his best showing for us so far.
The visitors looked somewhat uncomfortable in the first fifteen minutes or so as Glatzel kept a couple of members of the three man Bournemouth central defence honest, but they gradually got their bearings and took control to the extent that, while not exactly bombarding the City goal, I’d had that feeling that a goal was coming for a while when they did score.
Back in 13/14 in our first ever Premier League season, we conceded a lot of goals to balls played inside our full backs to release a runner who would then slide a cross in which was invariably converted from close range by an onrushing forward.
Bournemouth’s goal ten minutes before half time was a reminder of what was happening seven seasons ago as the influential Jefferson Lerma slid a pass through the left hand side of City’s defence. Bagan therefore has to accept some responsibility for what happened, but Junior Hoilett had let Jack Stacey go and when the wing back got to the bye line, his low cross picked out Dominic Solanke who netted from the edge of the six yard box.
Bagan’s inexperience did show at times, but, overall, it was a good first league game for the youngster we picked up a couple of seasons ago from Southampton. Indeed, on yet another occasion where our passing compared somewhat unfavourably with our opponents, the Scottish youth international took the eye with some thoughtful and composed contributions while also generally defending effectively.
City had to survive a rocky start to the second half when a second Bournemouth goal would have, surely, meant curtains for them. They also needed some luck when Solanke found himself in a similar type of position to where he had been in scoring at the opposite end of the pitch – this time Smithies denied him by brilliantly diverting the shot on to the crossbar and out.
City reacted well to this escape – Harry Wilson, who impressed with his ability to find pockets of space for himself, fired in a free kick from twenty yards that keeper Asmir Begovic had to tip onto and over the bar to follow up on a first half effort just wide from the edge of the penalty area which represented our only really close effort in the first forty five minutes..
Begovic then had to push a Vaulks header over and Curtis Nelson missed a presentable chance when he headed wide from an unmarked position beyond the far post.
City were having their best spell of the match and their high pressing game bore fruit when Ojo and Hoilett forced an error from the Bournemouth rearguard and the latter was able to burst clear of Stacey and cross towards the edge of the penalty area where an onrushing Wilson showed good technique to send his low twenty yard shot wide of the keeper and into the net to record a goal on his first start for his new club.
With still almost half an hour to play, I felt the game was there for the winning by City, but, in truth, they could never really recapture the intensity they had shown in the ten minutes or so before their equalizer and on both of the occasions when a decisive goal nearly came in the remainder of the match, it was the visitors who were denied – first as a free kick by Junior Stanislas crashed back off the crossbar with Smithies completely beaten and then an unmarked Solanke headed about a foot wide from a position where he really should have netted.
Moore, Ralls and Josh Murphy were all introduced, but the promising fluency that the front four had shown when we were able to get the ball to them had gone now and, although some of Bournemouth’s defending had a last ditch look to it throughout the ninety minutes really – only three efforts on target by City rather told a story in terms of an attacking end product.
What was promising though was that, on this evidence, Wilson is potentially that player who can provide ten plus goals in a season if he stays fit – he made what was certainly no sitter look easy for his goal and his ability to find space just in front of the visiting defence made him the sort of target which even our passing was bound to connect with at times.
I should also mention that a very young Under 23 side were beaten 1-0 at Sheffield Wednesday earlier in the week which means that their run of consecutive defeats to begin the season now stretches to four and that it is seven losses from eight matches for our Development and Academy sides which is a shade ironic on the day that a teenager finally comes up through the ranks to start a Championship match for the club!
Can I also remind you about my recently published book Real Madrid and all that which is available in e book and paperback formats and can only be purchased from Amazon.
Here are the reviews which have been posted on Amazon about the book so far;-
“As the quintessential Blogmeister with his “Mauve and Yellow Army” Paul Evans has been producing comprehensive and incisive reports on Cardiff City performances for a number of years. His capacity for a staggering amount of hard work and constantly fair-minded comments which characterise his writings are equally apparent in this new book. It revives so many pleasant memories of times gone by and will inevitably appeal primarily to the nostalgia of an older generation. Yet it has much to interest not only Cardiff City supporters of all ages but also anyone with an interest in professional football in general — including my wife whose favourite, back in the day, was John Toshack.”
