Cardiff City fell to a predictable home defeat tonight against third placed Burnley, but not really in the manner they were expected to. Burnley, the team that don’t concede goals are going to miss out on automatic promotion by failing to turn enough of their numerous goalless draws into 1-0 wins if they finish the season in their current position, so the predictions beforehand tended to favour a 1-0 win for the visitors, with City being given a chance of earning a goalless draw.
In the event, it was a much more open game than expected and, although it’s little consolation in defeat, City scored the first league goal against the Lancastrians in a whopping 1,132 minutes, they also hit the woodwork twice and should have scored a late equaliser as they missed badly from inside the six yard box.
For all of that though, Burnley created a lot more chances than they did back in August when they somehow beat us 5-0 and there was a desperation to much of City’s defending in the first hour of the game. It needed some good saves and last ditch blocks to keep the score down before we finished strongly and pegged Burnley back for much of the last twenty five minutes or so.
Burnley’s defending wasn’t as good as I expected it to be, but I’m thinking of what I’ll call traditional defending there because they were very good and organized with their pressing.
It’s to City’s credit therefore that Burnley must have been relieved to hear the final whistle – I wouldn’t deny the visitors their win, they deserved it over the ninety minutes, but it still felt like City could have got a second goal if the match had gone on for another ten minutes and at least, after five feeble defeats to the current top four with an aggregate score of 0-18, we managed to give one of them a decent game at the sixth attempt.
Im sure I wasn’t the only one caught out by Omer Riza’s tactics from the start as what looked for all of the world like a three at the back selection with wing backs became a 4-2-3-1 with Andy Rinomhota and Joel Bagan full backs, Perry Ng partnering Dimi Goutas in central defence, Sivert Mannsverk paired with Calum Chambers in central midfield, Cian Ashford on the right, Alex Robertson playing centrally and Callum O’Dowda given something of a roving commission behind Yousef Salech.
Will Fish and Ruben Colwill were two members of the team that played at Villa Park on Friday with good reason to feel hard done by after their omissions from tonight’s starting line up and the fact Riza introduced them both at half time for Rinomhota and Robertson is something of an admission that he’d got the original selection wrong.
City had defended pretty well in their previous three games, but I’m afraid tonight was a return to their woes at the back which have haunted all season.They were poor defensively in the first forty five minutes during which all of the goals were scored with the one which turned out to be the winner being a shockingly bad one to concede.
Three goals in a first half is almost unheard of at Cardiff City Stadium these days and so it doesn’t take much figuring out to realise this was one of the best first periods seen at the ground in months. City had begun in bright fashion and Ng’s cross was collected by James Trafford with his feet well behind the goal line, but his hands the right side of said line.
Burnley had moved the ball about quite slickly, but when they scored on eighteen minutes it was from their first serious attack as City’s season long problem preventing crosses from their right resurfaced as Hannibal get clear down that side and pulled the ball across for captain Josh Brownhill to score from eight yards out – there was a slight deflection off Ng, but I’m sure the shot would have gone in anyway.
Burnley now took control, but it was City who came closest to scoring in the next twenty minutes or so when O’Dowda clipped a great ball in and Salech, stood close to the penalty spot, stretched to divert the ball on to the outside of the post with Trafford beaten.
Zian Flemming missed a great chance to double the lead as he climbed unmarked to meet another cross from our right, but headed well wide from eight yards.
The Dutchman did better with his head five minutes before the break when he was left totally free on the far post to head across goal to where defender Maxine Estevan, equally unmarked, tapped in from about three yards out – again, the danger came from the right and there was little effort made to try and close Josh Cullen down as he crossed.
Given Burnley’s defensive record, it definitely felt like game over when the ball hit our net for the second time, but within a couple of minutes, O’Dowda did really well to win possession on the edge of the Burnley’s penalty area and Bagan’s cross was headed in at the far post by Salech who was giving his best performance for the club so far as he enjoyed an aerial superiority over the visiting centrebacks throughout.
For a minute or two in the second half, City pushed Burnley back, but they soon recovered their poise and I’m still not sure how we came through the next 15 minutes or so without conceding again – Ethan Horvarth made two good saves and there were a couple of decent looking penalty appeals turned down as our goal led something of a charmed life.
I was disappointed to see Ashford and Bagan withdrawn as I thought they’d both been among our best players, but the introduction of Callum Robinson and Anwar El-Ghazi as well as Aaron Ramsey for Mannsverk saw us improve as a team and we gained an element of control for the first time in the game.
Chances were still hard to come by though – Robinson’s good cross was headed on to the top of the bar and over by the impressive Salech, but the big chance came in the five minutes of added time when Goutas headed on to fellow centreback Fish who screwed his shot from the corner of the six yard box across goal and wide to send City to their first home defeat since the game before Christmas, which also happened to be the last time our opponents had conceded a goal in the Championship.