“A great read about a very average football club having one of its more memorable seasons. I will admit to being a Cardiff follower and have followed the author through his blog and on a message board some I am somewhat biased. However, this is an interesting and engaging read throughout and certainly brings back memories of my first year as a season ticket holder. Unlike the team this book does not let you down and I throughly recommend it regardless of what team you follow .”
“Another excellent piece of work from Paul. I’m just old enough to remember this and saw about half a dozen of the games during the season that I can remember. I didn’t get to see the Real Madrid game (it was a school night and my father didn’t want to take me) but this has been a great opportunity to refresh many of the other stories. What gives added value are the extra bits included from paper cuttings that also give a falvour of the time – especially the bit about the building of the A470. A great read!”
“As a lifelong Cardiff city supporter, I found this book really fascinating. The author is obviously a keen supporter himself, but he has put into words a whole wealth of information. Well done”
“My father is 75 this year and always says ‘I was there when City beat Real Madrid’. A great book and a trip down memory lane for those City fans who can remember.”
and
“Reports on each match of City’s most eventful season to date. Good background stuff about life at that time as well.”
Once again, can I finish by making a request for support from readers by them becoming my Patrons through Patreon. Full details of this scheme and the reasons why I decided to introduce it can be found here, but I should say that the feedback I have got in the past couple of years has indicated a reluctance from some to use Patreon as they prefer to opt for a direct payment to me. If you are interested in becoming a patron and would prefer to make a direct contribution, please contact me at paul.evans8153@hotmail.com or in the Feedback section of the blog and I will send you my bank/PayPal details.
–
Two eminent Victorians who were born and died at virtually the same time were denied by chronology, among other factors, from having the opportunity to be Cardiff City supporters, but each (in my opinion) produced important slogans that reflect Cardiff’s performances last night.
Charles Darwin, while noting that humans were not descended from apes even though they had a common ancestry, developed the idea of “the missing link.” This could certainly be applied to Cardiff last night. Something was missing, whether due to tactics, team selection, or the continued lack of creativity and passing accuracy from the Cardiff team.
Benjamin Disraeli once announced that there are “thee kinds of lies — lies, damned lies, and statistics.” The vital one goal each as well as all the other statistics from last night’s game were totally truthful, and highlight a game in which Cardiff were incredibly lucky to avoid a major defeat. That being said, some individual performances were very good. Glatzel had a fluidity of movement and got his head to several high balls which showed what he is capable of, provided he gets the right support,. Harry Wilson showed flashes of brilliance and took his goal with a welcome amount of skill. It was good to see Bagan given an opportunity to claim a regular place as a left back. Above all, however, it was the bravery of Smithies that, for me at least, made him “man of the match”.
Despite everything I cherish the hope that displays will improve as the season unfolds.
Good afternoon Paul – An entertaining game as you report, and I suspect that the result pleased our Manager more than our opponents boss as I too felt they shaded affairs. So at something before 10 p.m. last night, I was comforted by the fact that we have secured our first home point. Three more on Saturday will add greatly to my disposition.
Young Bagan was an adequate replacement, and I wonder if any of your devotees are able to remember the last time we fielded a teenager in a league match. I anticipate a deluge of replies.
I thought Glatzel did quite well, but he does need to move more quickly to put himself in front of defenders when the occasional ball is centred, and it is an occasional ball. Whereas Moore is capable of that, he does not yet receive the service that his particular talent deserves, and old fashioned wing play is something that Mr.Harris and Co must work on.
I think Wilson probably had the City’s most attempts on goal, so it was only just that it was he that secured our equaliser with a smart strike. Playing in a position that may be a little unfamiliar to him, he was our most dangerous attacker, and linked with Ojo quite well. It may not become a permanent position for him, but with Tomlin possibly side-lined, I would be happy to see the two Liverpool loanees given a few more outings together.
As I have stated on more than one occasion, it is difficult to defend against pace, and our central duo had a more difficult time last night with the Bournemouth attacks than on Sunday. But with super Smithies behind them, the fact that we conceded just the one goal was solely down to our keeper’s heroics. He certainly justified the decision to let Etheridge depart.