As I mentioned earlier, I thought the score was just about right, but there are plenty who thought we merited a draw with our stronger finish and, overall, it was a performance that makes me more confident we can stay up, but the obvious caveat is that we cannot afford to keep on giving away such soft goals.
Although the final ball and finishing still isn’t all that it should be, I feel this is the best attacking side we’ve had for three or four seasons, but the accusation that we are as poor in defence as we have been for a generation is a damning one with some merit to it I would say.Ability wise and on an individual basis, I don’t think we’re that bad, but we seem to have problems concentrating and we’re not as organised as most City defences since we were promoted in 2003.
A defeat for Plymouth by 2-0 at Hull sends the Humberside club above us again, but I’d say it wasn’t a bad outcome for us as we remain ahead of twenty second placed Luton by five points which is a handy gap to have over the bottom trio at this stage of the season. Clearly, Luton’s visit to Cardiff next Tuesday could see us taking a huge step towards safety, but, if things take a turn for the worse and we drop back into the bottom three, it’ll be substandard defending, more than anything else, that puts us there.
It was also a 2-1 defeat for the under 21s who played poorly this afternoon at home to a Millwall side who played the second half with ten men following what I thought was a very harsh red card shown to one of their defenders just before half time. Millwall were leading 1-0 at the time with a soft goal scored from a header from a corner, but City were given a lifeline by a penalty award given for a foul on Trey George as he dived to head a Luey Giles cross – the decision looked a correct one, but it was a real surprise to see a red card being shown to the culprit as well.
Mannie Barton’s underhit penalty was saved by the Millwall keeper and the visitors doubled their lead soon after the restart with another simple goal.
City struggled to find any fluency even with a man advantage, George did get a goal back when he took advantage of a mistake to round the keeper and finish well, but, apart from a shot against the post by Raheem Conte, Millwall saw the game out with few alarms.
Thanks as ever Paul.
I predicted at the start if the season we would go down. I see no reason to change my thinking. I cannot think of another Championship squad that player for player is patently weaker than ours.
We so need a right back and a ‘Keegan’ to play off our ‘Toshack’. I genuinely think that Salech is our best buy since Mark McGuinness. Whether Robbo is that man, I have my doubts. I see him as a sub to be brought on in the 6oth minute. What sayest thou, Paul?
Could Davies be that man?
One thing for sure… we need no kamikaze football in our own third… but we want to play the game in theirs. We need O’Dowda and A.N.Other to play the crosses aimed at his head.
Let’s see him give Mark McGuinness a testing time aerially next week.
And mentioning Mark… how Goutas is nowhere near the player he was with him alongside.
So lucky to escape that penalty for his tackle in the first half last night.
TTFN,
Dai.
Out and out strikers have become “luxury” players in the modern game Dai where managers and coaches dictate how a team p;lays moreso than in any other time of my football watching life. The system is everything and every player out there has their full share of defensive responsibilities. The first team I can remember playing with one striker as a matter of course was David Pleat’s Spurs team that was beaten by Coventry in the 1987 Cup Final – they had Clive Allen who from memory scored nearly fifty goals that season, but Pleat, who was considered a progressive manager with an attacking outlook, had some very attack minded players in the midfield five operating behind Allen and Spurs scored plenty of goals that season even if they did not win anything, The problem came when others started to im imitate Spurs’ formation, but did not have the players with the skill set to get the best out of such a system.
It’s the same with “false number nines” – Spain were the first team to play what was essentially 4-6-0 and got away with it because they were the best team in the world at the time, but, not too long after, you had Craig Levein playing it in a vital qualifying game for his Scotland team, which was predictably lost 1-0 to hasten what was eventually Levein’s sacking.
My point is that most genuinely new systems seem to involve less and less specialist strikers. There are some teams around who still play with a genuine front two , but not many and so a Toshack, Keegan type partnership is almost unheard of these days which kind of makes me think someone should try it to see how defences used to having to deal with one striker would cope.
I agree with you that if we were to go down the Toshack/Keegan type route, then Isaak Davies seems the player in our squad to be the Keegan to Salech’s Toshack, but I’d be amazed if it happened – Salech’s arrival has caused something of a conundrum though as, rarely for us, we have a striker who made it into double figures for league goals in January and we are now having trouble getting him into the team! The best cross Salech received on Tuesday from one of our wide attacking players was the one he headed against the crossbar from Callum Robinson, but I’m not sure where you play him if Salech is starting – maybe as a number ten type operating slightly behind the striker, but we tried something like that recently and it didn’t work.
I don’t think Sunderland away is the game to do it on, but maybe we should try an olf fashioned 4-4-2 when we play Luton next week with Salech and Robinson up front and Davies ready to come on for Robbo late on?