As and when all of our squad are fit and available for selection, I would find it difficult to name a starting eleven. To some extent that must depend upon who are the opponents, but it would be interesting to know if we have a preferred eleven. At this early stage of the season, I am not sure that I could.
Thanks Paul. Spot on as ever!
After our promising start our pressing eased off and Bournemouth looks very comfortable moving the ball cleverly and at pace. Their goal was well constructed with slide rule passing which was impressive . I genuinely thought we were going to be thrashed and outplayed.
That we grabbed a draw and fought well in the second half was due to a real collective spirit and increasing confidence.
As both yourself and BJA have commented, Wilson was a diamond and has real quality. He and Ojo looked to link up and he does seem to find that pocket of space – as well as a wand of a left foot ( Whitmanesque!)
Solid defending again in the main although I agree that Bournemouth should really have secured the points with their second half chances, although denied by super Smithies.
Great to see Bagan given a chance and sure he learnt a lot – tough debut against a quality team.
I assumed Bournemouth would be a bit flat after relegation and selling a number of top players – as well as returning loanees. However, they demonstrated all the good footballing qualities from their better Premier League performances and sure they will be knocking on the door come season end.
Happy to take the point in the end. Just need to get that home win monkey off the back against Mr W on Saturday now!
Afternoon everyone and, as always, thanks for the replies. Anthony, as always for now at least, I have to qualify what I say about City this season with a reminder that I’ve seen very little of them and Wednesday was my first chance to see them in action at home, but I did think the radio commentaries I listened to for the first two matches at Cardiff City Stadium told a clear story and, after thinking that we were in for more of the same at half time against Bournemouth, I was pleasantly surprised by what happened after the break – luck was certainly on our side and Smithies (who came close to keeping out the goal) was my choice for man of the match as well.
BJA, I think Mark Harris might be the answer to the question you ask – you were right to stipulate league matches, because there has been such a big difference between them and cup matches when it came to selection at City for almost ten years now. After making his debut in an FA Cup match against Fulham I believe it was in 2017, Harris was picked for a meaningless game at Wigan right at the back end of the 16/17 season and I cannot think of anyone since then. I don’t know of you saw Neil Harris, post match interview, but he confirmed that Tomlin was injured and he thought it likely he’d be absent as well against Middlesbrough, but he was hopeful he’d be available for the upcoming away matches. I agree it is difficult to name a preferred eleven at the moment, but here’s my take on;-
Smithies
Osei-Tutu
Morrison
Nelson
Bennett
Ralls
Bacuna
Hoilett
Wilson
Ojo
Moore
This time last week, I would have not had Ojo in that team, but I think he’s done well in the last two games and I do wonder if we’re duty bound to pick him for a certain number of games?
Huw, although I thought Bournemouth were a little careless at times and needed to resort to last ditch defending a lot, I was pretty impressed by them as well and I think a fit and firing David Brooks would be one of the best players in this division. As for tomorrow’s match, it has the look of a very tight affair to me possibly decided by a single goal either way – until a week ago, I would have given us little chance if, as seems likely, Tomlin is not there, but Wilson changes things – I thought he was, understandably, a little quiet on Sunday, but he looked like a Premier League player on Wednesday and a pretty good one at that.
Hi Paul.
I am going to buy your book and read it with a sense of regret that most City fans of that age still have.
I was living in Wick (lots of Bluebirds in that little village then) at the time and I can still remember as we drove into Llantwit Major to do some shopping, my older brother telling me we had sold John Toshak to Liverpool, I just burst into tears..I was 8 years old so that reaction was allowed.
Hello Paul, good to hear from you and I hope you enjoy the book. You touch upon something which I don’t think those who weren’t around when Toshack was sold fully realise – it was a huge event and I cannot remember another transfer like it in terms of its long term impact. There’s quite a long chapter dedicated solely to the Toshack sale in the book and I could have written a lot more on it – reading through the old editions of the Western Mail, Echo and Football Echo really brought home the size of the impact it had, I bet you weren’t the only eight year old to cry when they first heard the news and I suspect there were plenty who were a lot older than you who reacted the same way!